Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

which takes priority, my child my rules, or my house my rules?

57 replies

elfsmamma · 23/12/2013 21:43

I am in the midst of a family get together at my parents house, it's jolly most of the time but there are certain issues that me and my mum don't see eye to eye about.

The first is stairs, my ds is not yet 1 but has been walking since 10 months, he can crawl up and down stairs but ideally I'd prefer him not to think stairs are a fun play area. He understands not to go near things that are dangerous, for example he doesn't touch the Christmas tree because we have told him not to, I think we should also tell him not to go on the stairs. My mum thinks that babies should be allowed to fall down the stairs to help them learn how to use them safely. My parents house is a split level house over 5 floors with a very open plan lay out, so shutting the door and avoiding stairs isn't really an option.

The other issue is germs, my mum isn't worried about germs but I am, I actually really struggle with anxiety surrounding my dc's health. A member of the family had a tummy bug, I thought it would be sensible if I kept ds In a different room when possible to the person with a tummy bug ( vomiting child so in my opinion a fairly big infection risk) I appreciate the risk of catching the bug is fairly high when living in the same house but I'd at least like to attempt to avoid it. As it happens no one else seems to have gone down with the bug (so far) I think it was possibly excitement or a reaction to food as the child had no diarrhea or fever.

Me and my mum get on great most of the time, but in these cases who decides? I don't expect my mum to care for my dc, she wants to, when she does aibu to expect her to respect my rules? Aibu to expect her respect that it's my baby my rules and if I want to keep him away from ill people ( not expecting anyone else to change their plans, quite happy to hang out in our room or the 2nd living room or go out) and not let him play on stairs then it is my choices to make?

OP posts:
lljkk · 24/12/2013 11:04

Sorry this isn't working out for you, OP. The stairs thing would worry me.

I do think you have to supervise constantly, you can't make others mind baby the way you would (except sometimes if you have paid them). Must admit I was happy to let babies climb stairs if I stood below them; everything is play at that age, anyway.

Vomiting girl: I dread tummy bugs, but I am not sure I would think you were sane to insist baby can't ever be in same room with her. Across the room and no physical contact should be safe enough.

elliejjtiny · 24/12/2013 11:14

Your child, your rules unless they are breaking someone's property.

Having said that 2 of my DC's and my niece will be really close in age so we will probably adapt rules so they are the same for all eg if SIL doesn't want her PFB to have chocolate then I won't let DS4 and DC5 to have it when around DN.

whatever5 · 24/12/2013 14:16

YANBU to want to try to avoid a stomach bug or to not want to let your child play on the stairs.

The argument that your dc needs to fall down the stairs to learn how to use them safely is totally ridiculous. That's like saying that you need to be run over by a car to learn to cross the road safely!

brettgirl2 · 24/12/2013 14:21

yanbu re the tummy bug or the stairs. I would have done the same (in fact dd2 was sick on Friday, and I took dd1 out for the day leaving dh with the bleach.

I once caught my mil wiping dd1's face with a dishcloth. .... gross Shock

Lweji · 24/12/2013 17:06

Just to clarify, regarding the stomach bug, the main problem will be surfaces touched by the sick child and the toilet. I'd be bleaching the toilets regularly and wiping surfaces too. I hope they are washing any dirty clothes at over 60ºC

Unless the last bout was more than 48h ago, in which case I'd relax.

elfsmamma · 24/12/2013 21:34

Last vomiting was about 60 hours ago and there was no diarrhea so those particular germs are no longer a worry, now we have a lovely cold doing the rounds.

I used to wonder why there was often drama at Christmas, when I was childless I'd sit on the sofa with a glass of wine, peel some potatoes, load tge diswasherand wonder how Christmas could possibly cause family rifts. Ha ha ha.

OP posts:
breatheslowly · 24/12/2013 21:41

I'd describe it as "the most stringent rules win". In your case they are your rules.

As an example, we don't let DD sit on tables. If someone came round to our house with a child who was normally allowed to sit on tables, then I would expect them to follow our house rule of no sitting on tables.

Letting your child fall down stairs just seems like madness.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page