My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

MNHQ have commented on this thread

AIBU?

They're not refugees, we're being invaded

826 replies

goonthenflameme · 23/09/2015 23:22

I admit, the Syrians have got it bad. There is a war and those boys who haven't been shot by ISIL are being conscripted by the President.

But if life is that bad, why do they only want to go to Germany and if they can't go then then they'll go back to Syria.

Why are we now seeing people from Kazakstan joining the throngs?

I agree that people from Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria need help. But the thougsands and thousands of people coming through can't all be refugees in dire need of help if they are so picky as to where they will live.

They're invading Europe. And we are letting them. What's going to happen in 20 years? Will Christianity and western ways be swept under the carpet?

OP posts:
Report
merrymouse · 24/09/2015 06:50

I don't think everybody in Kazakhstan wants to come and live in the UK.

However the refugees will not turn around and go away if we just close our eyes and pretend they aren't there.

The UK must be actively involved in the refugee crisis because it is our problem, if for no other reason than that we need to maintain relations with all the other countries (like Greece and Italy) who have no choice but to deal with the people washing up on their shores.

Meanwhile, you don't need a Muslim to sweep Christian ideals under the carpet, when many seem so eager to protect 'Christianity' while ignoring its teachings.

Report
JeffreysMummyIsCross · 24/09/2015 07:01

The UK government has said that it will take 10,000 refugees over 5 years. And, yes, they will be refugees, since they will be taken directly from camps on the Syrian border. The priority will be children and women, not "fit young men".

10,000 people is equivalent to 0.0003% of our current UK population. Hardly an invasion, and hard to see how "they" are going to succeed in imposing sharia law on us. It's also a tiny amount in comparison to our immigration levels from the European Union.

I assume that those who are so eager to preserve this country's Christian foundations are delighted and grateful at the influx of immigrants from the EU over the past 15 years, since this has given churches over here a much-needed shot in the arm?

Report
LeaveMyWingsBehindMe · 24/09/2015 07:03

Neither do I merry. But that doesn't matter, because the fact is that there are 17 million people (at the very least) somewhere who do. And if they argument for allowing them is that they have a tough life in a place with few opportunities and poor human rights then we have a massive, massive problem.

The ones who are already in mainland Europe will not turn around and go home unless forced, it's true. But how we are seen to handle this now will affect how many choose to make the journey in future.

Report
Olivepip59 · 24/09/2015 07:09

I thank fuck you lot aren't in charge, frankly. The thought is terrifying

Agreed.

The posters so quick to dismiss Europe as a cesspit of binge drinking and post-colonial riches-counting, have any of you ever experienced life under the regimes you are keen to embrace? Or at least to attempt to diminish the danger to human rights they pose?

I have.

And I suspect if you had too, you might be more circumspect in your emotional extortion to blindly accept everyone who wants to live here.

The rape link posted above echoes what has been reported by Swedish press in recent years about Stockholm's terrifying rape crisis.

Report
LeaveMyWingsBehindMe · 24/09/2015 07:13

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06bnq1d

This is an extremely interesting, informative and intelligently balanced discussion on Radio 4, listen from about 40 minutes or so in.

thanks to another poster who posted it on another thread, and I have lifted it from there.

Also this is interesting.

www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/migrants-are-disguising-themselves-as-syrians-to-gain-entry-to-europe/2015/09/22/827c6026-5bd8-11e5-8475-781cc9851652_story.html?tid=sm_fb

Report
Lemonfizzypop · 24/09/2015 07:16

Christianity isn't fading because of the immigration. A lot of people left the churches because of all the abuses and wars. We could barely get a good education either. Many of us have been in the recent immigrant's shoes just a few generations ago.

Most of the practicing Christians, I.e ones that go to church regularly, I know are of African descent!

This is far more secular society than a Christian one.

Report
MrsUltracrepidarian · 24/09/2015 07:17

I have been upset to see those fit young Men elbow women and children to the back of the pack when it comes to transportation.
This

Report
LeaveMyWingsBehindMe · 24/09/2015 07:20

It's not about a threat to Christianity it's about a threat to our culture and our values and our laws. I wouldn't give a stuff if everyone in the country converted to Islam so long it didn't mess with our culture, our values and our laws.

But it would, wouldn't it? There's always a tipping point and when you have a sizeable majority of voting citizens who want a totally different way of life with different values and different laws that have their roots in a different culture and a different religion then you have a problem. And quite possibly a civil war.

Report
Lemonfizzypop · 24/09/2015 07:22

Look at our government, mainly rich white men, I think we're very far from having sharia law don't you? Even if we taken in thousands of migrants they would still be a minority!

Report
merrymouse · 24/09/2015 07:23

I'm more concerned about people who appear to be under the impression that because of the refugee crisis legislation is about to be passed to allow free immigration to the UK, but to stop this we have to pretend real refugees don't exist.

I think it's the reverse of clapping your hands to show you believe in Fairies. Stick your fingers in your ears to show you don't believe in refugees. They will all magically become economic migrants with iPhones.

Report
shins · 24/09/2015 07:24

Bogeyface, my point was that those who hold your views tend to use insults when they're run out of decent arguments, a favourite of which is to suggest that their opponents (a) aren't as moral as them and (b) are stupid.

