Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that many Mumsnetters have a self serving and skewed view of life

37 replies

LaWobble · 30/06/2012 22:21

Large numbers of (mainly female) mumsnetters post on a thread about their acts of physical violence in the home when angry. The tone of the thread is 'this is normal, we all lose it now and again'. However if any post mentioned a man carrying out these acts, the response would on the whole be 'domestic violence, run away to a refuge'.

Mumsnetters frequently post about their unpleasant behaviour towards their children, the response is usually 'we've all been there, you are a good mum'. However there are also multiple posts about 'narcissistic' or abusive mothers (of grown up mumsnetters), and these abusive mothers are roundly criticised and treated with little understanding.

It is a given on the relationships forum that if a man is having an affair, he has absolutely no genuine emotional connection with the OW. In fact he merely views the OW as a 'hole' to screw, and if it wasn't with her, it would be with someone else. However women frequently post that they are having EA or fully fledged affairs with someone, and their feelings are acknowledged as real and sympathy worthy (albeit unacceptable to act upon).

Women are on the whole allowed to post criticisms of mens physiques, small penis, beer belly or whatever without comeback. But if a woman posts that her partner has mentioned her less flattering features, he is an emotional abuser.

Now I am someone who has thrown things in anger, been unpleasant to my children, been cheated on, been unfaithful myself and been disappointed in a new partners physique. Because I am a real person and people are generally a mixture of pleasant / unpleasant, giving / selfish etc etc etc. But why is mumsnet normally so black and white about these everyday matters?

So AIBU to think that mumsnet would benefit from more posters who have a more rounded view of how humans behave and think, rather than a tired old stock of library responses.

OP posts:
tethersend · 30/06/2012 23:17

MN is not one homogenous voice.

You will find seemingly contradictory opinions on here because, put simply, they are the opinions of different people.

Whatmeworry · 30/06/2012 23:51

IMO you are leaving as its becoming far more balanced. I don't know why but there has been quite a shift in the last few months, even the Feminist section isn't as daft as it used to be.

Relationships is the last main bastion of the sort of people you are taking about as far as I can see.

winedrip · 01/07/2012 00:07

tethers I don't think that the op was suggesting that MN is a homogeneous voice - obviously there are opinions from many - I think it was more about the 'consensus' views, that can be difficult to subvert

Socknickingpixie · 01/07/2012 00:19

The thing is people in RL are like that as well. It's called gender roles or something like that

AgentZigzag · 01/07/2012 00:21

There's not a lot of difference between seeing MN as having reached a consensus on a certain subject, to seeing that consensus as the view of a homogeneous group winedrip. (which isn't reflecting the true state of things anyway because lots of people don't say what they really think and lots might be lurking and not post their view).

winedrip · 01/07/2012 00:25

agentZZ not sure you got me right - I have already mentioned a few times that MN is indeed becoming more heterogeneous, and varied. But I think that it is the consensus of the 'old-school' MNers or more dominant ones at least, that can be hard to challenge, for some, when bullying and snobbery is so prevalent here.

winedrip · 01/07/2012 00:27

and yes agreed AZZ, the opinions posted are naturally going to be biased to the extremes, as people towards the middle, often will just lurk

AliceInPoundland · 01/07/2012 00:32

I agree with you OP. Hard not to really.

AgentZigzag · 01/07/2012 00:33

I was just going on your last post wined, yeah, reading your other posts I see what you mean.

I'm not fussed about saying something I think other posters might disagree with, but there are times when I've not bothered posting because I can't be arsed with response I know it'd get.

Which is why it goes on I suppose?

lovebunny · 01/07/2012 00:44

internet communication is almost anonymous. people can put their views forward without needing to protect the rest of the world from them. are we under an obligation to be fair, right-minded and so on? i don't think so.

yes, there are threads which are sources of support - many of them.
but, this is a poisonous place and aibu is 'known' as the 'worst' part of mn - people talk about it. some people deliberately avoid it. i try to stay here rather than anywhere else...

my first experience of an internet forum was on a christian website. it was the meanest, most vicious and spiteful place i've ever been. it was excellent preparation for other forums. by comparison, aibu posters are cuddly bunnies.

MAYBELATERNOWIMBUSY · 03/07/2012 20:40

and NOTHING is as it seems ! end of sermon(WHO REALLY CARES?)

SoleSource · 03/07/2012 20:45

What Worra wrote.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread