Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to have allowed DD to call OH 'Dad'

17 replies

charllie · 02/07/2012 22:19

My ex (DD's father) even in the time we were together, was never a 'daddy' to her. He was always too busy. I don't think he really ever wanted a child to be honest. When i was in labour, he wasn't supportive at all, just put headphones in and tried to drown out the noise i was making, put the tv screen in between us, so he couldn't see me too. The day she was born, he stayed with us for maybe 2 hours, if that and then went home to 'bed' as he was 'tired' he went to the pub! Then every day, even though he wasn't working, didn't turn up to the hospital until at least 11am, even though he could have been there from 9am onwards. So in the time we were together, it was me and DD really. When we broke up in 2009 (i'd finally had enough of the relationship and got the guts to leave) it really was me and DD. We were both the happiest that we have been. She had a happy mummy again. I met my OH in 2010 and he moved in after only 6 months. Yes it was quick, but we'd fallen in love and he was there almost every day/night anyway. Before coming to this decision, obviously he met my DD and it wasn't just after one meeting that he moved in! We'd had lots of days out together, lots of times just staying home together, playing games etc. So i knew that she was happy with him. I also sat her down and spoke to her about OH and asked how she felt about mummy having a boyfriend and if that was ok with her. (she was 3 and half when we met) DD said she really liked him, liked the silly things we all done (water fights etc) He moved in and things carried on this way. We don't argue, there are never raised voices (well not in anger, just sillyness) I talk to DD lots about how she is feeling. She has said on a number of times (without me bringing the conversation up) that she is really happy and loves our family, loves that we never shout, never argue, loves spending lots of time together as a family.
Her father, has he seen her much since we broke up, does he see her regularly?? NO! And thats not because of me, he knows that all he has to do is phone and we can arrange something, arrange for him to see her. Does he do that, no. He is too busy going out, getting pissed, going to festivals. DD had to have a camera up her nose last year, i told him about it, sent him a text with the time and date. It was the day after his birthday. Did he turn up to support his daughter, no. He was hungover and had 'forgotten' she had an operation last year, did he come and spend lots of time with her, no. He came by with his mum 2 hours after she woke up, spent maybe 10 minutes there and then left. Told me he had lots to do. On her birthdays, does he phone to say happy birthday, no. He told her, which i was very angry about, that he had been busy! Busy ffs. Too busy for even a phone call.
Last year (DD was 5, almost 6) she asked me if she could call OH dad. I asked her if that was what she wanted to do and she said yes it was. She asked if OH would mind her calling him that, i said no he wouldn't, but it was her choice, we didn't talk about it again then. Then a month or so later, she ran into the living room just before bedtime and said 'i'm going to call you dad, because thats a nice name' and ran out, but snuck back in for cuddles with him too. Shes really come out of herself, yes she's a little monkey for OH, just like she is for me. But you can see by the way they are together, they have a real 'dad/daughter' relationship. He sits down and plays games with her, talks to her, reads her stories, helps her read stories, cuddles her and well, just gives her the time of day that she deserves.
I've been told a few times on a couple of different posts that i shouldn't have allowed DD to call him dad. Was i wrong in allowing this? I didn't feel like i could say to her that she couldnt' call him that, it was her decision.

OP posts:
MrsHelsBels74 · 02/07/2012 22:22

If she wants to call him dad & he is happy with that I don't see the problem. Presumably she is aware that she has a biological father & still wants your OH to be 'dad'. I say let her get on with it.

WorraLiberty · 02/07/2012 22:24

I think you should be guided by your child and from what you've written, you have been.

Lots of kids have two people they call Dad...sometimes they have two people they call Mum.

The only thing that concerns me is how quickly you moved this man into her home...then again that has nothing to do with what she calls him.

charllie · 02/07/2012 22:25

Yep she is fully aware that she has the biological father, she does see him (when it suits him) and calls him daddy. Think thats why she calls OH dad, in her head she has her daddy and then she has her dad. She loves him (my OH) can see that in the way they are together. Thank you :)

OP posts:
BeehavingBaby · 02/07/2012 22:27

Was all ready to say YABU, but you are blatantly not! FWIW, DH's daughter calls her stepdad 'dad' and it broke his heart a little but he sees that it makes DSD so happy to be completely conventional in her main home (we see her regularly, or did at the time anyway, she is grown up now).

strawberrypenguin · 02/07/2012 22:29

Sounds to me like they have built up a lovely relationship over time :) if she feels he is a 'dad' to her and they are both happy let her call him dad.

charllie · 02/07/2012 22:33

Wish my DD's father would see her regularly (for her sake) but unfortunately he doesn't. He'll regret that when she's grown up (i hope) but i think, even if he did see her more, she would have still got to this decision herself. My OH is a father figure to her, and hes a bloody good one too! So i think in time, she would have still done this. Maybe its happened a little faster because her father doesn't really have alot to do with her.
Your DH done well to realise that it was what his DD wanted and that it made her so happy to do it. Must have been hard for him, but well done him for being understanding :)

OP posts:
charllie · 02/07/2012 22:34

strawberrypenguin their relationship that they have built up is amazing, i love seeing them both together. Its just how i thought a father would be, but unfortunately she didn't have that with her biological father, but she does with my OH :)

OP posts:
OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos · 02/07/2012 22:36

You are doing the right thing. She knows who her biological father is but she's a little girl who wants a Daddy, and it sounds like she has one. Its lovely that she has someone in her life that she wants to call Dad, and it's great that she has a way to differentiate between her two Dads.

I think it would have been a mistake to not let her call your oh Dad, it would have made her feel rejected, even though that woudont have been the intention obviously.

ohmysilverballs · 02/07/2012 22:37

Bless, yanbu :)

BeautyBoo · 02/07/2012 22:37

That's pretty much the same situation as I was in at around the same age. I asked my Mum if I could call her partner 'dad' and she said it was up to me so I asked him and he was over the moon. He's been my Dad ever since and I wouldn't have it any other way. I didn't have any contact with my biological dad then because he wasn't interested but in recent years when he decides to email me he's completely aware that he's not my 'dad' and I've got a perfectly decent one I wont ever need to replace!

princelypurpleparrot · 02/07/2012 22:44

OP it sounds like you have done exactly the right thing as it was completely led by your DD.

Can I ask (as I know someone in a similar situation) what does she call her biological father? Just wondering what the protocol is here, if indeed there is any at all.

pigletmania · 02/07/2012 22:52

That's fantastic, why not! Your do is more like a daddy to her than her bio,ogical one, and she is responding to that. Your ex sounds like a total wanker

charllie · 02/07/2012 23:07

princelypurpleparrot she calls her biological father 'daddy'
OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos that is exactly what i didn't want her feeling, rejected. And like you say, it wouldnt' have been that, but to her, could have felt that way. BeautyBoo i can see that happening here too, her father getting in touch in years to come, realising what he's missed out on. Haha yes, pigletmania he is a wanker, i refer to him as twunt (thats how his name is saved on my phone too lol)

OP posts:
lovebunny · 02/07/2012 23:10

she's entitled to a dad, to have the dad experience. if it works for you all, go with it.

queenofthepirates · 02/07/2012 23:21

Aw you sound lovely, I wish you all very well. Your daughter is very lucky to have both you and your OH. She sounds happy and confident and a credit to you.

AKE2012 · 02/07/2012 23:51

YANBU. Yes u in my opinion u moved him in a bit quick but that has no relation to ur daughter. If shes happy and she wants to call him that then theres no problem. How does her 'daddy' feel bout it?

My dd has said that if i get married she wuld like 2 call her stepdad dad. I said it wuld b up to you. Think wat u hav done is right as it was her decision. If ud hav told her she had to call him that ud hav a lot of negative feedback. Your dd sounds content with the situation n u shuld feel proud that uv provided a stable loving home for her.

devonshiredumpling · 03/07/2012 00:19

My mother left my biological father when i was 3 and moved in and eventually married my step father . I was aware that I had a biolical father and obviousy a step father but I became emotionally attached to my step father and have always called him dad because in the end a dad is there for when you fall over and need a plaster and a hug and also any advice you may need they are also the one who read to you every night and tuck you up and essentally make you feel safe. If your daughter feels safe than i cannot see a problem. My step dad did not have any legal ties to me but I still felt he was my daddy. He died in March and it hurts so much that a man who had no obligations to me meant so much to me (he and my mother divorced when I was 16 and I wanted to live with him rather than my mother and he said yes) He always treated me like his own . I loved him so much and my kids always knew him as grandad ray Hope this helps

New posts on this thread. Refresh page