Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be as rude as her...

8 replies

thatdoesntsurpriseme · 26/02/2013 16:32

Have NCed as Dh knows my nickname and obviously I dont want him to know this is me...

Things have been a bit hard for DH recently for various reasons and he is missing his friends a bit. His birthday is in a couple of months and so I would like to throw him a surprise party. He's 25, so not milestone, but enough of a step to warrant a decent party.

Slight issue is that one of his best friends has the same birthday as him. it's never been an issue in the past as they've always had joint parties/dinners/drinks, and to be honest I would have been happy to continue this tradition (as would DH) had it not been for last year. Last year, the BF's DP (who I shold mention is also one of my DH's best friends, them all having gone to uni together) organised him a party for the BF without even mentioning it to my DH. It was a bit shocking when she invited me and DH to this party which was held on their joint birthday date without even so much as an acknowledgement that DH might not be able/want to come due to the date. DH wasn't that keen on going as he knew it was the BF's sole party, meaning that onlty the BF's friends would be there, rather than a mixture of their friends like normal - they have mutual friends, but obviously other separate groups of friends that usually come together on that date too.

She did this about a month before his birthday so it was too early for us to have arranged anything. We did some things with DH's other group of friends, but all of their mutual friends did go to the BF's party as it was organised first. Glad we didn't go in the end as it turned out she'd got a cake just for the BF with his name on it and iniststed on giving him his presents at the party etc etc.

Anyway, none of that was really anything to get too "knickers in a knot" about, it's just that i am worried about organisaing DH a surprise party because of the mutual friend situation. If I just go ahead and arrange it, I'm as bad as her and do exactly what she did last year, putting mutual friends in an awkward situation and being rude to her and the BF, but otherwise, I have to ask her first and i feel a bit reluctant to do this given the lack of courtesy from her last year and the fact that making it a joint party sort of takes away the point of it.

I am happy to make it a different date and can tell her this, but should I really even be worrying? WIBU to just organise it and stuff her?

OP posts:
thatdoesntsurpriseme · 26/02/2013 16:46

Loads of traffic today so giving a little bump!

OP posts:
quoteunquote · 26/02/2013 16:47

Organise it for the Saturday before the birthday, assuming that the birthday doesn't fall on a Saturday, that way the date doesn't belong to anyone, and it will really be a surprise.

cees · 26/02/2013 16:49

No you shouldn't be worrying because it's a none issue, just have his birthday and never mind what they do.

thatdoesntsurpriseme · 26/02/2013 16:56

The birthday does fall on a saturday annoyingly.

It is definitely an issue because two best friends with birthdays on the same day cant have a party on their actual birthday with ALL of their friends in attendance unless its joint. If you get my point...

OP posts:
KurriKurri · 26/02/2013 16:57

Your Dh's birthday plans (and yours regarding surprising him) are nothing to do with your friend. She simply happens to have a birthday on the same day.
Go ahead with your plans and don't worry about what she is doing, - I would suggest that the fact that she had a 'sole' party last year is an indication that she and her DP want to stop the joint party tradition.

KurriKurri · 26/02/2013 17:00

Ok I got muddled over who is male and who is female in the friends Grin
Bit I'd still say the same, the DP wants to stop the joint party thing, which actually is fair enough IMO. Make your DH's party at a different time of day - either very late or early, then people can go to both if they clash.

KC225 · 26/02/2013 17:02

I agree with Kurri - maybe last year was an indication they want to stop the joint birthday party. They are grown men who share the same birth day. They are not 4 year old twins. Do your party - invite them early and don't be offended if they decline

DiseasesOfTheSheep · 26/02/2013 17:53

I'm failing to understand why you took it so personally that the friend decided to have a solo party last year - it's not really unreasonable of them in the scheme of things. It's just how things work - people celebrate their birthdays with their friends, often not even on the date of the birthday itself, and friends attend if they can and they wish to. I really wouldn't worry about it - just organise whatever you want to do, invite whoever you want and enjoy it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread