Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

or is the teacher

51 replies

flixybelle · 04/06/2014 21:30

Our family had 3 deaths in 3 weeks of 2 close family members and a friend. Alongside job interviews and exams so a stressful month. The latest death happened on the first saturday of half term and was quite sudden. As a consequence my dds homework from half term was not done. (dd is 7 and in yr 3) it was totally forgotten about tbh. The homework came home via a text message with very vague instructions. On monday I wrote a note to the class teacher explaining the situation and apologising. DD came out of school on Monday upset as she had been shouted at for not doing the work. So I went to speak to the teacher,asked if she had got the note. She said she had BUT that the work needed to be done, at the latest by today.(Today was the funeral) I explained we couldn't do it (quite a significant amount of work) but she said she must do the work as it is vital for her SATS and she would be very behind if she didn't do it. I was gobsmacked that a the work was so important but there was no mention of this when it was set. b that the teacher was so rude and abrupt she just demanded that the work was done no empathy for the fact we were having a tough time at all.

I walked away really upset and went home and started to do the homework. DH (A primary teacher) came home to an upset wife and dd so immediately called the head teacher and asked what the issue was. She apologised and said that teacher had dealt with it poorly and would get back to us, which she did. Stating that dd could do the work in class with a TA. Again DD came out of school upset as teacher had shouted at her for doing the homework, so coming back from a funeral I had that to deal with very upset dd again. I will add this is the only homework not completed in 3 yrs and we always do reading and do are usually supportive of the school.

OP posts:
AElfgifu · 05/06/2014 03:35

I'm a teacher and I agree with everyone else. Of course this homework doesn't matter, in the wider context of things. The teacher is being an idiot. My Ds have been recently bereaved, and the school has been very helpful and supportive, Lots of hw has not been done!

Phoenix2014 · 05/06/2014 09:53

Child- year 3
SATs- year 6
Homework sent by text- lazy!
Teacher- incompetent if they are relying on h/t homework for child to progress.

flixybelle · 05/06/2014 16:49

Well I picked up dd today and she was upset AGAIN! Teacher had kept her in at break and lunch to do the homework!!! HT told my husband yesterday that DD would have support in class time to complete the work. I am fuming as last night after the funeral we talked through the homework talked about all the animals and descriptive words so that if she had to write a piece she would be able to without any problem felt I had to do this because my dd was so upset about it. I literally have no idea what the hell is going on why is this piece of work so important. On top of it another child (my dd's friend) was also kept in today to help my dd complete the work, that child was also upset at being kept in.

OP posts:
Lottiedoubtie · 05/06/2014 16:52

Have you got an appointment with the HT to discuss all this? Are you keeping a written log for complaint purposes?

Poor DD, she needs to know that her teacher is unreasonable here and that you're doing your best for her.

5Foot5 · 05/06/2014 17:03

Agreed the teacher sounds like an utter and complete knob. I hope your poor DD has a new teacher in September.

Just out of interest, when you say "I walked away really upset and went home and started to do the homework." I presume you mean supervising and helping your DD do the homework?

Princessdeb · 05/06/2014 17:04

Dear OP,
As a parent of a seven year old and a parent governor I would make this a formal written complaint to the HT and Board of Governors so that it is dealt with via the formal process and noted in the teachers file. The teacher is clearly not listening to or acting upon feedback given by a member of the senior leadership team, is not acting in the best interests of your DD and is being a complete cow! She needs to get a grip or if her perspective of what is important is so squewed then she may need to take some time off.

flixybelle · 05/06/2014 17:08

5 foot 5 LOL yes I meant I helped DD do it not that I did it. If I did it would only have taken 20 minutes but I thought the purpose was to inform a writing task so not much point if I had done it. Although talking to some parents seems they did the majority.

Lottie- Not yet spoke to dh and as he made the initial complaint to school he is going to follow up in writing and make an appointment for us both to speak to HT.

OP posts:
Randomeclectic · 05/06/2014 17:10

Formal complaint to the governors even though you are one. Get the process formalised and make the teacher responsible for her poor behaviour.

Randomeclectic · 05/06/2014 17:13

What on earth is that teacher supporting? the idea that all empathy can be lost as long as top grades are reached. Skewered priorities indeed

littlesupersparks · 05/06/2014 17:14

Another teacher here without a doubt yanbu. I would not have expected my y11 or y13 to complete work I. Those circumstances and would have done as much as possible to help them to complete essential work at the least disruption to them and only to the extent they could cope.

Real life always trumps school work at any age.

Pipbin · 05/06/2014 17:15

Another teacher here (pretending to write reports but the lure of MN is too great).
Firstly, a text message is not an appropriate way to be setting homework. Secondly, nothing that important should be set as homework. A 7 year old should not be expected to complete their homework by themselves. If they happen to have parents that can't or won't help them then they are scuppered. I always assume that homework won't be done. I praise those who do it but never punish those who don't.

As others have said SATS are non compulsory at that age.

whynowblowwind · 05/06/2014 17:18

It's ridiculous. My son is in year 2 and we got so fed up of homework I just send DS in with a note saying he didn't have time and not expanding, I think homework is a waste of time anyway.

Pipbin · 05/06/2014 17:18

And I never set homework over the holidays. Children should be on holiday, not worrying about school work, in primary school anyway.

whynowblowwind · 05/06/2014 17:21

Please be DS's teacher next year Pipbin!

flixybelle · 05/06/2014 17:22

The school is a small very family friendly school and it's not the general attitude of the school. I am baffled and furious.

OP posts:
clam · 05/06/2014 17:25

So, has your dd not had any sort of break all day?
THAT, right there, would be a complaint all on its own, aside from the ridiculous homework issue.

whynowblowwind · 05/06/2014 17:26

If I were you flixy I would send in a letter with your daughter stating she will not be completing the homework.

I had to do this with DS, and I wasn't trying to be difficult but honestly he had so much it was stupid. He had no time for his music, swimming or sports and was getting tearful and upset before bed saying he hadn't done his homework.

I just ended up saying that if he/we had time he'd do homework but otherwise he wouldn't and to contact me if this was an issue.

TheDailyWail · 05/06/2014 20:50

This is a shocking way to treat you and your child!

medievaljacqui · 05/06/2014 21:08

So shocking. Another teacher here (secondary) and I would hit the roof with this treatment. I've had GCSE students miss vital prep because of bereavement but I've always approached it from a 'here's what you missed, don't stress handing it in, you know where I am if you want a chat' point of view. Most of them have come to me for a chat and a cup of tea and occasionally we've done the work, but it has always been at their instigation. I make it very clear that I support but don't push, especially in those circumstances. My dad died when I was 20 so I know what it's like to lose someone very young.
Hope you get it sorted op

cansu · 05/06/2014 21:26

She was wrong to make a fuss and to not not be understanding. You should complain. BUT I also think you are making a fuss now. You have made your point. Your dd finishing the work at playtime is not really the end of the world. personally I would my complaint in and then let it go. I wouldn't have the time or energy to be going in and having meetings.

RedRoom · 05/06/2014 21:44

Another teacher here: totally agree with you. The teacher is behaving in an inexplicable way. Vital SATs homework in year 3 that is more important than compassion over a funeral? What on earth is she on about?

Pipbin · 05/06/2014 22:19

Your dd finishing the work at playtime is not really the end of the world.

Although it is not the end of the world, it is unfair. If DD hadn't finished school work because she was mucking about or whatever, fair enough. But why should she miss her break because of something completely beyond her control?

flixybelle · 06/06/2014 10:02

I don't think I am making a fuss. Dh called school was told to come in so he did. I sent a formal complaint into school in writing and was asked by HT to make an appointment to discuss it. I have not spoken to the teacher since I originally asked about the homework.
Whilst its not the 'end of the world' her being kept in, staying in at break time its usually reserved for children who are misbehaving and my dd was not.
Also to clarify her whole class was kept in at morning break to finish literacy work and then my dd was kept in the whole of lunchtime for homework.

OP posts:
DartmoorDoughnut · 06/06/2014 10:09

The teacher sounds like an utter cow, your poor DD :( I wouldn't like a whole day in work without a break let alone a full day in school at her age!

Really glad you're complaining and hope the teacher a) apologises and b) never acts like this again. I am assuming poor lesson planning earlier in the year has led to her trying to catch up and taking it out on the class or something Confused

Canthisonebeused · 06/06/2014 10:21

No SATs in y3 and home work inst legally compulsory.