Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if PIL will do something for DS' birthday

35 replies

cjt110 · 13/07/2016 12:55

-Am setting background out so as not to dripfeed - some may be irrelevant-

My DS turns 2 next month. PIL are currently hosting 5 year old nephew from June-August, on his own - SIL and family live in another non-English speaking country. MIL flew to their home, stayed a week or two and brought DN back with her for the summer. It is DN's birthday 2 days before my sons. We have arranged to go down from a Mon-Weds, the Tues being DN's birthday and the Thurs (when we are at home) is DS' birthday. This arrangement came off the back of MIL saying a while ago (could be as long ago as Christmas) that we should go down in August as DN is over and she can put a party on for both DN and DS.

PIL live 150 miles from us and generally only see us if we travel down there and stay in a hotel or they are on a trip to our area, where we then have to travel to them and see them for the day.

MIL spends alot of time abroad with SIL and herself says it's never a holiday as she always helps SIL with little jobs around the village such as cleaning houses, looks after SILs children whilst SIL is out etc.

MIL sends parcels to SIL for things such as Easter - The country she lives in doesn not celebrate it - with gifts for the children. We have had one or two parcels in the past that have had a hand knitted garment but nothing really to note.

DS for christmas and his birthday got lovely gifts from MIL from Mothercare and ELC.

MIL's facebook at the moment is documenting DN's trip and there are daily updates as to what he is doing. Some are trips to the park etc but some are tacking him away for a week in this country, some are taking him to football matches (local kids ones, not proper ones).

Would you set your expectation of our trip as low so as not to be disappointed, or would you feel a bit if something isn't laid on/done? I know, for example, my Mum has bought DS a play kitchen and accessories and we are pkanning to have a little garden party (me, dh, dm, df and ds) on his birthday at her house, weather permitting.

It could just be that some GPs are closer to one set of GC than the other - My DS being closer to my parents as they live 5 mins away and he is there 3 days a week and the DN and DN being closer to PIL - I just am not sure what to expect and whether to be a bit cross if nothing is done to mark the joint birthday as was mentioned way back.

Sorry if my post is a bit rambly - trying to give all info, come across neutral and also not drip feed.

OP posts:
MiddleClassProblem · 13/07/2016 15:10

Well maybe his dairy allergy is why she didn't get one for him but still may have been nice to get him something else instead.

I would honestly just ask and say it's no worries of its just a party for DN but just wanted to know in case you needed to bring anything/make a cake. I would feel uncomfortable myself making it a joint celebration with DN being away from home

AliceInUnderpants · 13/07/2016 15:10

Jesus, everything has to be a drama when it comes to ILs doesn't it?

"Hi MIL. You mentioned having a joint birthday party for the boys. Do you want us to bring the cake, since DS needs dairy-free? Brilliant, no problem. What else should we bring?"

cjt110 · 13/07/2016 15:42

I just dont want to upset anyone asking, but at the same time (due to anxiety) like to know whats going on.

OP posts:
diddl · 13/07/2016 15:54

Tbh, it sounds a bit unfair to have a joint party when it wouldn't even be your son's bday & you already have a celebration planned.

I'd be OK with being given a card & present for him as we left.

What have his parents done so wrong that your husband is thinking of limiting contact?Confused

diddl · 13/07/2016 15:56

Seems a bit much to be asking for a joint party when ypu are thinking of reducing contact"

Your son will only be 2 so I'm sure will have enough fun being part of his cousin's celebrations!

Griphook · 13/07/2016 16:05

sus, everything has to be a drama when it comes to ILs doesn't it?

This in abundance. Just ask her what plans she has, she probably so worried about offending you that she doesn't know which way to turn.
But hey keep sending those vouchers

Warl · 13/07/2016 16:12

My friend has a situation similar to this.....
Her parents live close by & her mum minds my friends daughter 2 days a week, every time she buys something for my friends dd she puts the same amount to one side for my friends nephew (her sister lives 200 miles away) wether it be a day out or something as small as an ice cream or sweets. When my friends sister come to visit the nephew can spend what's in his pot & it's usually a hundred or so quid, so he ends up with some massive present & friends daughter will probably always remember that growing up. Strange one as I do see the logic behind it but doubt a 5 year old understands the reasoning Confused

cjt110 · 13/07/2016 16:18

I think after having so many good and thought-inspiring responses, I'll just see what happens.

OP posts:
diddl · 13/07/2016 16:20

Seems like a good idea.

I mean it doesn't really matter either way as you have celebrations planned for his birthday.

MIL is obviously is thinking about him as she invited you with his forthcoming bday in mind.

cjt110 · 13/07/2016 16:32

I agree diddl who cares in the end, as long as the time we spend with them is a nice time :)

Thanks all for your comments. Helped me put things into perspective :)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread