This is an interesting read. We have similar problems with our pfa. Are we cliquey? God no!! We do spend time in a huddle on the playground because there is always something to be discussed. There is a core of about three or four of us who do everyfuckingthing, but i know for me, i do it because i enjoy it. This often means that things are presented in the meeting in almost a fate acomplis and i don't like this and we have lost members in the past becuase of this, but the other side of that coin is that we only have an hour to discuss events etc so without having pre-discussed the meetings get nowhere.
We are not in any way smug yummy mummy SAHMs, I co-chair and i have two other jobs. Although both jobs are flexible and allow me to have time.
We have our meetings during the day which i worry puts off the working parents but then they would need babysitters in the evenings. We allow people to bring their children to our meetings.
We do manage to get volunteers for events but it is like pulling teeth - I actually don't buy the "i work" excuse because we are asking for an hour or two of peoples time a couple of times a year - it is ok to say, you know what, i'd rather pull my teeth out with a pair of plyers than help sell your cakes but please let me have a couple of raffle tickets instead - we have decent prizes that i have broken my neck scrounging from anywhere and everywhere
Maybe having a creche for volunteers children would help at events but then you'd need CRB checked appropriately qualified supervisors??
I use social media alot - people must think i have nothing better to do with my time but i update it alot with requests and information. maybe it fucks people off.
Thing is - i just think that most people don't enjoy that sort of thing - maybe they are too busy having lives. They are missing out, yes its about the money, we raise ALOT of money so we must be doing something right - however i would like to see more people join in because, well, its fun.