Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my friends dd has a point?

44 replies

youcantpolishaturd · 11/02/2012 12:05

A close friends dd is coming up to a special birthday and she feeling pressured by her parents into accepting a very expensive present from a close family friend that actually she said she will not use (for good reasons), and really doesn't want them to waste their money on a gift that wouldnt be appreciated or used, and has said she would much rather they choose something off her wishlist (I am aware that some of you will say this is greedy and selfish, and she should be happy to get a pressie in the first place but she really isn't- most items are a fiver or under- mostly books as she is an avid reader) and if they wanted to have a splurge they could always get a couple. Seems reasonable. I will also add she is lovely, very generous and will always ask for peoples wishlists because she wants to be 100% sure that she is getting something that people will genuinely appreciate and want.
The pressy in question is a piece of jewllery but friends dd has SN and significant sensory issues and for this reason almost never wears such things, and also is not interested in the typical girly stuff.
Friends dd has confided in me that she just feels that her parents are trying to do the 'done thing' for the sake of it, and is getting fed up of what feels like she not listening to her. (the latest battle was the party dress- friends dd was made to try nunerous on having not worn one for 2 decades because she cant stand them and surprise surprise couldnt tolerate it, dont know what they had expected to have changed!). So I said I would post it here to get an unbiased opinion!

OP posts:
CrabbyBigbottom · 11/02/2012 12:50

What a thread full of slappers Grin

I can't deny it Worra... Grin

edam · 11/02/2012 12:59

Her parents sound weird and controlling. Nothing wrong with saying, oh, if you are kind enough to think about buying a present for my birthday, please don't spend a lot of money - I'd far rather have a good book than an expensive piece of jewellery which I can't wear because of .

mrsjay · 11/02/2012 13:03

I think the mum is trying to push her dd to be a girl and thats Unfair on the girl , I would get her to say she wont wear the jewellry int he nicest way , the girl seems more sensible than her mother tbh ,

youcantpolishaturd · 11/02/2012 13:20

Thanks for your replies, have shown them to her- but how can we make them listen?

OP posts:
PeelingmyselfofftheCeiling · 11/02/2012 13:36

What Edam said.

youcantpolishaturd · 11/02/2012 15:23

Thanks mn jury!

OP posts:
cheekyseamonkey · 11/02/2012 16:11

I was lucky enough to have family members foist unwanted jewellry on me for my 18th. It wasn't to my taste & it was very expensive. They bought gold not silver, despite knowing I have a serious reaction to gold (blistering skin, & anaphylactic shock if near my face). I felt anxious that they'd spent so much on something I would & could never wear. I'd have been much happier with some books too.

However, I still smiled & said thank you, how kind etc. But then I don't have SN which are unlikely to change & which if aware of, a sincere gift giver should take into account.

In my case my aunts threw a hissy when 8 years later, I didn't wear any of that jewellery on my wedding day, what with not wanting to have to call paramedics (or look lime a nob!). I despise when the act of gift giving becomes more about the giver & less about the recipient.

I also hate filling my house with useless things & am only sentimental about items with ACTUAL meaning, so they've been sold.

DeWe · 11/02/2012 16:27

Personally I'd have thought that a third party who knows them both, jut having a quick word would probably solve it. "Did you know X has sensory issues which means she can't wear jewelry?" If it seems to be more tactful phrase it as an allergy, which more people will understand.

I wouldn't bring up the wish list, that is where it can look grabby, unless they ask what else they could get.

It could be tactful to think of something that might fall into both categories, sort of jewelry, but one she'd wear. Say is a watch okay? Or would she wear brooches?

However, if they've got it, then I'd probably just smile and thank.

However I'd love to know where you're buying books if they're mostly less than £5. Even tiny books seem to be more than that unless you buy second hand. Wink

cheekyseamonkey · 11/02/2012 16:37

DeWe £3.73 for a bestseller from most supermarkets. 2 for £7 morrisons. Simple.

DeWe · 11/02/2012 17:02

Yes but they don't usually have the book I'm looking for-and I don't think there's a Morrisons near. Grin

cheekyseamonkey · 11/02/2012 17:37

No, true, it is usuLly a pile of old pap. But could well be on the girl's list. Waterstones online is good.

McHappyPants2012 · 11/02/2012 17:46

With or without the SN.

Why do people pick gift for a person who clearly will not like, use or collect

WhereYouLeftIt · 11/02/2012 18:14

"but 'rents are upping the pressure saying its not about her."
Her 21st birthday is not about her? Who is it about then? Confused

OP, this is the DD of someone you describe as a close friend - have you asked her why she is behaving so rudely this way towards her daughter?

youcantpolishaturd · 11/02/2012 19:46

I have asked her, and friends dd says that she should just let them get it for her because it looks nice and they want to, that she will have it for years to come and will be nice to have something special, but friends dd just cannot understand as books are special to her!

OP posts:
RandomMess · 11/02/2012 19:59

Could they get her something special like a gold book mark, or heaven forbid a kindle?

ragged · 11/02/2012 20:08

yanbu.
How make them listen...? I don't think you can. :(

bobbledunk · 11/02/2012 22:35

Are the gift givers aware that she has sensory issues? I doubt they want to waste their money on something that can't be appreciated.

Her parents sound very controlling by trying to force her into wearing clothes and accepting gifts that she would probably find quite torturous to wear due to her sn.

IUseTooMuchKitchenRoll · 11/02/2012 22:41

I don't think you can make them listen.

It's a gift, and gift will always be a little bit about what the giver wants to give, there is nothing wrong with that. It's nice if it's about what the receiver wants too, but if it's not, it's not. That is the nature of gifts.

If all this girl really wants is a couple of books, I'm sure someone else could get them for her. There is no reason for the parents not to give their daughter a piece of jewllery on a special birthday, and the dd should just accept that.

Sevenfold · 11/02/2012 22:46

(ok not yet read thread as didn't want to be swayed so going by the op)
could you not have a word, I have a dd with sn and have had people buy her stuff that is useless to her, it is always such a shame as they have wasted their money (eye shadow for a girl with athetoid CP!! for instance)
could you have a word? surely a compromise could be reached.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page