Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be a bit peeved that DG has chosen a derivative of DD's name for her new puppy?

19 replies

TartyMcFarty · 06/06/2012 20:31

Now I've typed it, it seems petty.

DD has a classic name. We weren't sure how to shorten it at first, and she was known by both the obvious and the more old-fashioned nn at first. We stuck with the latter, thinking that if she wasn't comfortable with it, her friends will naturally call her by the more obvious when she's at school (she'll be enrolled with her full name).

Think Victoria - obvious nn Vicky, less obvious Tori; Isobelle - Belle or Izzy; Edward - Ned or Ed. You get the picture.

Anyway, my gran's old dog died just over a month ago and of course I was all tea and sympathy, only now she's replaced the dig with a pup, and gone and named her the most obvious, common derivative of DD's name.

I am genuinely asking myself if I'm being U to care about this. Perhaps what I'm more pissed off about is that she will have asked herself (and my auntie, who can notoriously convince herself that black is white) whether it might be a bit much. Well if I think it is, the answer is obviously bloody well YES! However, she's just gone ahead without even bothering to tell me anyway.

AIBU here? This is genuinely a name that DD may very well chose (have chosen??) to go by in the future. It is the one that people will most naturally and obviously shorten her name to unless she chooses to tell them that we use a different one. And WIBU to ask her to change it?

I know the likely response here - I don't have exclusivity on the name. Just seems a bit weird, s'all!

Oh and, ahem, I once jokingly called my pet ducks Joan and Ken after my gran and grandad (not this one, the other gran!) Hilarious I know Hmm, but maybe I've just answered my own question.

OP posts:
AdoraBell · 06/06/2012 20:40

I'd also be a bit peeved, OH's secretary was very much peeved when he named our puppy the exact same name as her 8 month old son, not even a derivative.

fedupofnamechanging · 06/06/2012 20:40

Well, my mum would have happily given my dd the same name as her beloved labrador, who had sadly died, a few years before dd was born. Some people don't see names as off limits once they've been used for either a pet or a grandchild. I am of that view myself, so think yababitu in taking slight offence.

She has come across a name that she loves and has used it. YWdefinitelyBU to ask her to change it.

I can see why you think it is odd - of all the names out there, she had to pick 'yours', but perhaps it stuck in her head because it is yours and she equates it with a much loved DGC.

AnyoneforTurps · 06/06/2012 20:46

But children love sharing names/birthdays etc, so your DD will probably love sharing the name with the dog.

VonHerrBurton · 06/06/2012 21:43

Other way round for us! We 'inherited' a dog years and years ago and didn't name him ourselves. He passed away about 15 years ago and we have called ds the same name as the dog. Ds is 9.

Not in a strange named-after-the-dead-dog way, we just always loved the name, for a dog or a child! A nice name is a nice name.

Can see how you could be a bit bristly though, I think I would be too, if I'm honest. You can't ask her to change it, though, I don't think. It may cause a huge row, and it's not really worth it, imo.

sarahseashell · 06/06/2012 21:46

YANBU for being peeved because you may feel like it eliminates a choice of nn for dd. However, it may be that they didn't even think about it/realise. Unless you realistically want them to change it try to let it go and see it as karma for the ducks Grin

Ephiny · 06/06/2012 21:55

I don't think you can expect to 'reserve' a nickname like that, especially as it's not even the one your DD actually uses!

Not the ideal choice maybe, but surely it's not worth getting upset about. It's a dog, after all, I really don't think there'll be any confusion over who's who, even if your DD does in the future choose to use that nickname.

thatisall · 06/06/2012 22:04

I felt bad when DD made a friend at her new school and she came round and whenever we called out for our cat, she turned around as they have exactly the same name.

I wouldn't do it.

TessTosterone · 06/06/2012 22:07

Yabu I think. My mums dog ' s name is nn for one of my boys and I have never given it a thought. On my name short list this time were 3 names of their old dogs.

venusandmars · 06/06/2012 22:14

When I was at school, my boyfriend's gran named her puppy after me - apparently because it was so cute Hmm

fedupofnamechanging · 06/06/2012 22:19

My son's friend and his sister both have the same names as my mum's dogs. My son is not big on tact - I hope he hasn't mentioned this in front of the other mum Grin

GrahamTribe · 06/06/2012 22:27

The chances are that your DD will adore her Great Nanna's new puppy and love the fact that they have a name in common. :) An adult friend of mine did - he would have been about 10 when they got their pup and named him Micky, his prefered name being Mick. By the time I met him he was 23 and Micky was his favourite of the family's 3 Labradors, largely because he'd built up a close bond with "his" Micky.

HoneyDragonWearingLederhosen · 06/06/2012 22:33

I named my puppy after HullyGully .... Thus far we haven't fallen out over it Grin, perhaps you'll have to be like Hully and be gracious about it? Wink

I honestly don't think your dd will mind when she's older.

LST · 06/06/2012 22:36

I have a cat I got 3 years ago for my birthday. I called him Vince. I now have a DS and I wanted to call him Vince...Sad

TartyMcFarty · 06/06/2012 22:46

AIBU, aren't I. Ah well, The nn she's got was my choice anyway, I like it better. Yahboosucks!

Grin at Vince!

OP posts:
LST · 06/06/2012 22:49

If I have another DS I think I might just change the cats name.. He won't be none the wiser Grin

Spuddybean · 06/06/2012 22:54

i think i'd be pissed off. Surely there are other names.

the abbreviation of my name is often used as a dogs name. People always say it to me when i get introduced, without any sense of tactlessness 'oh my nan/dad/brother has a dog called spuddy' then a gormless grin while waiting for me to be flattered and say something gracious.

BertieBotts · 06/06/2012 22:57

I wouldn't mind at all. Someone I know adopted a child who happened to have the same name as another close family member - it's never caused a problem because it's usually obvious in context which is which.

BertieBotts · 06/06/2012 23:00

And the point of that was Blush that if it isn't an issue for two closely related people of the same sex to have the same name (and sometimes each uses the long version and sometimes each uses a shortened version) then it shouldn't cause an issue at all with a dog, it's not like you'll get them mixed up!

I think people get a bit precious about names. No, that person who named their baby something which was on your list didn't "steal" the name, and there's nothing stopping you from using it. It's not like you made it up and can demand royalties Hmm (Not aimed at you, OP!)

rainydaysarebad · 06/06/2012 23:13

Indiana jones named himself after his dog Indiana, and he was the best (fictional) archaeologist ever. Yep.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page