Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to veto this Christmas present price capping?

27 replies

Cbh1978 · 02/12/2012 16:36

My partner's sisters are millionaires. With a lot of disposable cash they spend on new cars, flash holidays etc. They have had a chat, and between themselves and their mother, have decided that

A) we spend up to £10 on each person's Christmas presents
B) because one sister has three children, we should buy for the three children but not their parents. However, they will buy for our son plus us, as that makes three presents (?!).

We are skint and always overdrawn by thousands etc. On the one hand this sounds like a top plan. On the other, it is hardly very christmassy. And a bit odd not to be consulted about this new 'policy'.

In the past, my partner has chosen beautiful, thoughtful gifts for her family. They have not really reciprocated the thoughtfulness. And I would be surprised if their gifts cost as much as £10. One year, my partner and I were given two books marked '2 for £10'. Perhos we shuld have a £5 policy?...

Have always found it a bit odd, but we are not materialistic so don't mind. It is more the lack of thought, given my partner will spend hours creating photobooks etc for them

It is not that they are being kind to us, as I don't think they know how hard up we are.

So, any other theories for the £10 cap? Won't our nieces think we are a bit mean for not buying their parents anything when their parents give us something?

I vote to veto the policy -especially given we were not asked - but would appreciate your (gentle!) thoughts...

OP posts:
Busyoldfool · 02/12/2012 20:44

I agree with Twitchy - for me it is the whole idea of enforced present giving and receiving that I hate. A £10 cap means I can buy chocolate or toiletries for people and not worry that I have spent hundreds on something that if they had wanted they'd have bought for themsleves. I also hate that sinking feeling when I am given an obviously expensive, thoughtful gift that I just don't want or need.

It is no reflection on how much I love people, I am happy to give my time or help if they need it, or give/lend money - the usual things that we do for people we care about. BUT I do not see the point in spending many stresssful hours trying to second guess what they might love.

We had a £5 cap for everyone last year and came up with some delightful things, (mini lego, eyeliner pencil, special chocs, small tube luxury hand cream etc)

CaptainVonTrapp · 02/12/2012 20:54

OP are you male or female? I just assumed from your biscuit thread you were a woman now it seems thats not necessarily so...

I would buy what you want wrt the presents. Bit cheeky aren't they - deciding for you? Although they probably had good intentions.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page