Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to give money to a friend in need? (bit long sorry)

26 replies

Sewlong · 15/09/2012 23:01

Long story short, I have a friend who I have known for a long long time, we are very close. She is absolutely lovely but terrible with money. She was in a highly paid job til quite recently but never managed to save anything, has loads of old debts etc.

Recently she has broken up with her partner (no DC) and is out of work. She is overdue on her rent and struggling to afford food and travel, can't pay phone bill etc. This happens every couple of years (because she never puts money aside when she's working) and then usually she will find some work at the last minute. But obviously right now we're in a recession so the work she's after is thin on the ground.

I feel really sorry for her and part of me wants to help her out, give her some money to tide her over (we are not wealthy but have some savings). But there are a few things stopping me. Firstly I "lent" her quite a large sum of money many years ago in a similar situation and it has never been paid back. Secondly she has not done several basic things to help herself which I would in a similar situation - she has not signed on/applied for HB (she's self employed which I know complicates matters), and she is only applying for a few highly paid jobs in her field (rather than getting any temp job/bar work/Tesco etc to tide her over). Thirdly I know that unless she gets to grip with her finances, even if I help her out this time then she'll end up in the same situation. I also know that although she would say (and mean) that she would pay me back, realistically any money I give her would soon be swallowed up by her debts and she'd be back at square one. I have advised her to go to CAB to look at her options and look at other options (like moving back with her parents) but it seems to fall on deaf ears.

So. I am wondering how to best help her. She hasn't asked for money although I know she would accept it gratefully if I offered. So AIBU not to offer because she is a grown woman who needs to get a grip on her own finances. Or should I just bung her some money and accept that it might not help at all?

OP posts:
VodkaJelly · 16/09/2012 11:45

I have a friend who is similar. Despite working she is contantly skint, and is always moaning 2 weeks before payday that she is short of money etc, but, and I know this sounds mean, I would never lend her any money because -

a) I would never get it back
b) I would have to lend her the same again next month. Lending her money wouldnt ease her money worries, it would only help her to reach pay day then she would be the same next month.

Her ExH was quite wealthy and she seems to think she still has that life style when she doesnt. She smokes 20 a day, buys top brand food (heinz etc) but every 3 months has her electric cut off as she cant pay the bill. She will spend about £100 a month on cosmetics, face wipes, foundation etc, which is fine to spend on yourself when you can afford it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread