I will try to explain, actually, then I really will go and let the thread die a death.
Typically I know who the repeat offenders are - children who will not have a pen - and as far as possible I have books, an activity and a pen out ready.
The start of lessons are VERY hectic and this isn't necessarily typical of all schools but our building isn't safe - too many students in too small a space - so they are (rightly) encouraged to come straight in. This means I frequently have one class piling out with another piling in and, of course, this is a secondary school so they are physically tall and often have big coats and bags.
Lesson changeover is very tricky because of this and so yes, students do often sometimes wander out with my pens. I'm not so arsed about this: it's the kids who trash them.
In the last week I've had:
- a pen hurled at another girls head (some argument about something or other - I rang down for assistance and it came, but the pen was still wrecked. I doubt the girl maliciously meant to destroy my pen: that's just it. It was just worthless - not someone else's item, just Something.)
- a pen smashed in a rage because I asked child to wait a moment (I'm not joking!)
- any number of pens dropped and smashed by massive teenager feet on the way out!
- a couple that 'exploded'
'Make them give something of theirs over' - well, how? I've confiscated phones because they've been on them in the lesson and every time it's a big massive kerfuffle. I do it, because I'm not having kids whatsapping through the lesson, but honestly, for ten/twelve kids? I'd never teach anything!
It's a symptom of the disease not the disease itself. Ultimately and sadly, education is not valuable enough to some of them - if you say 'no phone, no pen' they will self righteously see that as YOU depriving them of the ability to produce work some managers would agree - they wouldn't humbly agree the work was essential, it must be done and after all, they'll get their phone back.
It's a shame. I don't doubt we'll change things we will have to or ofsted will shut us down but I don't think the pen problem is going anywhere for some time. And as I say, it's always been an annoyance; it is just that in some schools it's an annoyance that happens twice a day if that. Here, twice a lesson would be a bloody miracle 