Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Distant FIL Veto'ing our baby names!!!

38 replies

Ellieben · 12/05/2015 09:24

Very long story but I'll try to summarise in a nutshell. DH and are have been together for 7 years, married for 2 and expecting our first baby in 3 months, a boy. We lived in London for 5 years before buying a house in Oxfordshire where both his mother and stepfather live in addition to my parents. It made perfect sense and we are so happy here.

DH has a difficult relationship with his bio father who is very hard work frankly. He takes from DH and gives nothing. His mum and bio dad split when DH was 6mths and his stepfather has been an incredible father - a true example if ever there was one that step parents can be an incredible influence in a childs life and i adore him, as does DH.

Background: bio dad lives in london, never used to bother to see us. Only saw DH on occasion and when he did he moaned and caused him grief. He's never worked, choosing instead to try and become a famous musician. Drawback of this is that he has continually asked my DH for money (he owes us about £6,000 by my calculations). Didnt even RSVP to our wedding, didnt come and never so much as sent me a text afterwards. He has never visited us in Oxford. Of course when DH (rarely) sees him he is all sweetness and light. Aside from that, DH receives barrages of texts at all hours about how crap his life is etc etc which in the past used to make him worry a great deal but i suspect less so now.

I am expecting a boy and am having great difficulty choosing a name. The only 3 i liked (which DH mentioned to his bio father in a rare phone call last night) were absolute no no's because they were the names of people who have "shit on him" in his life. Only one of those names we were aware of (and it's hardly a rare name that only that person has) but the other two we hadnt heard of. DH panders to his behaviour and has said that we can't use them, despite them being definites two days ago. I am fuming. AIBU??

OP posts:
ConfusedInBath · 12/05/2015 10:30

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Lipsync · 12/05/2015 10:33

I agree that we don't need the backstory. Whether he was a crappy, uninvolved father to your DH, or a loving, concerned, involved one, it still doesn't give him the right to issue edicts about what your child is called, based on his perception that some names remind him of people who behaved poorly to him.

I suggest you tell him your front runner name is 'Six Thousand Pounds'.see if that reminds him of anything.

oddfodd · 12/05/2015 10:40

Your FIL is a pathetic loser and your DH is a fool for expecting him to behave like a normal, rational person.

I'm not surprised you're fuming. Hopefully your DH has learned a very valuable lesson.

lantien · 12/05/2015 10:44

Talk to your DH - get an agreement with him that the subject of your DC name is not to be discussed with anyone but you - especially his bio father but everyone else as well - as everyone will have an view that in few years time they'll have likely forgotten anyway.

Then have a look again at baby names - see if anything you prefer to these names - only because they names now feel tainted - as you put it.

If there are not and these names remain your favourites- point this out to your DH and point out how little contact his bio dad is likely to have with DC based on past form and get him to agree it's both your decision only so go with what you want.

Otherwise if you find something better - use that but don't tell anyone the options - even use this as an example why you refused to discuss it - and consider these names for middle names.

I'd also gently point out to your DH that what every he does FIL approval isn't going to be given - as he's a very negative person. Plus other people in FIL life sharing the same name or similar name isn't anything to do with your DS - perhaps might even start bring positive connotations to the name for FIL after initial sulk.

flora717 · 12/05/2015 10:45

Name him after the stepdad & Jacob. Blush OK, you wouldn't use your child to make a point. But wow the self involvement of this guy is extreme.

lantien · 12/05/2015 10:52

We named DD1 and MIL wasn't happy - months of petty comments after birth -then she got over it. Now of course she'd always liked the name - in some conversations I've over heard even suggest it Hmm.

Have friends with similar stories - horror about names - then it's the DC name and everyone gets used to it.

echt · 12/05/2015 10:52

said "i cant believe you would consider calling your baby Jacob when you know about my Jacob and how he ruined my career.

Send it back to the stupid dad, with his name substituted about what a whiny, distant leeching arsehole he is.

Then say how do you them apples?

DayLillie · 12/05/2015 10:53

I would only discuss outlandish or names you know they would find embarrassing, then he will be grateful when the baby arrives and it sounds fairly normal!

We only had one objection for the name of DS when he was born - from a GGM. We told her we had no intention of using the shortened version (which the horrible person we had never heard of apparently used) and all was fine.

MoustacheofRonSwanson · 12/05/2015 11:02

Must be difficult for you and your DH having such a nightmare on your hands.

I'd be tempted to give the three names you've already mentioned a bit of a swerve, more to stop DH getting it in the neck (and children with divorced parents often have way more than their fair share of that over their lifetime).

But any future discussions are between you, and yes, a nod to the step father might be a good idea- if his name's no good, then maybe something that alludes to his middle name, surname, dad's name, town of origin etc. Bit more subtle but do point to the real support and love from a father figure.

Years after my parent's divorced, I changed my surname. I didn't take my mum's maiden name, as I thought that would be a bit too big a slap in the face for my dad. So I used my mum's middle name as my surname instead, as that made more sense to me, and also it clearly showed who had realy done the work of bringing me up.

Clutterbugsmum · 12/05/2015 11:06

Sound's like it will be very hard to find a boys name that is link to someone your FIL may have come in contact with.

As I suspect every male he has come in contact with has done him wrong, well at least in his tiny mind.

specialsubject · 12/05/2015 11:32

call the baby what you like.

as for texts at all hours; turn the mobile off at night. Easy.

ouryve · 12/05/2015 11:34

You need to make up some names that are vaguely ridiculous and refuse to discuss any further.

DS2 was Ogbert for the few months we knew his gender before he was born.

Whatisaweekend · 12/05/2015 11:45

Tbh, given what you have told us about this man, I suspect that there have been loads of people in his life who have "wronged" him. In his mind, he should be where Mick Jagger is now but it hasnt happened and instead he has failed both professionally and personally (bad/absent father) and this is everyone else's fault. Whatever name you told him, he would moan about it as that seems to be his MO.

Go your own way - rubbish FIL doesnt get a say and, as others have said, whats the worst that could happen? He gets the hump and doesnt pester you for money for a few months?!!

Good luck with your birth! Flowers

New posts on this thread. Refresh page