Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think this TA was rude?

58 replies

confuddledDOTcom · 28/10/2012 01:51

My 6yo daughter has a name that has a shortening that I personally don't like, it was one of the weighing factors to giving her this name but we decided if we stuck to calling her by her name until she was old enough to decide for herself what she would be called the others would and that has worked. My daughter also hates this shortening! Not because we've said anything to her, she just loves her full name (the whole thing, middle names and surname too). Her dad recently realised she hates it and will call it her if he's trying to play her up, which works, she'll start trying to beat him up.

At school there are two teachers who call it her and when they do she breathes in deeply through her nose whilst pushing her lips out. I've asked her why she doesn't say anything about it but she won't, it's not in her nature. I was talking to a senior member of staff recently and mentioned it, she said she'd noticed she hated it too and would make sure people know not to call it her.

About a week later she comes home from school and says "[TA] said she has to call me... because my name is so long and she has lots of children" her name is 6 letters long and "shortening" it makes it 5 letters and not much quicker to say. I'm not sure if this is in response to the senior teacher saying something or she's stood up for herself, but either way if someone doesn't like being called a name, isn't it rude to tell them their name is too long and they have other people's names to think about?

OP posts:
whatatwat · 30/10/2012 08:47

Did I read correctly upthread that a parent is unhappy that the school is trying to get their child to write their name in the correct full version?
Seriously. It's the child's name. Of course they need to learn to recognise and write it.

Thistledew · 30/10/2012 09:14

I would step on this hard and insist that the TA use her preferred name. I went through a similar thing at secondary school - I am, and have been all my life, known by my middle name. It was when I started the second year of secondary school that the teachers found out that my known name was my middle name and started insisting on calling me by my first name.

I was also suffering a bit of low level bullying at that time, which I had until then been able to keep on top of. When the teachers decided to change my name despite my wishes, it really knocked my confidence and also seemed to give out a signal to the other children that it was ok to behave in a way that made me unhappy. The bullying really escalated from that point and never really got better.

I think because names are so tied up in our identities it is very rude not to respect a person's wishes regarding how they wish to be identified.

CoffeeDog · 30/10/2012 09:22

There are 3 Alexanders at my twins nursery ...

1 likes being called Alexander, 1 likes to be called Alex , and at the moment my little chap likes to be called Lexy (i hate this but he LOVES it) they are all 3/4 years old.

the teachers / staff at the nursery always listen to whta the children want to be called that week - My chap was known as 'tiger' for a few days ... I tend to call him that at home... especially if the twins have there backs to me and i have no idea which one is which ;)

confuddledDOTcom · 30/10/2012 14:53

I don't think it's any ruder than thinking you're the only one who can change someone's name, Zombie. If you'd quoted further on you'd answer your own question. He has to drop her at morning club to get the youngest one to nursery so there aren't teachers around to talk to.

I can't imagine that she would have thought to make up a story like that and bit of a coincidence it happens the week after (I went in at the end of the week) I mentioned it to the senior teacher, I didn't even tell her that I'd been into school. We do get a running commentary on everything that goes on but she's not known for lying or making things up.

OP posts:
ZombieArmsDragOnTheFloor · 30/10/2012 15:19

No, quoting further on wouldn't have answered anything. If you have a problem with school a parent makes the time to go in and sort it. You don't teach your 6 yo child smart arse responses which are just plain rude.

The things my Y2 tells me have their roots in truth but the whole story is rarely what actually happened. For example, the TA may have been making a joke. This happened to my Y5 son - I could see it was a joke, he could not and took it at face value. A simple chat with the teacher sorted it out, no huffing, puffing or stomping required.

As a teacher once said on MN "If you promise not to believe everything your child tells you about school, I promise not to believe everything they tell me about home"

FolkGhoul · 30/10/2012 15:27

Yes Zombie, those were wise words indeed!

CrapBag · 30/10/2012 15:28

My DS's reception teacher was shortening his name. I don't shorten it and I always make a point of emphasising his full name to people who shorten it. I did briefly say to the TA one day that we prefer x (full name) and she said thats fine and she would tell the teacher. They now use his full name.

They should respect what you as the parents and what your DD wants to be referred as.

confuddledDOTcom · 30/10/2012 15:39

She doesn't huff puff and stomp her feet, she sighs. Not even enough for people who do it to notice - obviously those who don't notice it. You don't know what I've taught her because I haven't said what her name is or what the answers to the question are.

I do believe my daughter when she tells me things because I know when she's lying, which is very rare. I can't believe a 6 year old would think of the miliseconds it takes to drop one letter from her name would add up. If the teacher has come out with that line (even in jest!) she has been told either by the senior teacher or by my daughter, so even as a joke, it is rude.

This is the point I'm trying to get at in this thread,

this teacher has obviously been told by someone and feels that she is exempt because she's too busy

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page