MrsG - how do we show that we remember our dark history and recent collusion in bungling in the Middle East? Don't forget the latter decisions like invading Iraq were made by political leaders against the wishes of their electorate. Or does everyone have to suffer the consequences now? Must we all prostrate ourselves and say we're so sorry! Please come and live here, everyone - even people from totally unrelated countries that aren't at war! Seriously, what is your solution? The "west" spends billions on foreign aid and development in war-torn countries in comparison to the wealthy Gulf states whose only interest is exporting the poisonous Wahabism that's radicalising Muslims the world over. Doesn't that show our values?

MaudeGonneMad, what's new here is the numbers which have no end. The proportion of young men is significant because it characterises this as a migration, not refugees seeking asylum from war. People are getting angry about the media's conflation of the two. If you want to see real refugees, look at photos of the Kurds fleeing Saddam Hussein's gas attacks, or the Ugandan Indians arriving in the UK.

Lamination, then they aren't refugees. An example: after the displacement of millions in the second world war (and this is the context in which the UN Convention on Refugees was drafted), they were held in camps in Europe, often for a year or two, before it was decided where they were placed or whether they could go back. They were sent - and I mean sent - to specific destinations like Canada or Australia. They were set up with a job and a temporary place to live and that was that. No further support. They didn't throw rocks and burning tyres at police or demand free transport to their destination of choice. They were extremely grateful to be alive.

Atenco how on earth was the war in Syria started in the name of Christianity and Western ways? It was a failed Arab Spring which led to a civil war. The West only intervened very recently, in fact they were criticised for doing nothing. Iraq was a horrendous mistake, unfortunately those strong arm dictators in the ME usually hold a volatile place together (look at the disaster in Libya since they helped get rid of Gadaffi), and ditto Afghanistan, that particular mess having started when they armed the Taliban against the Russians. US intervention was about power and influence but Christianity??

When I talk about Christianity, I'm not talking about religious faith and observance. I'm talking I suppose, about post-Christianity - that over recent centuries, Europe's clerics lost power in favour of nation states and scientific discovery and new ideas challenged religious orthodoxy. Christianity got put in its place - it was defanged. We take that so much for granted, but it's not the case in the Muslim world where in most countries there is no separation at all between church and state. In most Muslim countries other faiths are barely tolerated and routinely discriminated against because one of the core beliefs of Islam is that unbelievers are inferior. There is no comparison to the way Christian or post-Christian states treat non-Christians. I cannot think of anywhere Muslims are discriminated against in Europe by law but I can point to many many Muslim countries where Christians aren't allowed to run for election, build churches etc. or have been driven out and persecuted. Don't take what we have for granted. People like you are dangerous.

Report
SausageSmuggler · 24/09/2015 07:28

I've not read the entire thread so this may have already been said but a lot of the 'fit young men' are fleeing being drafted against their will (to both sides of the conflict). Can't say I blame them for not wanting that.

Report
LeaveMyWingsBehindMe · 24/09/2015 07:34

Lemon if you go to Tower Hamlets or parts of Birmingham or Burnley, or wherever there are large settled communities of Muslims you will find that local government is often largely dominated by Muslims because they vote in people they perceive to have their interests at heart and who can represent their needs and wants.

We have a largely white, loosely Christian government now because we are a mostly white, loosely Christian society now. When that changes and the see-saw starts to level out and eventually tip, so will the shape of how we are governed, first at a local level and then at a national level. You don't need to have a degree in PPE to work that one out.

Report
beaucoupdemojo · 24/09/2015 07:35

In a patriarchal society the young men are more important than the women... wrong in our eyes but understandable err no, not to me it isn't. I don't want to import people whose cultural beliefs fundamentally contradict the rights and freedoms this country holds dear.

The fact is we don't know who we will be getting and it's not wrong to have reservations about that.

Report
Brioche201 · 24/09/2015 07:35

21000 people a day starve to death, manybofvthem children. Where is the public outrage about that?

Report
sakura · 24/09/2015 07:46

I really would like an answer as to why it's mainly men in the crowds we see.

Report
BMW6 · 24/09/2015 07:48

Why are there so few women and children coming? Concerns me slightly to be honest.
Because the journey is expensive, dangerous and extremely arduous.
When they are granted asylum in a safe country, they can send for their dependents (wife & children) who are then able to travel safely and legally to their new home.


In that case, for every young man who is granted Asylum in Europe, how many family members will apply and be granted the right to join him under the Right to Family life within the Human Rights Act?? As EU has now agreed qoutas they should factor in that for each one accepted perhaps 3 or more may want to join him!!

Report
sakura · 24/09/2015 07:49

did anyone ask the women whose countries these men are entering, whether they want an influx of extra men into their communities? I don't believe they did. This isn't families, in the main, it's packs of young men. A woman in Greece was crying that she could no longer take her children to school because these idiots were fighting in the streets. That says it all to me;.

Report
MissFitt68 · 24/09/2015 07:54

Well, how many have actually entered the UK so far?

Report
beaucoupdemojo · 24/09/2015 07:56

We are part of Europe. Once they get leave to remain there, they will be free to travel here.

Report
LittleLionMansMummy · 24/09/2015 07:57

Oh look, another goady refugee thread. Yawn.

Oh and bollocks to 'Christianity' if being a Christian means you turn your back on other humans, even if you absolve yourself of the guilt by saying a prayer or two. Hypocrisy of the highest order.

Report
MissFitt68 · 24/09/2015 07:58

Well yes, 'bollocks' to all religion really

Report
MushroomMama · 24/09/2015 07:59
Biscuit
Report
howtorebuild · 24/09/2015 08:00

Missfit, a very small number, at least they are the most vulnerable.

Report
howtorebuild · 24/09/2015 08:01

20,000 over five years is such a low number.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.