I would say QS, but then again I do enjoy a good toffee. The last time we had roses, they were dull and had changed beyond all recognition.
We don't have tins this year, they seem poor value and a mighty rip off, you get hardly any sweets in them these days. I would rather that they were more expensive and you got a lot in them, than now, where you pay £4 and get about 20 sweets.