My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

Would this annoy you? My mum always makes out that DH and I are poor

113 replies

MoonBabyMoonBaby · 04/10/2016 16:26

DH and I both have decently paid jobs and a comfortable lifestyle. My Dsis and her husband both have jobs of a similar nature/pay and enjoy a comfortable lifestyle too. My Dsis has always been favoured by my mum.

My mum constantly makes comments making out that DH and I are poor and that my sister and BIL are not poor. For example we have decorated our living room in the past few weeks and bought new furniture. I spoke to my mum on the phone last night and she said we'd done well decorating it especially since we "Only have DH's and my earnings coming in". I said we both earn a decent salary but she just ignored me. We get comments like this ALL THE TIME! It infuriates me. She will then in the next breath start talking about what a good job my sister has and about how they can afford expensive things.

She also, all the time goes on and on about how she hates the benefits system but doesn't mind paying into the system at the moment as DH and I apparently get benefits. We get no benefits at all, not even child benefit, and no matter how many times I re-iterate that we don't get any benefits she still seems to think that we do.

She also quizzes me all the time about everything that the DCs and I wear, asking if it's new and how much did it cost, and making comments like "I don't know, all these new clothes, wasting money that you don't have", even when we are not wearing anything new at all and I've never ever said to her that I spend money that we don't have.

AIBU to be pissed off with these comments?

OP posts:
Report
EbyBum · 04/10/2016 19:45

My husband's Aunt dropped round a used roll on deodorant and a towel that a house guest left behind last week.

Report
AyeAmarok · 04/10/2016 19:46

She also, all the time goes on and on about how she hates the benefits system but doesn't mind paying into the system at the moment as DH and I apparently get benefits. We get no benefits at all, not even child benefit, and no matter how many times I re-iterate that we don't get any benefits she still seems to think that we do.

This is seriously bizarre! Confused

Report
Mysticstar13 · 04/10/2016 20:15

Sounds like my neighbours, because they very rarely see us come in or out, I work online and the hubby works night shifts, plus it fits in with school runs and stuff, one of our neighbours has decided that we are nothing but benefit scrounges that don't deserve to live or have a family and be happy, in 15yrs of living at our house we have never spoken or socialised in any shape or form with any of them. Yet they have taken it upon them selfs to cause us as much grief as they can possibly do. The name calling I could cope with but things got nasty mainly them starting on us at every chance they could

Report
Laiste · 04/10/2016 20:19

nina - she actually makes stuff up about my children when they were little and tells me as if she is their parent.

Shock MY mother does this! She did it recently; told one of my DDs how she remembers her not managing to get to the loo in time a lot when she was little (DD is now 18 btw).

DD was Confused i was Hmm. It's just not worth the struggle. We laugh about it when she's out of earshot.

Report
BravingSpring · 04/10/2016 20:35

I'm (fairly recently) a single parent, my DM and PIL and most of the world it appears assumes I'm now destitute.

I'm not rolling in money but have a decent salary, above the national average full time wage for part time hours. I don't qualify for any benefits except child benefit and a single adult discount on my council tax, but because I'm now labelled as a single parent I must be struggling and must be claiming something. Drives me mad.

Report
CoolCarrie · 04/10/2016 20:47

I know how you feel, it is a pain in the arse! I get it from mil & my own mum, i think it is 50% bloody noseyness and 50% bloody jealousy from both. My mil even got her 12 yr old niece to ask my parents how much our wedding had cost, not once but three fucking times, despite the fact that it had fuck all to do with her. She asked her sil how much they had spent on their twins 21st party, how much was the girl's dress, all at the party, in front of other people, it was so embarrassing, I was cringing. Now I don't tell either of them any thing any more, can't be arsed with the how much!!?

Report
3luckystars · 04/10/2016 20:51

I bet you anything she does the same to your sister. Ask her.

Report
T0ldmywrath · 04/10/2016 20:56

People are strange that's for sure!

My dmum has never ever commented on money or lack thereof. She is just glad that her children are content/happy in their jobs and lives.

However, she has the idea that one of my siblings is getting divorced- not true at all (Dmum is in the early stages of Alzheimers) Sad

Report
crayfish · 04/10/2016 20:57

I read a thing recently that in families you are stuck being the person that everyone else thinks you are and no matter what you do you can't change it. I think there's some truth to that. In your family you are the 'poor' one and despite all the evidence to the contrary, that's who they think you are.

In my family I am 'the one that holds a grudge' even though I don't think I have ever held a grudge in my life. It's all 'oh don't get on the wrong side of Crayfish!' and stuff - very bizarre.

Report
KayTee87 · 04/10/2016 21:04

Hmm this sounds a bit odd. My 94 year old grandpa does things like that - makes up stuff basically. His memory is awful.

Report
schokolade · 04/10/2016 21:15

FIL is weird about money too. When DH and I got engaged, his reaction was "how much was the ring?". Wtf?!

DH and I are academics. Most of our extended families think we are STILL students Grin. "Oh schokolade, how is your course going? Must be nearly finished eh". I can only assume they think we are terrible students to still be slogging away at the same degree a good 15 years later, humph.

Report
Greengager · 04/10/2016 21:22

I think your mum has a narrative in her head about you and your sister which no evidence to the contrary will dislodge. My MiL does this to an extent seizing on anything that might support her theory and ignoring everything that doesn't fit.

Report
ShiftyLookingBadger · 04/10/2016 21:25

Is your mum a crayon short of a full pack?

Report
rollonthesummer · 04/10/2016 21:32

Why would she think you are on benefits?

Report
bibbitybobbityyhat · 04/10/2016 21:35

"poster AyeAmarok Tue 04-Oct-16 19:46:18
She also, all the time goes on and on about how she hates the benefits system but doesn't mind paying into the system at the moment as DH and I apparently get benefits. We get no benefits at all, not even child benefit, and no matter how many times I re-iterate that we don't get any benefits she still seems to think that we do.

This is seriously bizarre! confused"

I agree AyeAmorak. See my earlier post about the mum thinking the dd doesn't have a job.

Infact I think it is so bizarre, op is leaving something out, or she should be posting in Elderly Parents or Mental Health for advice rather than AIBU. Because of course she is NBU to find some of those things her mum says seriously concerning

Report
CauliflowerSqueeze · 04/10/2016 21:40

Just keep turning it round.
"Oh mum I've been a bit worried about your finances- that cardigan is quite old isn't it? Are you worried about your pension? The local school is supporting help the aged in their harvest festival - do you want me to have a quiet word?"

Report
StealthPolarBear · 04/10/2016 21:41

I love " I tend to see her about four times a year. I don't always wear the same t-shirt for it." :o

Report
Flywheel · 04/10/2016 21:48

We get this from MIL. It's bizarre. I think part of it the role she has in her head for dh as others have mentioned. Also our house is small apparently - it really isn't, but we live in expensive part of the country compared to other relatives. There's absolutely no convincing her that we are doing fine.

Report
Damia · 04/10/2016 22:11

I wonder exactly what jobs you all have? maybe they have one she thinks of as high earners like lawyers or something, and you have ones which are classes in her mind as lower earners, even if the reality is different.

Report
M0nstersinthecl0set · 04/10/2016 22:24

My mum is one for constantly implying my house is too small for our needs. This house might be smaller than her current one, but still larger than the house I grew up in (that she said was large enough and she'd never take on more cleaning Hmm). Ok, I have one more child now than she ever had. But we have two extra rooms.
But it's great, I'm never prevailed upon to host parties etc (we have lots of family get togethers) because of my "too small" house. My brother was even expected to host in his (lovely) 2 bed flat. But I'm the one with space problems for some reason!
I just help with the odd dishwasher load / make a dish of food and never have the big effort. I secretly delight in it.

Report
AmeliaJack · 04/10/2016 22:52

M0nsters that seems like an excellent deal to me!

A relative of ours made some extremely rude comments when we moved to a much larger house. The comments implied that the mortgage must be at the very maximum we could afford and we must be really stretched. In fact the bank would have lent us twice as much. She'd be furious if she knew what we earn. Fortunate as we've been refusing to tell her for 20 years she has no idea. Smile

Report
manandbeast · 04/10/2016 23:22

The lack of empathy on this thread amazes me.

Your elders are probably thrifty because of the legacy of growing up with relatively little (even if they were relatively well off) and the sense that we should be careful (even if we don't necessarily need to be now, we might in the future). Scarcity used to be a real thing in our culture.

Do all you well off folk receiving these insulting vouchers / offers of support from your family really not get that???

Fml

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

bibbitybobbityyhat · 05/10/2016 00:47

You seem to be on the wrong thread manandbeast because what you have said has no relevance to this discussion. I'm not sure you've even read the op! But this thread is not about "elders" being "thrifty" in any way. Sorry you feel so strongly about an internet thread (that you haven't really understood) that you actualy think "fuck my life"

Report
AmeliaJack · 05/10/2016 00:54

man
In our case it's actually nothing to do with that. The relative concerned coveted the fact that they were the wealthiest ones in the family. Until we moved house they had no idea that our earnings had risen to such an extent and noses were rather out out of joint.

Regardless of cause though, I'm a responsible adult. I'm not wasteful and save appropriately. I don't expect to be subject to snarky, hurtful remarks about a house that my DH and I have decided we can afford.

I'm not a child and don't expect to be treated like one. No one in my family would dream of commenting on how we spend our money.

Report
Meeep · 05/10/2016 01:15

Weird, we get the opposite of this from my in laws.
They go on about how successful DH is, not like his siblings (their families are all - in reality - doing equally well, just average, like us!)
They've given big presents to the siblings to help them out, cars, holidays, money for deposits when moving etc.
I don't really get where it comes from! DH finds it a bit uncomfortable, like a pressure from them.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.