Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel my wedding because of my future in laws?

860 replies

MidnightAura · 19/04/2016 09:17

This is my first AIBU so please be gentle!

My fiancé and are I due to be married this summer. Venue is paid for and everything is booked. My partners family have thrown a few spanner in the works already. My future brother in law, let's call him Adam was upset he didn't get to pick his own best man suit and called up my DP saying it was a waste of his time going for a fitting as he "didn't have any say in the clothes" We found out through Adam that future father in law was unhappy because he wasn't wearing the same suit as his sons and in his words "he would look a spare prick at the top table" but we resolved that only because the man at the suit hire said that the father of the groom should not be identical as he didn't want them all to look as if they were in a marching band and most importantly the groom should stand out. My future mother in law won't tell anyone what colour she is wearing. I had to ask because my mum is getting a corsage and the florist said it should match the colour of her outfit. But my Dps mum won't tell me the colour. But she is miffed that then she may not have a corsage that matches. I don't know why she won't tell us, she says it's a surprise for the day of the wedding. I only mention this to avoid drip feeding!

So that was a few weeks ago. The maximum numbers we have for the wedding is eighty but our numbers are nowhere near that high. We only have 20 people we want there in total. We don't want a big wedding. We have sent out save the date cards. We had to contact father in law to be about getting addresses for some of the family on my DPs side. Dps dad asked for a copy of the guest list, without thinking I gave him it, we got the addresses, save the dates went out. Last night DPs Dad texts him and says he has booked hotel rooms for his cousin (so my DPs second cousin) and father in laws best man. Not my DPs best man, his dad's best man from his wedding 40 years ago who to our knowledge he doesn't see much of.

I realised right away that they weren't invited, checked the list and DP called and spoke to his Dad. We haven't invited these people. We have never met father in laws best man and in the eight years DP and I have been together, he's seen his dad's cousin twice. Both at funerals. There is no contact in between.

DPs dad started to get very upset on the phone, saying the hotel was booked already. DP hates confrontation and hates upsetting people but to give him his due he told his Dad that we hadn't invited these people, two of them we have never met and the other we see rarely. Our decision not to invite his fathers cousin is simply we don't want a big wedding with all the extended family there. None of my aunts and uncles will coming and certainly none of my parents cousins are coming. We want a small wedding.

So father in law to be puts DPs mum on the phone, the whole conversation is then repeated. She says his dad is devastated not to have the whole family there, they just assumed his dad's cousin would get an invite automatically as a second cousin is "immediate family" So even though none of these people had a save the date, DPs parents took it upon themselves to invite them and book them all hotel rooms. His Mum said we would have to do something about it and we then have to call them back. I don't feel we should have to fix this ? We haven't invited any of these people and it's not our fault they booked hotels without asking us if they could come?

So anyhow DPs mum starts to get upset and then she puts Dps brother on. Again we have to go through the whole thing again, dos brother lays on the guilt saying his parents are in tears, we should invite the whole family as they are never altogether and it isn't fair. He also said that Dps Dad will not come to the wedding if father in laws cousin can't be there. He also said we could add on these people as extras and they will pay. They are quite annoyed we have said no and have said its a matter of principal, it's our wedding day we decide who gets an invite, it's not for DP's family to turn it into a big family affair without asking and it's not what we want.

DPs brother *Adam messaged me this morning saying that four guests from their side won't be coming can we please Invite father in laws best man and his cousin? They just want to have the family there as the all the family only meet for sad times and they just want a happy family event. Why can't they just accept no means no?

It upsets DP and I that they are trying to turn our wedding day into a big family affair. I guess we are also a bit baffled because we hardly see DPs family. We seen them twice last year. They stay a 45 minute car journey away and they all drive but they just aren't interested in DP. We invite them round, we get told no. When we moved house and needed help with the move and for some things after, we asked for help and got told no.
Dps parents are retired and very wealthy. If they want big family get togethers they could have one any time, but they don't see much of the extended family either. It just feels like they want to use our wedding to have a big reunion (which is fine if that's what we wanted) and they seem intent in making it about them. It actually feels like they want to pretend at this wedding that we are all really close when the reality is completely different. We haven't seen DPs parents since Christmas!

So now I'm ready to throw the towel in. That how upset I feel about it. The day doesn't feel about us, it feels about DPs parents and their wishes. We would lose a lot of money to cancel and elope but I'm starting to think it will be worth it.

Adam is really pushing us (no doubt on his parents orders) to invite the best man and second cousin. We just don't want to and I fear that by giving in on this occasion there will be something else down the road I.e they aren't happy the relatives are only getting evening invites, Adam isn't happy his girlfriend of a month isn't on top table. I just don't want any more of this hassle. I just want to get married and Dp and I have those we want there to celebrate it with us. Is that unreasonable?

OP posts:
MyFavouriteClintonisGeorge · 19/04/2016 18:13

Midnight, I would speak to your sister yourself. You don't need your mother as a go-between. You said you didn't go to her wedding and the two of you aren't close, so it would be surprising if your sister was actually demanding to go. Her children can still have special roles at any family party you decide to do afterwards. You do need to tell her directly if the wedding if off, not let her hear about it through your mother.

BoatyMcBoat · 19/04/2016 18:13

So just elope. Without telling anyone. Have a big party a week afterwards, where I'm sure the imagination of MN can come up with ideas of how to give the children a special role, and everyone can wear the nice clothes they want to, and you can have some nice food.

You could even do all that at the original venue so no need to cancel the booking at all, it's just an after-wedding party instead of the reception. Just book the elopement for the week before, and cancel the current marriage ceremony.

PestilentialCat · 19/04/2016 18:14

Oh & eloping actully means running off to marry in secret - just go & do it at the weekend or something & swan in, rings on gloat a bit & sort out the party Grin

upthegardenpath · 19/04/2016 18:14

Wow.
Families really are dysfunctional, and not only mine!
Do what is best for you and your DP.
It's your wedding day, no one else's and if they are happy for you both they'd be happy about your arrangements as well.
End of.

TaliZorahVasNormandy · 19/04/2016 18:19

Op, seriously just go and get married, fuck everyone else. Your mum is just as bad, placing demands on you if you elope.

You and your DP just want to be married, so go get married. Fuck the lot of them,

TitaniumSpider · 19/04/2016 18:20

I've heard that Greta Green is nice at this time of year.

LindyHemming · 19/04/2016 18:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

GummyBunting · 19/04/2016 18:23

The other option is that you have the wedding you want, and tell everyone in no uncertain terms that

The guest list is final
Bil new gf will not be at the top table
No negotiations

Cornishclio · 19/04/2016 18:24

i don't think you should cancel your wedding and eloping just sounds like another nightmare unless just the two of you do it on your own. I think you should stick with your original guest list and your PIL and BIL can lump it. It sounds as if you don't have a close relationship anyway but I can understand why your DP wants his family there. You don't need to tell PIL''s best man or cousin anything. Just send out invites as you intended whether for ceremony or evening and don't get tied up in conversations about accommodation or minibuses. It is up to guests to arrange their own once they have an invite.

If you start your married life off with PIL dictating what you should and should not do having kids will be a whole other nightmare should you have them. Both you and DP need to remain united and have the people you want at your wedding. The families will get over it or if not so what. It is your day and if you let them spoil it before you even get there you will regret it afterwards. This is all fresh now but in a month or so when you are closer to the date this will be over and done with.

RaisingSteam · 19/04/2016 18:26

You are all grown ups. It would be good if you could sort it out. Even the most annoying family are still family. ATM I have people on both sides of my family not talking to each other due to IL issues, it stinks being caught in the middle and seeing so much hurt on all sides.

sonjadog · 19/04/2016 18:28

You need to realize that there is no option that makes everyone happy. You are still trying to find a way to please everyone. There is no way. This is good practise for you and your future husband for being a family unit just the two of you. Who decides how your family life is going to work, is it going to be your mother, your in-laws or you and your husband? No-one should decide how you are going to have your wedding but the two of you. You show your family that you are no longer the son/daughter whose parents make the decisions, but two independent adults who run their own lives.

expatinscotland · 19/04/2016 18:29

'I've spoken to a few alternative venues about eloping. My mum is now kicking up a fuss saying she wants my sister and her kids to come watch us elope. '

It's not eloping then. Eloping is you, him and two strangers off the street (or you can hire them in some areas).

I'd cancel the entire wedding, tbh. Your DP is still not up to sticking up to his family. This will only get worse.

BoopTheSnoot · 19/04/2016 18:30

There's no way of doing this while keeping everyone happy. It's impossible.
If you elope, I think the best way would be to do so without telling anybody and just having a couple of close friends as witnesses. You're not favouring either family then.
After a few weeks, have a celebratory party.
You know what? Yeah, your parents will probably go mad. DP's too. But you know what else? They will get over it.
You can't live your life for everyone else. Balls to them. Elope and do it properly.

Sgoinneal · 19/04/2016 18:36

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DerelictDaughter · 19/04/2016 18:42

Goodness, just reading this makes me wish you weren't marrying into that family. I'm surprised you aren't putting the whole thing off indefinitely.

These things get repeated when you have children, just a friendly heads-up. I suggest you move miles away then do what you want, at a time of your choosing! But move first!

MyLocal · 19/04/2016 18:42

FWIW, I would stick to the original plan, stick to the original 20 and TELL (not discuss) the in laws that this is what is happening. That you are sorry if it isn't what they want, but it is what YOU want. You would be delighted for them, (and not their friends from 1980) to attend, but if they don't want to come you understand.

Finish it there. As you leave, remind them, that no one NOT in YOUR invitation list will be allowed entry.

Inertia · 19/04/2016 18:44

Eloping doesn't work if you end up inviting all the people giving you grief - it's just getting married in a place you didn't want with the same shut from your relatives!

I would go with the suggestion above about telling everyone that you are reconsidering your optios.

Janecc · 19/04/2016 18:45

Was going to suggest the same as Augusta. Or if they'd like to organise an event even if it was with you in your dress etc and a family party for dhs family. Or what about for their wedding anniversary/birthday etc. If they won't go for any of this it's because they want the party to be all about them. And if they want something all about them, they need to foot the bill.
Tbh if your parents are being difficult now you may as well have it at your chosen venue because if dp's family don't end up coming, it will be almost the same as eloping with 11 of you. I know you don't want that either.
I would do as some others suggested and write a firm letter. Perhaps more along the lines with we love you and we want you to be happy for us and this is our day and this is how it's going to be.
I know a lot of people are saying cancel. I don't agree because you are being bullied then into changing your plans. On a personal note, I married years ago and had a big wedding and loved being the centre of attention. But I fully understand that we are all different.

Friendlystories · 19/04/2016 18:48

Just the thought of wedding stress makes me want to run away, we sloped off to the local registry office with two witnesses from work and didn't invite anyone, I have no regrets!

ScrambledSmegs · 19/04/2016 18:52

Good lord - eloping used to mean running away to get married in secret. Getting witnesses off the street. Turning up a week later and going Ta-Daaa! while family weep, wail and gnash their teeth. Then getting cast off without a penny until you produce precious grandchildren or make pots of money in a successful venture at which point they all want to know you again. That kind of thing.

It's not eloping if you have to bring your family too.

Fuck 'em. They're all arseholes. Get married however and wherever you like.

LisaMed · 19/04/2016 18:53

My suggestion, fwiw...

You cannot win. Both sides are trashing what you want and putting your feelings at the bottom of the list.

I suspect that you want to be married because you want to commit to your husband. There are also a lot of legal implications bound up in marriage. I suggest that you get married but don't tell anyone - not before and not after. Go down to the registry office and get the legals covered. As far as anyone knows you have cancelled the wedding due to the interference of the families.

If you want to have a 'family party' later on to announce that you married a year ago or whatever then you can. There will be fallout but I suspect that you will get grief no matter what you do. I think you need to work out how much grief you are willing to take and what you can do to minimise it.

Good luck

EverySongbirdSays · 19/04/2016 18:53

Don't they have a waiting list for Gretna Green these days?

WhereYouLeftIt · 19/04/2016 19:04

"She's all for us eloping but only providing they come."
But that's not an elopement. That's a wedding without the groom's family there. I am a bit bemused by an elopement that includes the bride's parents (and sister, and niece, and nephew ...). So yes, I agree with beatrix that "Your mum is fine with you eloping, but only if her family is there. Which is basically saying she's ok with your DP pissing off his family, but don't you dare do the same. "

"When I think if our wedding I picture it being a small affair, our nearest and dearest and the day just being about our commitment to each other"
Which is a description of a perfect wedding IMO. Trouble is - your nearest are not your dearest. Both sets of parents are being PITA's. Both are trying to be in control. Your mum is behaving no better to your FIL. FFS, an elopement does not involve parents et al!

OVienna · 19/04/2016 19:05

I haven't RTFT - sorry. But you know what I'd do? I send a really, really vulgar wedding poem in the invitation to the guests you don't know/were made to invite. With details of the venue to be sent after payment has been made to Messers Mossack Fonesca.

I wouldn't but it would be so tempting. If DPs family kicks off, there are plenty of links to suggest it's 'normal.'

WhereYouLeftIt · 19/04/2016 19:06

I think I would consider de-inviting all family and just having our 20 closest friends celebrate our wedding if both families were going to be so cantankerous.

It would certainly put some boundaries in place, which at present both families are happy to trample all over!

My sympathies OP Flowers