Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my sister is in denial about her DD (long)

29 replies

Flugelpip · 26/10/2012 22:07

This is a genuine question as I really don't know if I'm being fair to her. I fear she's letting her DD down, and I don't know what to do, if anything.

Background: I had Dd1 6 months before she had her DD. Mine is totally normal, by which I mean good at some things, awful at others, very charming. According to my sister, MY child is a genius and amazing. In fact, my DD is neither (though I love her, obviously). Her cousin, sister's DD, is way behind her in development, and way behind her peer group, which is what actually worries me. I know children are all different and it's not one thing that worries me; it's all of them together.

She didn't move much as a baby - sat at 10/11 months, I think, walked at 20 months but reluctantly, seemed lost in a fog all the time. She was hard to engage - never looked at where you pointed, never noticed much, never played with toys for long or creatively. She has never played a game with me - not even peepo. She's nearly three and has a vocabulary of maybe 50 words, a lot of which are numbers, colours and animal noises, which my sister has taught her practically since birth. She can sing nursery rhymes without pronouncing the words properly (so I think doesn't know what she's singing) and otherwise doesn't speak in sentences at all. She still doesn't walk brilliantly. She does do role play games (pretending to cook etc) but doesn't play with her dolls to act out situations or play imaginatively. To me, she seems more like an 18 month old than a three year old. She doesn't understand basic instructions and certainly not two-part commands. She's prone to bad temper and lashing out but most of the time she's sunny and sweet, although still not engaged with her world. The temper could be frustration at communication problems but she has always been like that, even as a very small child.

I've repeatedly hinted/said to my sister that I would talk to their GP if I was her to rule out hearing or sight issues, at least, as she was slow to walk and now talk. (I get on with her well and it wasn't taken badly but it was ignored.) The health visitor told her not to worry, which is now gospel, but I suspect my sister didn't give her the whole picture as she was more asking about tantrums than development and at the time her lack of speech wasn't all that unusual at that age, but she hasn't improved since. Now she is insisting her DD is normal and mine is just very talented, which is not my point, or true. Sister works full time and lives in an area where it's hard to meet other mums so I think she just doesn't have anyone to compare her DD to. She also has a real Pollyanna approach - if she thinks everything is fine, it will be. This is how she deals with life, not just motherhood. My niece has a nanny, who is too professional to discuss her with me, not that I would ask her to, but from things she's said (desperately hoping sister would take her to the GP to discuss development) I infer she is concerned too. My brother- in-law is equally busy, unfamiliar with children, glass half full. They both think she is lovely but thick (and say this in front of her Sad).

I love my sister and niece; I'm very worried that my niece has some delay that could or should be picked up and treated. I'm not a doctor. I don't know much at all about it. If she was my child I would have dragged her around every health professional I could find to make sure I wasn't missing anything, and I'd have done it years ago. I'm frustrated with my sister but for my niece's sake. And I may be being paranoid. My DD is clouding the issue as I think my sister feels I'm unfair in comparing them, but I don't expect them to be the same. I do see children the same age as my niece all the time, and my niece is nowhere near them, or children much younger. Her own sister is 11 months old and sharp as a tack - walking already. Yet no alarm bells are ringing for my sister about her older child.

Thoughts? Suggestions? Reassuring anecdotes? Biscuits?

OP posts:
EllenJaneisstillnotmyname · 27/10/2012 00:20

No, don't go behind her back and talk to the health visitor!

I've just put on another thread that I was the Queen of Denial when my DS2 was young. I'm sure your DSis is worried, if she ever says anything to you, just be supportive. Never say, 'But lots of DC are late at this or that.' It will just give false reassurance. Agree, if she brings anything up, and explain that you are no expert, but that perhaps she is right to be concerned, and should follow it up.

But if she is still firmly in denial, you bringing it up isn't going to help.

EllenJaneisstillnotmyname · 27/10/2012 00:21

Yes, post on SN board. It'll be quiet this late, but maybe tomorrow?

Flugelpip · 27/10/2012 01:03

I will put it on SN but I think I have a much better sense of what I should do from your remarks. I'm going to see what happens with the nursery - it has a good reputation, apparently, so I hope they'll be on the ball. I don't think I can say anything, can I? It looks as if I'm saying I know her DD better than she does, which is obviously untrue.

Just to clarify a bit more, because they were very inclined to baby her, the physical slow development was a bit inconclusive. She just wasn't allowed to do things, and not encouraged. And they weren't surprised that she couldn't do things because they don't expect her to be able to. They are good and loving parents to a child who has not been easy at all, but they just don't know a lot about children of that age (and nor did I). With the slow language development, I'm more convinced there is an issue.

Because our mother is hell, I always sort family things. Hence being involved at all.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 27/10/2012 06:24

Is she having a problem with her husband, Flugelpip? Why doesn't she get out with other mothers? Why do she and her H spend all weekend every weekend alone? What do you mean when you say he is emotional?

Is she restricting her DD's exploration and stimulation because the H can't handle it if she gets excited or loud or overtired and cranky? Does he get angry at disturbance to his routine? I know I am speculating, but maybe there is more to this than you might see. Could she be keeping the DD wrapped in cotton wool and unwilling to risk any stress in her life (from the child falling downstairs, falling and bumping herself and crying for instance) because the H would shout at her or something or that nature? Just speculating here, could be way off the mark... but some women who are under pressure at home bend over backwards to keep the peace and some men who have a short wick make life with babies and small children very difficult.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread