Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to let my DD10 choose when she sees her dad?

30 replies

duckwalk · 14/11/2014 23:15

My DD is 10, was 5 when ex'D'P and I separated. They didn't have a great relationship when we were together but she's gotten much closer to him since we split up and really adores him now.
I've now remarried and DD and DH have a great relationship..... He's so good with her, but at first she was quite jealous at having to share me again. It was tough for a while but DH put in the time and effort and they genuinely love each other now.
ExP (DDs dad) has been with his partner for a couple of years and their relationship is pretty non existent. Again DD was jealous, but instead of trying to take things slowly they refused to..... cuddling on the couch/holding hands etc and when DD would try to take his other hand she'd be told to stop being needy. They've been away on holiday a few times and kept it from her, but didn't attempt to hide 'evidence' such as photos etc. This has added to the resentment DD has, being lied to (plus she's never been taken away with her dad).
Now I can appreciate it must be so hard being the person coming into a relationship and your partner having a child, but it seems as though this woman just gave up trying. DD used to stay overnight once a week and would sometimes tell of going over there and her dad's partner didn't say Hello or Goodbye, and not very much in between. Apparently there's loads of arguments at their house (which I believe as exDP is quite a volatile person and v argumentative). So the whole combination has made DD reach the decision that, while she still wants to see her dad, she doesn't want to have to go to his house. She doesn't want to see his DP as they have no relationship and feels quite uncomfortable when there. Instead, she's happy to see him for a few hours away from his house...eg, go to the cinema, bowling, for lunch and so on. But her dad has refused point blank. Says if she won't go to his house then she doesn't see him at all! And into the bargain has accused me of being unreasonable by not forcing her to go! She's so unhappy going over and at times has had nightmares about being there. I would love for all to be well and good and have never tried to stop him seeing her...in fact I've always had to encourage him to step up to being a dad to her as at one point he didn't attempt to see her for a full month and She had said at the time she felt he didn't love her.
I really don't want to force her to do something which makes her unhappy but he's now saying I'm a disgrace and generally trying to make me feel a shit parent. DH and I have tried several times speaking to exDP and his DP explaining how difficult things were for us at the beginning, telling them to persevere and to include her in things....but then heard on the grapevine that they felt patronised.
He's saying he'll not be dictated to by a child and has told DD that if she'll not see his DP at his house then she doesn't see him at all.... basically making her fee l as though it's all her fault.
I know that I'm only protecting my child but he's making me feel partly responsible too.
Sorry for this long post...there's so much more to this story tbh but that's the present issue in a nutshell.
Do I allow their relationship to gradually fizzle or continue to push it? TIA x

OP posts:
redexpat · 15/11/2014 18:49

Bottom line: he puts his and his dps needs above dds. No decent parent would do that.

Aeroflotgirl · 15/11/2014 18:54

Ams you and your dd have done all you can to reinforce that relationship, if he's not putting the effort there is not much you can do. Just let her make her decisions about contact and not force her to go when she is very unhappy.

nochangewanted · 15/11/2014 23:08

I think take the fact his own parents see how badly it is, you feel guilted into reinforcing relationship, she has to go what does he do?

I can say as a parent whose Dad gave up contact with his son when he was very young it is very hard to understand why their other parent doesn't love the bones of them.

I think the best you can do is support her..

TaraKnowles · 15/11/2014 23:25

His parents' stance on this is telling.

I agree to let your dd decide.

How sad though, that a parent could be like that.

duckwalk · 16/11/2014 00:44

Wow, so sad hearing about lots of other children in this situation.... heartbreaking! My DD seems to be doing a lot better earlier this evening, not as distracted and much happier. People say kids are so robust so I'm hoping this is the case here as this last while has been so hard on us all as a family. Definitely no forcing her to go anywhere she's not completely happy to be. I'm taking a PPs advice and making a copy of this thread, and in the future only ever written communication (although mostly is as I can't bear the sound of his voice!) how childish of me

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page