Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think if this is a genuine reason to not adopt....

134 replies

Janoschi · 07/05/2012 14:54

.... then really you'd be a shit parent?

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2140586/Scandal-babies-parents-wont-adopt-theyre-called-Chrystal-Chardonnay.html

I mean, SURELY you can nickname anything to make it bearable? Chardonnay could be Charlie, or Donnie...

OP posts:
FamiliesShareGerms · 10/05/2012 06:39

Article is beyond terrible. Though as someone said upthread, I suspect most prospective adopters do ponder the name issue. There are some seriously awful names out there, and seeing page after page of them in Be My Family does take you back a bit.

We were very lucky in that our (adopted) daughter has a lovely name along the lines of what we might have chosen ourselves, though we changed her middle name to reflect our family members. I've been quite surprised by how many of our friends have made comments along the lines of how well we did to adopt someone with a lovely name, how it "fits" with our (birth) son's name etc etc. And the huge number of threads on MN about choosing baby names demonstrates that for lots of people getting the "right" name is a really big deal. But...to turn down a child because of their name? I don't know anyone who would do this.

CaptainKirk · 10/05/2012 08:27

As an adopter I have to say that there is a lot of truth to the article. These kids DO come from some pretty terrible backgrounds and the current guidance is to tell them about their background at age appropriate times. The whole adoption process is very stressful. You just can't imagine it if you haven't gone through it yourself. There are many roads that lead to adoption and for the most part we all want a "normal" family because we can't have one any other way. This is why children may get rejected for their looks or their name.

Adoptive families don't want to stand out. How can you explain away a very ginger child when there is no sign of it in the parents? How do you counteract the looks when a nice middle class family tells people that their child is named "Chardonnay"? It's just wanting to be normal and fly under the radar.

Fortunately our child has a very nice name that sounds good with our surname. Would we have rejected him if he had a ridiculous name? It's hard to say, but it would have been a big check in the "no" column. A name can be everything. Look at all the stress people have naming a birth child. It can be a HUGE deal. Disliking a name does not make someone unsuitable to adopt. It just means they may have to wait longer. Our social workers advised that names should not be changed unless they are unique or a security risk. One couple we know DID change their child's name because he is very recognisable and the birth parents are dangerous.

At the time of the final adoption proceeding you could change the name and I doubt anyone would be able to stop you. You'd just have to deal with any potential fallout from the child in years to come. We heard from an adult adoptee that fell out majorly with their family when they found out their name had been changed at adoption.

As far as knowing about the background of the child, we know everything and are happy to know it. What we share in the future with our child remains to be seen.

OhDoAdmitMrsDeVere · 10/05/2012 08:34

There are many adopters on this thread

Janoschi · 10/05/2012 11:25

I understand that names are a big deal and the Baby Names threads do illustrate that very clearly. But to turn down a child because of it...? I can see how the name could really grate, but it really is often the only thing they carry with them from their past and I'd feel Sad taking that away too.

Do adopted children sometimes ask to be renamed themselves?

OP posts:
OhDoAdmitMrsDeVere · 10/05/2012 11:42

Yes they do.

LieInsAreRarerThanTigers · 10/05/2012 16:29

I have a cousin called Crystal, in the UK. Very pretty name, although I would't choose it myself. My Canadian cousins have mostly given their children names we would never have heard of over here, or boys' names for girls etc.
I can't see what the fuss is about - probably not really about the names at all.

Mum4meme · 06/11/2018 02:03

Starting with a clean slate is perhaps an unrealistic and unhelpful way of looking at adoptees. Their life before being adopted, however young, however difficult, needs to be honoured in some way, simply because it is part of them. My name was changed when I was adopted and the life I went in to have with my adopted family was awful to be honest. Adopting parents need to show a little more respect for the child. Keeping The name is one way of doing this. Albeit a symbolic one as things would not have been different if I’d kept my original name.

MsHopey · 06/11/2018 06:06

I read too much of this to realise it was a zombie thread 🧟‍♀️

DramaticGoose · 06/11/2018 06:37

Argh man it makes me want to adopt all the chardonnays and champagne and crystals.

One day I might be able to afford to adopt but at the moment I can't. Poor little mites, it's so sad.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page