Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel a bit aggrieved ?

28 replies

poshfrock · 19/02/2014 12:35

So I think I probably ABU but I still feel irritated by the following situation and just need some MNetters to make me see sense.

So about 4 years ago we helped out a family member by giving them my car. I was due for a replacement anyway and it just meant we brought forward the purchase by about 6 months. Obviously we lost the trade-in value ( about £1k) and we had to repay the outstanding loan so we could give it to them unencumbered ( about £1.5k) so there was a significant cost to us in doing this, but their need was greater than ours at the time.

A couple of months ago DH's car started playing up and we resigned ourselves to getting a replacement. This was about 2 years earlier than we had planned for but his commute has increased dramatically in the last 18 months so not surprising really that car has worn out. It would be a bit of a stretch to buy another car right now as we are still paying for mine and have another 2 years to go and so I posted on here about whether I would be unreasonable to ask family member for return of car ( they had since inherited another which is almost brand new and were no longer using the one we had given). The general consensus was that I was not BU.

Unfortunately before we contacted family member DH's car died and had to be scrapped ( garage told us not economic to fix). We had to go and buy a replacement car at short notice. I asked DH to contact family member (his side of family) to get return of car. We thought car may not really be suitable for DH but thought we would at least get something for trade-in and so be able to borrow less. DH was told that car has been sold. So nothing we can do.

So we take a loan and use all our savings to buy DH a second hand car.

Anyway, we are going on holiday with this family member soon and I emailed asking when we need to pay our share of holiday accommodation ( about £200). Family member calls DH to say that she and her DH will pay our share of the accommodation as thank you for giving them car and for other stuff that we have done over the years.

Now I know this is a really generous offer and I should be pleased and grateful but I feel really annoyed. It cost us £2.5k to give them the car and we did it gladly to help them out. But now they think that by paying £200 for our half of the accommodation ( we still have to pay our own travel) that we are in someway "even". They have just inherited £200k from the person who left them the car so I know they are feeling flush which is why they have done this but it leaves a bad taste in my mouth and I can't explain why. They don't know that the car still had finance on when we gave it to them but they must have realised that we would lose out on the trade-in. We have helped them out loads financially and practically over the years ( DH has given up countless weekends off, of which he gets very few, to go and redecorate their house which is a 6 hour round trip - they never even pay his fuel costs), he has laid laminate floor in their house on Xmas Eve because that was when they moved in and they wanted it doing on that day, he has landscaped gardens at 2 different properties, laid a patio, redecorated their hall, stairs and landing , the list goes on. The most he gets is a 4pack of beer.

I don't know why I feel like this. It's just that they are making it out to be some grand gesture they are doing for us ( they've told all the family) and part of me wishes they just hadn't. I'm sure IABU but I can't put my finger on why. Am I just woefully entitled ?

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 19/02/2014 18:08

Next time your DH is asked to help with decorating, gardening, whatever, say that you'll be happy to, but out-of-pocket expenses such as petrol will have to be paid for.

Or don't do it.

poshfrock · 19/02/2014 18:48

We did ask for petrol costs once. We were all going to visit for a weekend when SIL decided she wanted DH to do her patio. The patio and path running up the garden are large and BIL is as much use as a chocolate teapot when it comes to DIY so DH knew he would have to do it single-handed and it would therefore take about 4 days. So he would have to leave Friday am and return Monday pm on his long weekend "off". This would entail taking 2 cars as I work and DCS were at school so couldn't leave until Friday om and return Sunday pm.DH pointed out extra cost of taking 2 cars to facilitate patio building (not to mention loss of weekend supposedly spent relaxing with family and attending local music festival which had been original plan). She agreed to give him £40 (about half cost of fuel one for car) but was very cat's bum faced about it.

OP posts:
gimcrack · 19/02/2014 18:58

Chalk it up to experience. And be aware that their family culture is different to yours. In future, get DH to say no a bit more. He should also ask for petrol money if he does want to help - just say he's happy to help but your finances have changed so he can't help any more if it puts him out of pocket.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread