antumbra - you really make me laugh that you think AP is the answer to all problems. It is actually possible to do AP and still find teenagers exasperating, and not easy to parent.
You remind me of my old pastor. One Sunday he was preaching about something and said that his girls never swore because one day he had sat down with them and explained what the swear words meant and they thought that wasn't very nice so they never used them. He had 3 very sweet gentle girls, who have grown up to be 3 very gentle women, with, to be blunt not much personality to speak of. He thought that he was a great parent because he had never had any problems with his girls.
It never occurred to him that there are kids out there with very different personality types. My ds for example, when I explained what the swear words were that he was learning in the playground aged 6, thought they were really funny and they became his favourite words. If you suggest anything is a bad idea to him, it makes him immediately want to do it. He is a very bright, interesting, larger-than-life personality who doesn't cut anyone any slack, not even his mum, and he had been a real challenge to parent well.
dd1 on the other hand is a gentle soul, quiet and studious, and pretty straight forward to parent, I don't think that will change that much in her teenage years, as long as I write on the calendar what time of the month it is (she is 10 and I can already see the hormone patterns!!)
Congratulations, you have kids who have been straight forward to parent. For the rest of us, humour helps
And yes, it really does feel as if you are picking on butterfly.
Please, go and start your own thread. I have followed this one for days and found it so encouraging as we are hitting the teens with a vengeance with ds, and the humour and funny stories has made me feel like we are quite normal after all.