Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to XP's request to keep dd for an extra day?

36 replies

Imabadmum · 27/12/2012 06:45

Dd is now 13, and her dad and i have been separated since she was 15months. Both of us have remarried and have had more children since (he 2xdd, me 2xds). My current DH also had a dd from his first marriage who is now 14. Between us we have come up with a system to share Christmases, by alternating them. This year it was the turn of the other parents to have the dd's so my dd went to her dads on the 21st Dec at 8.30am (collected by him), as did my dsd go to her mum. Both girls are due home tomorrow, when we will do their presents. My dd is booked in for the opticians on friday afternoon, and riding lesson on Saturday morning, a family lunch (with all the gp's) is arranged for Sunday. I go back to work on the 2nd Jan.

My XP has requested by text that he keep her until sat as his dm and ds are coming to visit on Friday and she hasn't seen them for a while. I've said no, as I now only have 5 days until I go back to work, and i want to spend some time with her. He has had her for a full week and i would have thought the could have arranged the visit earlier. His dm is married to a Muslim so they do not really celebrate Christmas in her house and his ds is single with no children or ties of her own. I don't see why they couldn't have come on either Thursday (today) or even Boxing day to spend time with her except that they (XP, his wife and their kids) have spent Christmas with her mother and don't plan to return to their own home until Friday.

I very rarely say no to any of his requests for extra visits, or swapping weekends about because it is important to my dd and to me that she has a good relationship with her dad and her half sisters. He didn't see her at all in december before the xmas week because she had dancing commitments and was on a French trip, and he and his dw were going to his works Xmas party. None of these missed weekends were my fault or my requests.

So..... AIBU to say no to the extra day?

OP posts:
Daddelion · 27/12/2012 08:50

'Threads like this make me glad dd1's father was never about. Shared accesss is a pita isn't it?!'

A pita for the parents maybe, pretty good for the children, and I would have thought they're the priority.

But I am a father so I get a bit twitchy about comments like that, as I know how easy it is to brush a father out of his children's lives as I've seen it happen.

Inertia · 27/12/2012 08:59

If she has been with her dad for a week (and presumably access dates were known well in advance) , then he's had plenty of time to arrange visits with relatives.

I would just say that it's not possible to change dates this time as you have already made arrangements involving DD.

TheSecondComing · 27/12/2012 09:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TheSecondComing · 27/12/2012 09:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MagicHouse · 27/12/2012 09:08

I think having her back when you arranged is fine. Like you say he's had a week to organise his visitors, and another weekend coming up if that week was difficult.

Imabadmum · 27/12/2012 09:19

Kitty, I think you have made a good point, about just wanting to slag him off. I got his response when I woke up this morning, and thought grrrrrrr, then AIBU? So I posted. I think many MN's recognise that the AIBU threads are filled with people wanting to vent their spleens, than actually wanting other peoples opinions.

I really did want to know if iabu, but if part of this is about getting it off my chest, better so here, in peace (no ranting in my house in front of the other dc's) and relative anonymity. Better that than a heated row on the phone with him, with my dd listening at his end and my dc listening at mine.

He didn't rant, but was peevish about it, and made me feel that I was being unreasonable.

OP posts:
Onezerozero · 27/12/2012 09:28

I don't think YABU.

Imabadmum · 27/12/2012 09:29

Thank you all, I feel better now! Am off to enjoy my day and look forward to seeing dd tomorrow and doing her and dsd's Christmas at ours x

OP posts:
KittyFane1 · 27/12/2012 20:49

Ah, I'm glad you feel better! You're right, MN is a good place to vent!

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 27/12/2012 21:07

Glad it's sorted but wondered, if it's an hour's drive away between you - can you not meet up at a halfway point? If not this time, next time?

2rebecca · 27/12/2012 21:17

I don't give my teenage kids a choice of where to go once plans are made. They get a choice before plans are made in where to go at holidays (as long as they are acceptable to my ex and I, (they get limited choices we are OK about first so they don't feel they are having to choose between us or pit us against each other ). Once arrangements are made they are only changed if unforeseen circumstances/ emergencies arrive though so they don't get taught it is acceptable to mess people about and change plans at the last moment. Relatives visiting over the xmas period isn't an emergency, your ex knew when his daughter would be there and should have given this info to his mother when the arrangements were made and arranged for her to come earlier or asked to have his daughter at a different time to fit in with his mother.
I had my kids over Christmas and wouldn't have took them back any later than arranged as their dad had made plans for his family to be there when I dropped them off with him. Arranging late visits from my other relatives and getting the kids to "choose" isn't nice for anyone.
If parents are to have a civil relationship post divorce they have to make plans and stick to them and not muck each other and the kids about.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page