Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think I should tell the parent?

29 replies

cherryade8 · 01/06/2013 14:03

My sister has two dds. One has health problems which has resulted in overnight stays in hospital (emergencies so unplanned) both times she's asked our dm to look after the younger dd during the day so she and her dh can be at the hospital with older dd.

Our dad can be a very selfish and unpleasant man. He actually resents having his grandchild for the day whilst they are at hospital, even though it is our mum looking after her. I live three hours drive away and as these are emergency situations I would struggle to be there to help, but yesterday I happened to be visiting our parents at the time of an emergency and so dsis dropped off her dd (aged 2) and I looked after her, with dm. However, my dad was extremely unpleasant and even started almost snarling at his grandchild because she was touching things in his living room. He thinks children/toddlers should have more discipline, be grateful for having a toy to play with etc. If she made any noise he nastily told her off etc so I went out in the garden to play with her as well as my own ds, 18mo. I didn't cause a scene because I didn't want to make it even more unpleasant for the children. But my father's behaviour and unpleasantness sent a chill down my spine.

Dm says she would never let him be on his own with dsis dd and hopefully she doesnt realise how much he dislikes her being there. I only visit for dm sake and would never leave a child with my father. Dm and my dh say I shouldn't tell dsis about dads behaviour towards her dd, but I feel she has a right to know so that she can ask someone else to look after her dd if there's another emergency (dm would get given am even harder time by dad if she looked after her gc at dsis house, as I said he's a very unpleasant man but dm won't leave him..)

Aibu to tell dsis, even though it would cause a big family fall out? Her dd isn't being physically hurt but I'd hate to unknowingly expose my child to such unpleasantness, dsis obviously knows dad can be unpleasant but he's never been horrible to her dd in front of her..

OP posts:
flanbase · 01/06/2013 18:35

You must tell your sis. If she hasn't realised she'll at least be able to make an informed choice on childcare

quesadilla · 01/06/2013 19:16

Does your dsis not suspect this though OP? I am assuming you were both brought up by him (correct me if bit), but she must know what he is capable of? Has she never been around him with her dcs?

I am in the camp that feels you should tell her. If my dd was at the slightest risk of unpleasant or bullying behaviour by a member of my family I would want to told.

I would be surprised if it came as a huge shock to her if she know him at all...

quesadilla · 01/06/2013 19:17

Correct me if not

cherryade8 · 01/06/2013 22:53

Thanks for the replies. Yes, dsis does know what he's like but I think she naively thought as it was just a few hours whilst she and her dh were changing over at the hospital and speaking to doctors etc that her dd would be ok. she's never left her dc with dm and him before. Unfortunately I'm unlikely to be able to help at short notice as I live several hours drive away, but I'm sure dsis has other childcare options. I think part of the reason she asked dm and dad was at the first emergency they offered to help look after her dd whilst she went to the hospital.

Tbh even I was shocked he could be so unpleasant towards a toddler who was only in his house a few hours whilst her parents were at hospital. I will definitely tell her once her dd1 is out of hospital. Thanks again.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread