Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To try to resurrect this friendship...

34 replies

englishbreakfast · 01/07/2013 22:13

Sorry, this is quite long, but I'd like some thoughts please regarding a situation with an ex-friend. I've been close friends with N for about 14 years, we'd meet as couples with her DP and my DH, celebrate most birthdays and Christmases together, go on holidays etc. I initiated most of the contact, but she was like this with all her other friends and even family, so I didn't mind. She's had on /off depression for years and lots of issues with her mum from when she was growing up, so I kind of thought that maybe that was the reason she wasn't great at keeping in touch with people generally. Just over 2 years ago we had our DD, and gradually our friends started distancing themselves and there would always be a reason why they couldn't meet up with us. I had PND and DD had some issues in the first few months, but when I tried to talk to N about how I was feeling a couple of times, she seemed quite dismissive. During that time I'd kept in touch with her through occasional calls and texts and we saw them a few times, but when I invited them to DH & DD's joint birthday party (DD's 1st birthday so a big deal for me), she didn't respond to my text for a week and then when I gently prompted by another text to check if they'd be coming, she just replied to say they couldn't.

Several months later we saw them at a mutual friend's birthday and N was really off with me but won't tell me why. We saw them twice after that and things seemed better so I thought we were over whatever the issue was. However, over the following 4 - 5 months they'd again be busy every time we'd suggest to meet, and would never call us themselves. They have a very small social circle and we were their closest friends, so it just didn't feel right. In the end, I texted N to say that I felt like we were becoming distant and that our friendship was disappearing. She replied to say that yes, the friendship was not the same as we've both changed and maybe one day she'd talk to me about it. This really upset me as I had no idea what the issue was, so I emailed her and her DP basically saying that we were very upset that they didn't want to be our friends and that they have distanced themselves from us with no explanation, and if there was something that we did to upset them, we wished they'd have told us. They did not respond and we have had no contact since then. I know that she has since told a mutual friend that yes, she was off with me at the birthday party but wouldn't say why, but that she did not mean that they never wanted to see us again and I misunderstood.

I still feel sad about the loss of this friendship. I think that maybe I over-reacted (well, I'm pretty sure I have and probably shouldn't have sent that email but I was feeling really hurt). However, I also can't help thinking that if things were the other way around and my best friend misunderstood me to such an extent, I'd have let her know and tried to talk to her to resolve the misunderstanding! So, AIBU to consider making contact with N again to see if anything can be salvaged of this friendship?

OP posts:
pigletmania · 05/07/2013 02:32

She has treated you very badly, jst leave this friendship in the past where it belongs

Jan49 · 05/07/2013 02:47

It sounds like the issue might be having children - you have a child and she can't/doesn't/might never have. I would just let this friendship go. If it's an issue around him not wanting dc and her wanting them, maybe she feels out of loyalty to him she can't tell you that? It might be that she feels she can't be friends now you have a dc, so even if she explained, your friendship would still be lost.

I don't think I'd want to salvage the friendship if I were you. She's treated you badly. There are lots of people in the world. You don't need to run after someone who isn't worth it.

Elquota · 05/07/2013 12:10

If Jan49 is right that she's having fertility problems then it could be that she and her DP have agreed not to discuss it with others. You don't know what she may have been through. Who knows, maybe she had a miscarriage the day before you were wanting her to discuss babies with you or do something baby-related. And sometimes it's just impossible to put on that brave face everyone expects. So please do cut her some slack and I think she'll talk to you when she feels able to, and will appreciate your patience at this time.

JRmumma · 05/07/2013 12:39

Agree with Jan and Elq above. It sounds like you havent done anything wrong per se, but that maybe it is hard for her to see you with your DC as she cant have this for whatever reason. If you had really upset her, then i dont think she would have avoided you by saying they were busy when you wanted to meet up etc, she would have just ignored you completely. The fact that she might discuss whatever it is with you someday also suggests that its something she needs to work through and if it is something like accepting that she will never be able to have a child, then this may take some years.

Agree that maybe keeping up xmas/birthday cards and possibly (depending on whether you think its appropriate or not) still extending an invite to occasions you would have previously, but maybe not anything DC-related, is a good idea and keeps the door open for her if thats what you want.

Doesnt seem like there is anything else you can do at this point but try not to let it occupy you too much or upset you for too long. Some frienships do fizzle out for a variety of reasons, even long ones. I parted ways with my childhood best friend when I was about 20 as i suddenly realised that she was quite frankly a sh*t mate. Im not sure she ever understood the actual reason that I stopped being her friend but I had to just walk away and just break contact as it was for the best. When you have such a shared history with someone it is like losing a partner or a sister, but sometimes stepping away from someone is the best thing for you. Im not saying you were a bad friend to her, but if for whatever reason she has decided that she doesnt want to be friends with you anymore, then you have to accept that as she has the right to chose who she is friends with.

HildaOgden · 05/07/2013 12:54

It could well be a pyschological reaction with her....before you had your daughter,she just saw you as 'you'.

Now she sees you as a mother.And her own mother issues could be stabbing at her...seeing you have a close mother/daughter bond could well be (even subconsciously) making her uncomfortable and jealous(not of you having a baby,but of having a normal loving bond that she missed out on).

There is nothing you can do about this,it is her issue to fix.

Squitten · 05/07/2013 13:01

The bottom line in all this is that you have asked for some explanation repeatedly and she is refusing to give you one. No matter what the reason behind it, I think that is really cruel. If a close friend of mine took issue with me, even if it was over something very personal like fertility, I would expect that they would at least be able to say "Look, it's nothing you have done, it's just some personal stuff, etc." You don't have to lay your entire life out in order to put someone's mind at ease!

She has made the choice to end the friendship, even if she won't be honest about that with your mutual friends. I think you have to accept that you have tried to get to the bottom of it but she's not interested in fixing things, and let it go.

ThreeEyedRaven · 05/07/2013 14:20

I had a very simular situation once. Tried for 2 years to make it work. Nothing good ever came of it. Personally I think the best thing you can do is walk away. Even if you do resurrect this friendship, she sounds likely to go off on one again.

Sorry OP

Mintyy · 05/07/2013 15:13

Even if your good friend is having horrendous fertility problems (or whatever) treating your mates so dismally is unacceptable. Really.

Let it go and be thankful that you do not need to be friends with such an unpleasant person any more.

englishbreakfast · 05/07/2013 20:34

Thank you everyone for sharing your thoughts. I know that she ended up upsetting me quite badly, but I don't think she's a bad or uncaring person, just her issues do sometimes affect her perspective on things so I actually hope it was that or me doing something to upset rather than anything to do with infertility / conception problems as that would be awful for her...am going to let this go and be grateful for the friends I have got. Who knows maybe one day all will become clear! :) x

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread