Dammit, I go off to watch TV with DH and you've all been talking about the Winchesters without me.
Oddly, I think I prefer Dean the character to Jensen Ackles the actor. With Castiel it's the other way round; Cas doesn't do much for me but Misha Collins is hawt and seems v. funny and clever. Sam/Jared and Jeffrey/John are on even footing. I wouldn't kick any of them out of bed though. Not sure about Bobby, then again Jim Beaver was sort of cute (in a serious and valiant kind of way), in Deadwood.
In other news, I may have spent too much time thinking about all this.