Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some fitness experts can put people off

35 replies

doingthesplitz · 29/07/2013 11:31

One of my colleagues wants to lose a few pounds and a few of us were chatting away giving her bits and pieces of advice from our own diet and exercise regimes. Then two people who are really really into fitness started butting in telling her it was no use simply cutting down on carbs she also had to do this, that and the other; spend half her life in the gym; walking was no use she needed to also join a gym and use weights and the exercise bike and weigh her food blah blah blah.
The girl' started to look more and more dispirited and I know in my heart and soul she had just lost any motivation and wasn't going to bother.
I've seen this before where the fitness experts come steaming in, turning their nose up at the idea of cutting down on sweet stuff and bread and going out for a walk every evening and start bossily instructing people "No, no. You must......." followed by a regime that would be fine if someone was training for a triatholon.
Why can some of these people not get that a lot of us just want to take a few simple steps to becoming fitter and slimmer, but are not planning to enter the London Marathon. I see it on some threads on here as well and by the time they're finished the original posters have long slinked quietly off the thread and are no doubt gloomily munching a cream cake and wondering why they thought it was worth bothering in the first place.
AIBU to wish that these fanatics would just tone it down sometimes and stop putting people off before they've even begun?

OP posts:
SmiteYouWithThunderbolts · 29/07/2013 14:53

oooh SummerHoliDidi you must have the patience of a saint. I would have lost it with DH long ago if he was that much of a PITA.

OP, YANBU. There is no point belittling or overwhelming someone trying to make minor changes to their lifestyle to make it healthier. All healthy steps are good ones, whether it's ditching the sugar from your tea and switching escalators for stairs, or joining a gym and weighing everything that passes your lips! Softly softly catchy monkey and all that.

arabesque · 29/07/2013 15:31

YANBU. I really hate it when someone rubbishes someone's efforts to lose weight and get fit, making them believe that unless they make major, major changes to their diet and lifestyle they might as well do nothing. Just starting to cut down on sugary food or carbs makes you a bit more aware of what you're eating; and getting into the habit of going for a 30 minute walk several times a week means you get used to a certain amount of exercise and notice when you don't do it and may even want to increase it after a while. All of these are positive changes that will help you lose weight and become fitter. No, they might not give you a figure like Jennifer Aniston or Keira Knightley but most people aren't aiming for that. They just want to lose a few pounds,tone up a bit, and be able to fit into a nice pair of jeans or a waisted Summer dress.

SummerHoliDidi · 29/07/2013 15:34

Well, in September he is going down to 4 days a week working, so I will be able to go to the gym, or go swimming if the pool is available, on the way home from work one day a week while he does the childcare. That should help a little. He also gets up with dd2 on Saturdays while I go to Slimming World, so maybe he wouldn't notice too much if I went to the gym after that.

bluesbaby · 29/07/2013 15:38

The all or nothing approach is pretty annoying in most aspects of life... my OH is either the most slothenly person ever, or a clean freak. It makes me see red when the switch happens, mainly because I spend an inordinate amount of time persuading him to close drawers and shut doors properly, and pick up clothes... then once every two months or so suddenly my standard of cleanliness is not good enough, and we have to do everything "properly". Well, if he didn't leave it so long there wouldn't be so much dust under his things...

Sorry. Rant Over.

He needs to get over himself. Can you have a code word that you agree, that when you say it, he needs to catch himself and shut the hell up?

If anything, making too many lifestyle changes (for health) at once is bad, you want to progress slowly so you're more likely to keep it up and maintain the weight loss, without yo-yoing. He needs to chill the hell out. I assume you still want to have some semblance of your old life while you're making these changes!

arabesque · 29/07/2013 15:46

Also, don't start me on those people who meet you for a meal and then spend the whole night fussing about what they can and can't eat; start quizzing the waiter about what ingredients are in every dish or refuse to eat anywhere that doesn't serve this, that or the other. If you have an allergy or a medical condition fair enough; but if you're dieting just assess the menu quietly and make the most suitable choice possible or decide you're off the diet for the night and enjoy yourself. The rest of the group really aren't interested!

ApocalypseThen · 29/07/2013 16:24

I wouldn't mind the over enthusiastic advice if they were only kind. But so often, the tone is scathing about things they've no business commenting on.

Lizzylou · 29/07/2013 16:29

You only have to read some exercise threads on here. Drives me mad!
If you are making changes and getting fitter then it doesn't matter how you do it, there is certainly no one size fits all approach to exercise or diet.
Not everyone wants to be an athlete or get a 6 pack.

vintageclock · 30/07/2013 11:33

This does my head in. Someone starts a thread saying 'hi, after many years of eating unhealthily and taking no exercise I have finally managed to stop eating rubbish between meals and am also going out for a 30 minute walk 5 times a week. However, it's hard to stay motivated so am looking for encouragement on here'.
A few people post back saying 'Good for you' 'keep it up. It'll be worth it when you get back into that size 12 dress' etc and all is going well. Then some fanatic comes racing energetically onto the thread 'walking is no good. You need to get a personal trainer and go cross country running 4 mornings a week followed by some weight training in the gym. And is that a packet of pasta in your cupboard? No, no, noooo. That's not the way to do it' and on and on, totally misreading the mood of the thread.

Also, I can vaguely remember the days when going for a walk meant pulling on a pair of sensible shoes and just going. Nowadays you have to be head to toe in Nike with a pedometre in one hand and a stop watch in the other and an ipod hanging out of your ear.

Lizzylou · 30/07/2013 12:38

Grin Vintage, you have totally summed up my thoughts!

Filimou · 30/07/2013 14:14

There is a girl like that where I work. makes me Sad
I put on quite a bit while pregnant and it all went a bit downhill. When I had a realisation that I actually felt really fat, I decided to eat better and exercise more. I cut out snacking at work and eat meals that are more nutritionally balanced. I also try and exercise when I can and have so almost lost two stone. My clothes feel better, I feel healthier...I am so very proud of this.
Then my colleague comes out with "but your exercise plan is a bit hit and miss, sometimes you can go a week without exercising, and doing DVD's at home is rubbish you have to have a plan, a proper trainer".
Thanks.
Dickhead.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page