Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to stick my oar in..

39 replies

RVF400 · 23/09/2011 23:31

to a family dispute between DH and MIL that is escalating wildly?

(First post but I have been lurking since birth of 8wo DD)
DH and MIL have always had a somewhat fiery relationship, I put it down to the Mediterranean blood, but now things are getting out of hand. Here is the (long, sorry) latest feud:

I recently gave birth, DD was born at 9.30 am so by the time I was installed in the postnatal ward at 4pm I had been awake for nearly 48hrs. DH had done all the phone calls to family etc and requested that no-one visit until the following day, (I didn't know but seems sensible).

DH left about 5.30pm to sleep. At about 6 ish MIL & FIL turn up on postnatal ward. I was a bit Hmm but DD was sleeping peacefully (little did I know how rare this would turn out to be!) and I was feeling pretty happy so I just went with it (I usually get along pretty well with ILs). They talked at me for a bit and left about 8 I think.

The following night was absolute hell, DD screamed constantly until 7.30am.

Next day, DH is livid about his parents having visited and decides that his parents are now not allowed to see DD at all as he is soooo pissed off with them and cannot trust them to respect his decisions.

Some of me thinks this is an over-reaction, but some of me is also very annoyed with the Ils. They have a history of belittling DH, treating him like a naughty child (he is 38 ffs). They don't believe he is capable of being a responsible adult. I really think they should have respected his decision, whether or not they agreed with it, but I'm alarmed that we're now faced with a showdown in which the weapon of choice appears to be DD. Sad

Since then some fairly vitriolic emails have been going back and forth with trivial "sub-arguments" that are muddying the waters (e.g. FIL had a cold so put babies at risk by visiting, but oh, no, FIL actually had hayfever, long and totally irrelevant debate ensues over difference between cold and hayfever). I have tried my hardest to stay out of it because
a) it's not my family
b) I am likely to get over-emotional and say something I regret
c) I think the whole thing is very sad and I just wish everyone would try being nice to each other

But it is getting silly now, with uncles, nephews and all sorts involved (WHY? None of them were there!) and I really feel like going in a banging a few heads together. Also, DH is getting stressed about it and would like me to "show some support". I do fully agree that his decision should have been respected (and am prepared to say so) but TBH I don't like the way he has over-reacted. He is a very black and white person, I am not.

Well done if you got this far.

SO:
Should I stick my oar into the vicious email traffic with my ha'penny worth, or should I just leave them all to it?

(reading that back, it sounds like DH & his family are a bunch of nutters. They may well be)

OP posts:
KeepInMind · 24/09/2011 17:19

I think you need to tell your DH that you have a new child to deal with and he needs to stop acting like a baby.
The in laws should not have come to visit but I guess they were excited about the new baby, I think your DH needs to calm down a bit and get over himself

Whatmeworry · 24/09/2011 17:23

I'd side with DH, because if he doesn't establish his authority on this one then MIL will be all over your family in the future. If the PiL cared about you they would have adhered to his wishes in the first place.

diddl · 24/09/2011 17:41

Well, I think that your ILs need to explain why they thought that your husband´s request didn´t apply to them, & convince you/your husband that they will listen in future.

You need to present a united front so that the ILs will respect you both & not pull such a stunt again.

For example, what if you hadn´t been OK to see them-would they have insisted?

What I´m saying is how much do they care about you or do their wishes always come first?

"At last, a man with balls!"-that as well!

Dozer · 24/09/2011 17:49

Your DH is being unreasonable, and YABU to "support him" in punishing the IL's by not letting them see the baby for this one mistake. Doubt they'd make the same mistake again.

diddl · 24/09/2011 17:56

I agree that your husband has overreacted-but it sounds like a good chance to set boundaries.

It´s also up to you who sees your baby-so a compromise of a not too long visit?

Who´s getting everyone else involved?

ChaoticAngeloftheUnderworld · 24/09/2011 18:02

"They have a history of belittling DH, treating him like a naughty child (he is 38 ffs)."

It's not just one mistake though. It sounds like a culmination of things and the OP's DH has finally snapped.

I agree with diddl that this is a chance to set boundaries.

elesbells · 24/09/2011 18:04

There's a lot more behind this than just this incident...I can't see anyone getting so upset at this and this alone. I think you need to talk to your DH and tell him he needs to clear the air with th ILs - and that means getting ALL of the grievances he clearly has with them off his chest.

It's not fair that you and your DD has to suffer for what has gone on before....

Congrats on the birth by the way... and good luck

Inertia · 24/09/2011 18:08

I think it's great that your DH put the welfare of you and your baby first, and it's understandable that he was angry at his parents for ignoring his requests . And , although banning access to the baby doesn't help, I don't think he needs to apologise for being angry that his parents had totally stamped on his wishes, which were made with the intention of protecting you while at your most tired.

I think you can mediate - you can say that you support your husband but would like to move on and make peace.

floosiemcwoosie · 24/09/2011 18:20

This time is really for you three to bond and thats what you need to focus your energy on

You might gently remind DH , that now he has a DD how would he feel if they had a poor relationship?

Yoour not ging to change ils behaviour, just how you respond to it

Enjoy your DD!

floosiemcwoosie · 24/09/2011 18:20

your change!

RVF400 · 24/09/2011 18:34

OK, so I have just bitten the bullet and clicked send on an email of my own. Said I fully supported DH's (initial) decision and was upset they didn't respect it, and that I want all the silliness to stop now.
DH has read it, but won't budge an inch due to the "boundary setting" a few of you have mentioned. He sees this as the thin end of the wedge if it is not stamped out now, I agree it could cause problems in the future.
Have suggested an apology and an assurance that they will not undermine his (our) parenting decisions in the future would go a long way to helping fix everything. And told DH and MIL to stop copying the whole family in on every abusive email they send, it just makes them both look like idiots.

Grin @ "a man with balls". DH's fave comment on this thread, naturally!

OP posts:
RVF400 · 24/09/2011 18:36

not sure I could handle a face-to-face with the level of mud slinging currently going on. We would need the riot police on standby.

OP posts:
diddl · 24/09/2011 18:57

I have to say that involving everyone else would send them way down in my estimation.

They´re trying to garner sympathy, but my goodness-you´d think that they would apologise & promise to behave in future.

The fact that they haven´t seems to suggest that they either can´t see that what they did wasn´t wrong or that apologising to you isn´t necessary.

WhoseGotMyEyebrows · 25/09/2011 08:45

Kayano Your husband sounds awful imo -

Really? For sticking up for himself for what sounds like the first time in his life, and for sticking up for his wife and their new baby, trying to set boundaries that will benefit his new family? Can't see what's so awful about that.

op I would actually point out the lack of apology.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread