Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What made you FINALLY stop over eating?

122 replies

spad · 07/03/2016 22:40

I am struggling to lose more than 5 stone.

Any advice would be gratefully received.

tia

OP posts:
Toffeelatteplease · 09/03/2016 16:56

My fitness pal

I log everything that passes my lips. I still have large portion sizes but the contents of my plate has definitely changed. I have still snacked, drunk coffee, ate mcdonalds and roast dinners (but only if it is within my calorie allowance). I have made a few food switches, I don't really eat bread anymore because it is too expensive calories wise, I don't fry in oil (or I use spray oil) and I have swapped crisps for popcorn. I eat a lot more rocket and leek

I have so far lost a stone and a half (I think because I actually never weighed myself at my heaviest), I really haven't found it hard and don't have a problem with the idea of doing it for the next 5-6 months to loose the rest. I do accept logging everything is a new way of life if I want to keep it up.

What prompted me:

Realising how much medication I would need to take if I developed diabetes.
I had few clothes left in my wardrobe that fitted and I refused to buy a 20
Seeing photos of me from last summer and accepting I was deeply unhappy with my weight.
It was the next aim in my five year plan. I had done the other bits

Behooven · 09/03/2016 17:01

It's portion size for me is a problem. I seem to have lost sight of what is normal/large/huge. Therefore I cook too much and eat it all.

Toffeelatteplease · 09/03/2016 17:09

The thing about my fitness pal is you can eat how you want. You can low carb if you want or not if you don't. It's like my little food guardian angel in my pocket. What do I fancy today and can I make it fit. For me a club wouldn't be anywhere near as responsive and immediate so wouldn't work. I do plan some days but i can also be spontaneous.

mountains · 09/03/2016 17:33

wow my head is spinning so many different eating regimes has anyone taken bits from each one to tailor one for themselves...? I think I might try to take some of the tips above and make up my own system from the different diets to see how it goes....

I'm taking bits from everywhere...
I'm logging everything I eat on myFitnessPal, I try to stick to 1200 calories (fairly low, but not v low), and I avoid carbs and sugar as much as I can, on the understanding that the insulin they make me produce, hinders fat burning. So anything sugary or starchy I regard as an enemy & don't touch. The result being that I stuff my face with veg, eggs, dairy and nuts, and I don't go around feeling hungry - in fact I feel better than ever.
I'm looking into introducing exercise and yoga , but I've never done any in my life before so v tentative.
There's great advice on the fasting (5:2 etc) threads about insulin and exercise btw.
I also try to walk and nice about.
Recently I thought I was ok going back to carbs, and I soon found myself overeating madly again. Ritz, toast with butter, yum! Well, i can't afford to start on them, or I can't stop. And I feel so much better I'm not hugely tempted.
In other words, I personally think that mixing advice is ok Smile

karenknows · 09/03/2016 17:50

Stop watching too much TV or news, they make a negative impact on you! read positive stories, find out new facts, food, snacks, tactics, all this information can make you see a different perspective of eating. Get used to the idea, that's part of the secret. Wink

pipjune · 09/03/2016 19:35

I do Slimming World- you can still have treats and fill yourself up but you just need to change the bad habits! I also started a blog which keeps me motivated to cook new healthy meals (www.theslimmingfoodie.com). I've lost nearly 2 stone now! Having to be weighed also keeps me motivated!!

feralgirl · 09/03/2016 20:07

Another vote for Fat Club (aka Slimming World). I've shifted five stone gradually over three and a half years. I love it coz it's dieting for greedy bastards; you can eat a washing up bowl full of pasta/ lean meat/ potatoes if you want which suits me perfectly as I am a massive glutton and life without carbs is not worth living imo.

I did 5:2 for a bit and it worked for a while but then stopped and WW is too much counting and not enough eating for my liking. Low carbing is also too expensive for my food budget and I level out on it very quickly and stop losing weight.

It took a while to wean myself off white bread and copious amounts of olive oil with SW; they were the only things I missed. I find the principles of SW are so ingrained in my lifestyle now that, even if I have a stint 'off plan' like at Christmas, I still do a lot of it unconsciously anyway.

It's all down to what suits your budget, food taste and how much you enjoy cooking I think.

ohmywhatamisaying · 09/03/2016 20:45

I took off all my clothes, made myself look as fat and ugly as I could in front of a mirror and took a photo on my mobile. Whenever I feel the cravings for something bad, I just look at it.

Works a charm.

God help me if my phone ever gor hacked :(

mountains · 09/03/2016 21:35

I have to admit I wouldn't have chosen to go low carb, it just happened, and crept up as I wanted to see the weight drop off, yet I hated being weak with hunger (as I too often did following sugary stuff).
There's nothing I love more than a baguette with butter and jam (yes, a whole one! ;)) but I'll have it 'another day'.

Crispbutty · 09/03/2016 21:39

for me it was a wii fit and the myfitness pal app. I lost 3 stone in about 5 months.

Ohdearohdearme · 09/03/2016 21:46

Motivation - didn't want to look fat in my wedding photos.

How I went about it - cooking everything from scratch, investing in a pair of kangoo jumps rebound shoes and exercising in them 3 times a week.

Lost 20lb in just over a year.

Colsgirl · 10/03/2016 07:47

Making friends with mild hunger - I don't need to eat at the first sign of hunger anymore. Attending Overeaters Anonymous is very helpful too. I also walk lots and do Pilates, which is amazing for my body (and nearly sorted out my back issue). I'm down about two dress sizes so far and am very happy with progress - the previous ten years was a horrible cycle of diets and over eating. I feel much better mentally and physically. Good luck!

MitzyLeFrouf · 10/03/2016 10:22

Making friends with mild hunger

That's a good one Colsgirl. I completely agree. It's fine to be hungry, it's good to be hungry before a meal!

EthelMercaptan · 10/03/2016 10:58

Cooking everything from scratch for me too but in my case because I read Swallow This by Joanna Blythman and could no longer face eating processed food. When you don't eat anything unless you've made it, pretty much, you don't eat things like cake and biscuits very often and when you do you eat much less. You eat crisps, well, never really!

Postchildrenpregranny · 10/03/2016 11:01

I'm the classic comfort eater (I also eat when bored)My meals are generally quite healthy but its the snacks-usually late at night. I try not to have biscuits,crisps , nuts (which I love)dried fruit ,in the house and we've given up eating cheese and biscuits after a meal (I can eat cheese like chocolate)...DH loves home made cake and I have learnt to cut it into pieces and freeze it so I/we can't binge on it .
I don't drink much, just wine at weekends but interestingly gave it up for Lent last year and didn't lose a pound .
Exercise definitely helps even if it's only gardening or vigourous housework .
Two of my current 'worries'are easing and better weather/longer days lifts my mood .So am going to try harder .An immineny reunion with family members I haven't seen for years helps.I need to lose a stone to be ahealthy BMI.As you get older its as much to do with health as aesthetics
I find writing down what I've eaten helps and I have tried putting £1 (more would be better)in a jar for every pound lost and treating myself is good

Marmite75 · 10/03/2016 12:09

I was 13st 10 45 days ago. Today, I way 12.9. I'm using my fitness pal and on a strict 1200 Kals. I would think nothing of eating a big bag of giant buttons and half a bottle of wine in the evening. I went shopping for new trousers and I as totally shocked when I couldn't get any to fit and caught sight of my shape in the triple changing room mirrors 😭😭😭 I have 2 st to go and my goal is holiday in July. I swapped the big bag of giant buttons for a kids size bag of normal buttons, measure my wine and eat tons of sale or veg with a low fat meal. M&S count on us or health balanced one are really nice. Good luck OP!

Marmite75 · 10/03/2016 12:12

Weigh it way. Rocking DT's to sleep and typing in my phone!

hareinthemoon · 10/03/2016 13:31

I do think if you have 5 stone to lose (as I did) you have to admit to a disordered relationship with food (and probably exercise as well, but certainly food). The first thing to do is to kick any bastard who tells you "just eat less and move more" as if you were so thick that hadn't occurred to you. The next thing is to read through this lovely thread and mentally try on things that resonate with you. Not everything will. Different things work for different people. I think over my life I've tried the vast majority of things in the thread and I offer what is currently working for me not as anything better but just an addition to ideas.

Firstly I had to get over the nagging feeling that everyone else's needs had to come before mine. I feel much better when I am quite hardcore about food; for me that is a kind of "dirty vegan" way of eating which was anathema for my family. Well now that the kids have gone to uni I am free to eat as much quinoa and buckwheat as I like. I am prioritising my own health and feel better for doing so. I made myself feel worthy of that time and attention (mind you that took a lifestyle earthquake and I'm not sure I'd recommend those on a regular basis, and nor do I know how to carve out a slice of self-love for yourself without a huge change. Perhaps posting your question here is that point for you.) I was trapped in a kind of addicted feeling around foods like sugar and bread, and read a few books about binge eating (I actually was bulimic for a while, and just stopped the vomiting part when the kids were born, without losing the disordered eating style, hence the overweight). Lots resonated with me, but one in particular was by a woman who had found herself in all the bulimic intervention strategies, nothing working, and just deciding one day that she was not ill, that she had poor impulse control. And she stopped being bulimic quite quickly.

The main thing I took from this book was that I started talking to myself as if I was a toddler - that is, kindly, instead of mentally yelling at myself for "being so disgusting" all the time. I asked myself if I really wanted something. If I did, could I bear to wait for a bit? Was I sure? If I really wanted it I gave it to myself, after reminding myself of the consequences of my choice. I was kind, always, but clear about results of actions. It might sound mad but separating myself into the toddler with poor impulse control and the adult who was not witholding for the sake of it but had my own best interests at heart, seemed to allow me to decouple myself from a kind of desperate relationship with food. Once this had started I moved on to other techniques like lower carbs etc. But I find the "having a treat for being good" approach just doesn't work for me - it seems to upset that kind relationship between the adult and toddler mes in my head. And counting everything makes me twitchy too. I know they work for other people, really well.

Try not to give up on yourself. You really are worth it.

I'm two stone down and still losing, and hopeful.

JasperDamerel · 10/03/2016 13:57

This is such a lovely thread. Someone started a thread a week or two ago about how she had decided to stop trying fruitlessly to lose weight after years of disordered eating and just try to be healthy and everyone piled in to attack her because of the way she'd phrased her original post. So it's really nice to see more people advocating a bit more self-love when it comes to weight loss.

I don't know if what I'm currently doing will lead to me losing weight, but I'm fairly sure it will. I was ill last year, and realised that if I carried on the way I was, I would, at some point, be ill a lot of the time.

So I started making little changes. My first change was to get enough sleep - no phones after 9pm, camomile tea and a bath or shower before bed, bed at ten and lights out at half past. I haven't given up sugar or alcohol or white flour altogether, but I tell myself that I avoid them - they are things I will eat only if I really, really want them, and it turns out that often I don't.

I have started doing Crossfit classes, which I love. They are really good exercise, I feel great after each class, I feel motivated to get better, and I get to spend time with a load of super-fit people, which is quite inspiring.

I still need to work on portion control and stress/tiredness eating, but I'm making my changes in small steps. I'll be doing a Whole 30 in May, so I'm going to see what I find hard from that.

I've stopped keeping things like crisps in the house, although I make kale crisps on Fridays which is the children's crisp day at school, so I still get my crunchy treats, just in a more nourishing form.

And I'm finding that by thinking not about weight loss but about nourishing my body, and treating it well, and waiting to see what I really want after the first craving for rubbish (the answer is almost always that what I really want is to go to bed and have a rest), and what me make feel good ready for my exercise class the next day, I am choosing to eat less and more healthily. And when I don't do that, I'm better at thinking of it as learning experience rather than a horrible failure. Mostly what I've learned is that to lose weight, I will need to sleep and rest a ridiculous amount. And I'm OK with that - I lost a huge chunk of last year to a series of chest infections followed by post-viral fatigue. As I get healthier, that might change, or it might not, but I've stopped thinking of getting enough rest as laziness and started thinking of it as vital self-care.

JasperDamerel · 10/03/2016 13:58

I love the toddler thing! I think I'll start doing that, too.

Casimir · 10/03/2016 14:03

Move countries for me. Behavioural science suggests asking 'What would Batman/Wonderwoman/ insert admired person here' do? before eating.

Honeyandfizz · 13/03/2016 08:52

Thanks op for starting this thread. I'm trying one day at a time to not overeat following some of the tips on here! Just off for a run Wink

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread