Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is this a weird and a bit off thing to say to your daughter?

22 replies

quesadilla · 22/11/2012 23:03

My parents are old and mum has dementia. I try to visit at least once a month with dd (2) and sometimes DH. This weekend is going to be the last chance DH has to see them before going to his country of birth for Xmas. (Dd and I are joining him out there for NY). I called my dad and said if it was ok we might come down. He hesitated and said: "er, that might be tricky because (my sister and my aunt) would be going there for dinner. Just as context, they live in a big house (four spare bedrooms) so space isn't an issue. Me and dd and DH pretty much have to stay as we don't have a car. Sister and aunt are just going for dinner, not staying over. But we stay regularly, it's never an issue. We always do all the housework and cooking when we go and usually go halves on groceries. have a good relationship with sister and aunt - no issues there that I'm aware of. My dad is gregarious and isn't the sort of person to be overwhelmed by having too many people in the house. Am I over-reacting or is it a bit off - when there are no logistical challenges for them - for him to imply that he would rather I not join members of my own family at his house for dinner?

OP posts:
Megan74 · 22/11/2012 23:06

My parents are old and mum has dementia.

Maybe its more to do with how your mum would cope. Can't you just ask him?

dearcathyandclare · 22/11/2012 23:07

Maybe your Mum is really struggling now with too many people around and your Dad being protective? Alternatively he may be exhausted with coping and putting on a good front?

maxcliffordslovechild · 22/11/2012 23:09

Perhaps he just doesn't want your mum overwhelmed with lots of visitors. Too much going on can be upsetting for people living with dementia.

GrimAndHumourless · 22/11/2012 23:09

perhaps they have made plans to talk about issues - your aunt is your mum's sister

caring for a person with dementia is very VERY hard, emotionally draining and sapping; your dad prob just cannot BEAR to think about organsing fresh linen for you, no matter how much you say airily oh WE'LL do the housework/shopping/blah blah

JeezyOrangePips · 22/11/2012 23:10

It sounds to me that it could well be more to do with your mum being overwhelmed rather than your dad.

quesadilla · 22/11/2012 23:10

Dearcathy: I have considered that but he's generally really up for having as many people in the house as possible: in large part because of my mum's condition. I hope I don't sound entitled - it's just that it's very out of character for him.

OP posts:
dearcathyandclare · 22/11/2012 23:10

just re-read your post and it sounds like carer stress.Could you go down just you and dd before you join your dh abroad?

PomBearWithAnOFRS · 22/11/2012 23:10

That would make me think there was something going on that Dad was trying to avoid telling me. Hopefully it's nothing, or something very minor - I am a "worrit" and would be all stressed until I found out, and chances are it wouldn't be anything anywhere near as bad as my imagination made it, but it would bug me and I would either just come right out and ask, or "ferret around" and see if I could find anything out.
There could be hundreds of reasons, but unless you ask, he might never tell you Confused - maybe he doesn't want to worry you about something.

GrimAndHumourless · 22/11/2012 23:10

oh yes, your Mum might be needing less disruption, good point

any interruption to routine can be distressing

floweryblue · 22/11/2012 23:10

Speak to your sister and aunt?

quesadilla · 22/11/2012 23:11

Grim: no my aunt is my dad's (half) sister. And not particurly close to my mum.

OP posts:
dearcathyandclare · 22/11/2012 23:14

If you are usally close dad is probably trying to protect everyone especially your Mum.

GrimAndHumourless · 22/11/2012 23:15

support for your Dad then.

Or are you worried that they are planning to Do You Out Of £££?

dearcathyandclare · 22/11/2012 23:16

Grim that sounds harsh!

EnjoyResponsibly · 22/11/2012 23:19

OP things change, dementia must be a very terribly draining condition to live with. Throw in guests and overnighters (although dearly loved and wanted) I'm betting DF is bloody knackered and defeated.

hhhhhhh · 22/11/2012 23:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TwitchyTail · 22/11/2012 23:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

quesadilla · 23/11/2012 07:32

Twitchy tail: "he's just not that into you..."
This is my FATHER we are talking about... That's a weird and slightly creepy way to approach this conversation, don't you think? I do totally get why someone caring for a relative with dementia might feel overwhelmed. It's just that he's generally gagging for company of any sort. Normally he can't get enough of us. It was more the way heseemed to be positioning g it as if it would be awkward to have me and my sister and aunt together as if there had been some falling out. I just thought it was a strange way to couch it. But maybe I am underestimating his general stress levels.

OP posts:
AmandaCooper · 23/11/2012 07:48

I think Twitchy added that last option to make the point that there's bound to be some good reason, it's clearly not that he just randomly doesn't like you any more.

CatsRule · 23/11/2012 10:02

If your Aunt or Sister see your parents regularly could you maybe call one of them to see if all is well?

I don't mean go behind your Dads back, just because you are concerned as it is out of character what he said.

I know when my Dad wasn't well he and my Mum would put a face on for my sister and I, not because we aren't close or wouldn't help, just because they wanted to protect us even as adults. Could your Dad be doing that for some reason?

whizmum · 23/11/2012 11:54

Maybe he is 'stressed' about his sister visiting and wants to get it all right, and you just called at the wrong moment. He might have just been a bit tired.

I would talk to everyone, aunt sister etc, and change plans if that would make him happier. It may be better if you go if you can do lots of washing up etc and looking after mum and make it easier for him to talk to his sister.

If he has liked you all his life, I am sure it is not because he has gone off you - it may be because he feels more able to say this to you!

StanleyLambchop · 23/11/2012 12:01

Maybe he is trying to spread the guests out so that he does not get all the visitors in one go and then none for a while. If you say he is normally eager for company, then he might be worried that he will not have any 'breaks' from caring if he does not stagger his visitors.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread