Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect MIL to occasionally pay for herself when out with us/treat her grandkids?

16 replies

sagalsmith · 31/08/2012 18:04

My MIL has been driving me bonkers of late (past 3 years to be exact). She was brilliant when we got married 9 years ago and since then my family has been doing fairly well financially and are occasionally able to enjoy the perks of it. That said, due the nature of our work, we are fairly cash poor and asset ok and this week I even found out that the company I work for is probably going under and I haven't been paid for 3 months- so not great luck all the time and we work very, very hard. My FIL passed away last year and DH felt like he needed to do something for his mum- I'm all for family and no probs with that. I consider myself generous in nature and treat guest well, feed, wash laundry (:) ), want them to participate in family and will bring them on holiday (MIL joined us for one for 10 days- everything paid for). She's doing pretty well herself, not flush but with a small portfolio of rental income, pension etc.
Her gifts to my kids have now decreased in value considerably- fine, I'll accept that. She doesn't spend much time with them preferring the internet and going for west end shows (she's American- so enjoys London), buys herself nice food etc but not for anyone else in the house. Hasn't offered to pay for one meal this trip- already 2 weeks down the line with lots of meals eaten out on hol. Offered to take my kids out for a haircut today (I got to a really cheap place- £7.50 each- they are very good)- then asked me for money to pay them. I was quite furious but gave her a £20 to which she then said that she could use the rest for food for them.
My husband pasified me and said he'll try to explain things to me reg cultural differences which may help me understand it better- I'm waiting for him to come back now but I'm so mad! We are of different races but not that different!!

OP posts:
TheCunningStunt · 31/08/2012 18:09

I think yab a bit unreasonable. What she spends her money on is none of your business. She can eat what she likes and socialise how she likes. If you go out to dinner, make sure everyone knows they are payng their share etc. give her a break and talk to her. Getting mad gets you nowhere.

Pinkforever · 31/08/2012 18:12

YANBU-My own mil pisses me off by being tight when she has plenty of dosh. Before I get accused of being "entitled"Hmm-I know she used to help bil/sil out-buy kids school coat/shoes etc and has taken her other gcs out loads of times.

She has taken 2 of my dcs out twice-once fed them nothing from 9am-6pm but an ice cream-and still moaned about the price of it.

She also takes her other gd out for dinner every week-only macds-but when I meet her with my dcs I am expected to pay for their meals. Pisses my tits right off.....

ssd · 31/08/2012 18:12

dont blame you op, she sounds hard work

sorry had to Shock at "small portfolio of rental income"

get her

NatashaBee · 31/08/2012 18:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Pochemuchka · 31/08/2012 18:51

I would also be annoyed by this.

My MIL is like this, she comes round or we go to her, she ignores the DC, gets us to pay for her lunch/whatever we do, buy her food shopping and then asks DP for extra money. She gets annoyed if we ask for a contribution even though it's usually nominal and she has more than enough money.

She also talks about fucking Marks and Spencer all the time she's here. Angry
She then moans that she doesn't get to see the GC enough (at least once a week)
Sorry a bit of a rant! Blush

I've started to be 'out' during her visits (at work usually) as it's less stressful for everyone!

I can only learn from this and be a better behaved MIL when DS is grown up!

CaliforniaLeaving · 31/08/2012 19:41

She's an American there is no cultural difference in this so your Dh is making rubbish excuses, she's taking the piss and being a tight wad.

juneau · 31/08/2012 19:47

The bit about it being cultural is bollocks - some of the most generous people I know are American. Your MIL is a tight-wad. Not even taking her GC out for lunch FFS and not offering to pay for anything at all? I get that she's presumably paid to come over here, but I'm guessing that she isn't paying for her board and lodging and it's just polite to 'treat' your hosts and what GP doesn't want to spoil their GC a bit when they're in town? YANBU at all.

Cynner · 31/08/2012 19:49

Indeed..I can't wait to about " regional cultural differences" my dads was American and this sort of behaviour would have mortified him.
Just to be sure, your MIL is not suffering from any illness taking any medications that might be responsible for personality changes?

SoleSource · 31/08/2012 19:49

Yanbu she is a rude grabby tight git.

MrsCampbellBlack · 31/08/2012 19:53

YANBU

But then my in-laws fight to pay bills and are always slipping me money for school shoes etc etc

MrsCampbellBlack · 31/08/2012 19:53

What happens when you stay with her?

InkyBinky · 31/08/2012 19:58

YANBU. However, if your DH thinks its OK then it is not suprising that your DMIL thinks its ok. Maybe she thinks that, having bought up your DH, it is her turn to be supported.
I also think some older people get a bit mean with money, especially when they see 'younger' couples with, what looks like, plenty of money.

You probably have two choices, get your DH to deal with it or try not to let it bother you.

Born2bemild · 31/08/2012 20:11

Yanbu. I always pay for MIL. And cook etc. Feels rather one-sided!

LettyAshton · 31/08/2012 20:14

She'd make a good match for my fil. Buys the finest of everything for himself, yet is extremely mean when it comes to spending anything on his family. He is always angling to be taken out for meals and when I took him shopping he started "Oh, I think I've forgotten my cash card..." I said quite firmly that unfortunately we'd have to put all his shopping back in that case. He found his card pretty sharpish! I think that some people are just tightwads. Fil has been retired for 30 years and has been playing the "poor pensioner" card for all that time. It makes me sick to think of all the money we've spent on the pil when they have lived a far better lifestyle than we can ever hope to.

Cultural differences? What state is she from? Sounds like that 51st state Mothinwalleta to me.

GreyTS · 31/08/2012 20:32

These threads always make me so grateful for my lovely PILs and parents who are so generous to us, and we are not struggling they just like to help. So from my point of view YANBU, I would always take hosts out for meals, do some shopping, bring gifts etc if we are staying in someone's home- friends or family

lotsofcheese · 31/08/2012 20:41

YANBU.

You can pick your friends.....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread