Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give my Friends With Benefits relationship a chance?

34 replies

Itsgettingbetter · 27/09/2016 11:15

Long time lurker, first post.

It's been going on, on and off, for five years. And he hates when I say we "are just friends who have sex" - he says he loves me but I keep saying I don't think we would work as a proper couple. But I'm not the best judge of such things. Am socially awkward and tend to make misjudgements. Am wondering if I may be overlooking something potentially very good and solid?

I'm a single parent in my mid-thirties, 1 DS, age 10, currently doing a PhD with a scholarship. He is a divorced creative, nearly 50. 2 grown up DCs, doesn't make much money. However, he is gentle, kind, wise, supportive and patient. He is tall with unusual looks but has attractive features and looks after himself. He keeps his home beautifully, gives me tips on how to decorate mine and cooks for me when I visit. He is opinionated, political and clever. We both share a sweet tooth, the same sex drive and sex with him is the best I've had. We are both introverts and awkward as hell, but somewhat comfy together.

But there are issues: he is quite anal as well as a bit old fashioned in regards to parenting so realistically I don't think we could live together until DS is at least 18 and has his own life. I'm not sure if I would have another child but definitely would not have one with him as our approaches would be completely different. Also we are both currently renting and I am planning to work towards owning my own home - he is not interested in such things. He would support it but not actively help. He sometimes struggles financially so I would have to fund things like trips, whether to the theatre or a holiday. We are both quite solitary people and are not an integral part of each others lives.

Often I get fed up and start considering online dating or see an attractive man and wonder could be in store for me, if I was brave enough to step away. Could the grass really be greener elsewhere?

OP posts:
MargaretCavendish · 27/09/2016 12:48

I'm wondering what you mean about 'not being sure what love means' and the fact you expect to 'feel excited by the sight iof him'. Aftyer 5 years, some people are still in that phase but a hell of a lot of other people have moved on from that. Still fancying each other but not in that way iyswim?

But they never went through that 'phase'! It's surely a very different thing to have had those feelings but be feeling more 'settled and cosy' now, and never having had those feelings at all?

Vintagegirl1 · 27/09/2016 12:50

I would end the fwb things. Someone of 50 who hardly earns and has no interest in owning their own home is not a good catch. Stop sleeping with him,you are giving him false hope.

Itsgettingbetter · 27/09/2016 12:55

Thanks for your messages they have really made me think. My intention wasn't be unfair to him but I can see that's what I have been.

How do I break it off? Do I have to stop seeing him (as I never practice restraint when I do?) Speaking to him even? It's so hard trying to be celibate during the winter!

OP posts:
OhhBetty · 27/09/2016 13:06

I think you both need to move on and find people who you love and who love you back. Fwb only works if you're both on the same page.
Just be honest and tell him how you feel. If you wanta proper relationship you should cut him loose.

LetsJunglyJumpToIt · 27/09/2016 13:10

Agree with the above. You need to stop seeing each other and move on. You are stringing him along. You know he's interested yet you continue to sleep with him which keeps the hope going that one day you'll change your mind, and that's not fair.

If your gut feeling is you don't want a relationship then that's the right thing. Don't be with him because it's comfortable, don't settle. That's not fair on either of you as it won't work long term.

maggiethemagpie · 27/09/2016 13:16

If you're not feeling it, you're not feeling it OP

If you were feeling it, you'd know. You couldn't NOT know.

The absence of any strong feelings for this man means he's not the one for you.

dontwannapullahammie · 27/09/2016 13:17

You need to stop messing with his head. He is in love with you, probably infatuated, and he will never be able to make the break himself. You are being very cruel to him ending it and then going back, multiple times. He is not your safe option and he deserves more than you just settling for him

FlyingElbows · 27/09/2016 13:41

Op read these words you've written again

Trustworthy
Dependable
Safe
Sensible
Very good friendship

Those are the building blocks and foundation of every successful relationship. You're not friends with benefits, you're in an actual relationship with this man. If you don't want to be then cut him free.

OliviaStabler · 27/09/2016 18:35

Hi OliviaS, by old fashioned I mean an attitude of expecting children almost to be seen and not heard, and wanting unquestioning obedience

Sounds like quite a difference of opinion.

I would have to agree with Vintagegirl1. Walk away. Life is too short and you don't get a second chance.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread