Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think people's mental health is a private matter?

27 replies

DrSeuss · 12/09/2016 09:04

On the one hand, I do think that we need to be more open about these things. You wouldn't hide the fact that you had a physical illness so why hide the fact that you have a mental health issue? On the other, I know from experience that I have to be careful who I tell about my previous bouts of depression as some people are not at all sympathetic, some will use the information against you and some just plain don't understand.

I recently stopped off at my MIL's on the way home from a visit to a friend who has suffered at times from depression so bad that she cannot work or sometimes even function normally. Thankfully, at present, she is feeling a lot better although is still unwell. My MIL has met this friend a handful of times and last spoke to her at my son's second birthday party. My son is now ten, so that was quite a while ago. During my visit she asked me a couple of times about my friend and how she was. Both times I replied, "Fine." I was very unwilling to say more as my friend had not authorised me to do so and my MIL barely knows her! Also, MIL has a deserved reputation for being unable to keep her mouth shut.

She later asked me again on the 'phone and I again said, "Fine." and told her quite bluntly that she had now asked me three times and that was all I was ever going to say. She then did her usual thing when challenged about her nosiness in telling me that I was unreasonable and that she was just displaying concern. For someone she last spoke to eight years ago. On a very sensitive topic. Yeah right.

AIBU in thinking that I am not at fault, despite her best efforts to persuade me otherwise? She knows that my friend has depression and she was after detail. I asked my friend what I should have said and she told me to just say that she does a lot of handicrafts at present. There will be a next time. AIBU in feeling that this is less about concern than voyeurism?

OP posts:
GloriousGoosebumps · 12/09/2016 14:57

Good on you for calling your mil on her nosiness. Quite why people who are simply being nosy believe that everyone else is too stupid to see their real motivation escapes me, however, you're calling her nosy to her face must have been a bit of a shock!

harderandharder2breathe · 12/09/2016 15:51

If you were talking in confidence to someone because you needed support to help support your friend, and it was someone you trusted not to repeat it and ideally not a mutual friend, that's ok imo

Anyone just looking for gossip should be brushed off though

I'm relatively open about suffering from anxiety and depression in general conversation but struggle to discuss how I'm feeling when I'm unwell especially. I'm having to at the moment to access support at work, and talking about anxiety is causing further anxiety Hmm (at myself)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page