Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think this isn't fair...

32 replies

Atwaroverscrabble · 21/11/2011 19:48

Ok, brief potted history...

Dh and i have bern together 5 years, married for 4. He has a daughter who is 16 and until Sept lived with her mum and saw us once a month or so whenever she could be bothered to come over. She now lives with us and has seen her mum twice since moving in (45 miles away, her mum and my dh don't drive, only me and she lives in a tiny villge). I have a ds who is 12 and sees his dad alternate weekends and his dad does most of the drive to an fro, again 45 miles away. We also have a dd who is 2.

Anyway, since getting together my mum has always ensured she treats dsd the same as ds and now dd and spent exactly the same on them. Dont see her much as she is 250 miles away and is v skint. She spends about £10 each for xmas and birthdays and thats fine.

Dh's parents live 45 miles away and we prob see them once a month. When we go up dsd basically ignores them but ds will chat and help out. When its time to go dh's dad gives dh £20-40 for petrol (dh never pays for petrol, i do, and dh generally gives me £10 and keeps the rest for his spends... Anyway thats irrelevant for now)...
Dh's dad then slips ds a couple of quid and gives dsd anything between £5 and £20... So unequal there but hey its not worth stressing about. However birthdays and xmas have started to niggle me a bit and i need to know if iabu or not...

Birthdays and xmas ds is usually given a £20-30 voucher from the IL's, dsd however is given a stack of presents, £40-50 cash plus £75-100 in vouchers....

Is this fair? I know its totally up to them what they spend etc but it seems so over the top and i think in front of ds it is a but cruel... Perhaps give her the money discretely? Or better still perhaps treat them the same? Aibu? I wont say anything to them btw....

OP posts:
Atwaroverscrabble · 22/11/2011 11:03

I would like to say that actually i will be spending exactly the same on dsd as on dd and ds from my mums cheque but was curious as to what the opinions wouls be as some suggest that its understandable to treat differently based on whether they are related by blood or not...

I really dont care about the actual money, what i object to is the blatant and obvious way it is done. If dsd was given the money and extra gifts discretely then fine but its all done in front of ds and to be honest dsd does have a tendency to gloat at him and being given so much has made her lazy in terms of not bothering to try and get part time work etc but it is their choice.

Re DH and the petrol money, again i really dont care anymore about that. I have had conversations with him and he knows how i feel and if he wants to be selfish then so be it, i am happy knowing that what i have i share and perhaps one day he will have a 'lightbulb moment' too... Probably when he is skint and i am not! Lol

Thank you for all your comments....

OP posts:
Journey · 22/11/2011 11:18

They sound generous to me. Your DS has his own set of grandparents.

I agree with gramercy.

BluddyMoFo · 22/11/2011 11:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CalmaLlamaDown · 22/11/2011 11:34

YABU over the grandparents presents, it is up to them! Also confused over petrol money issue - You have been married for 4 years and have a child together, why the distinctions over 'my' money and 'his' money?

stuffthenonsense · 22/11/2011 11:50

I can understand your frustration....you go to the trouble and expense of driving your DH and your DSD to go to collect their pocket money, whilst you and your DS converse and help out your ILs. Very very frustrating for you, but very well done.
I am sure that your DS will not be wanting to visit there within a year, he will be wanting to be with his mates, and whats wrong with that..they are not his grandparents...maybe then your DH and your DSD will be more considerate to you as you will probably be reluctant to leave your DS 45 miles away so they can collect their pocket money.

Hullygully · 22/11/2011 11:55

If she doesn't live with her mum then therre is sadness there somewhere. Perhaps they are trying to compensate.

Atwaroverscrabble · 22/11/2011 12:38

she only moved in with us in September, 100% her choice as we live in a lively city and her mum lives in a sleepy village and she wanted to be somewhere 'happening'... and this has been going on for years...

interestingly the other grandchildren (yes blood related) get somewhere between what ds gets and about half of what DSD gets...

and DSD has grandparents on her mums side too, there really is nothing to compensate for. I am semi-dreading xmas morning as we will all be up at the ILs and the children will be opening their presents together and it will be pretty obvious at how differently they are being treated but as I have said, I won't be mentioning it to the ILs or to DH although if it was the other way around DH would be jumping up and down insisting that we compensate DSD for being treated differently....

We have a joint household budget to which we both pay into and then we have our own which is why it is not just 'our' money tbh.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page