Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want to go to my brother's child's Christening?

35 replies

LifeIsButtercream · 26/08/2011 13:40

Ok - back story - I have a brother who is a few years younger than me, we have never gotten on well, he is (at the risk of sounding one-sided) an aggressive bully. I know 'sibling rivalry' (which my parents had put it down too) is quite normal, but this continued into our twenties, I can honestly say I have never been physically aggressive towards him, but he had on several occasions (when I was home from uni) threatened me and hit me (I once had to barricade mysely into my room), usually if he hadn't had his own way, or mum and dad had refused him money/beers/fags/the use of their car.

My parents often encourage me to 'bridge build', and I have buried the hatchet on numerous occasions only for him to repeat the behaviour. He has also been abusive towards my parents. Lots of bullying behaviour etc.

After an occasion last year I decided enough is enough, I do not want him in my life as I'm not stupid enough to believe that he has 'changed' for the millionth time. We now don't have contact unless we happen to be at my parents at the same time (which I avoid - although my parents sometimes don't tell me that he's there).

Brother has now had a child with his on-off teenage girlfriend. Said child is to be Christened soon, my parents are presuming I'll be attending with DD, I said that we weren't planning on being there, I don't feel that it's appropriate and would be very uncomfortable being there. My parents keep saying that it's a shame, all the family will be there, it's important for DD to see her 'Uncle X' etc. I stress to them that she see's plenty of her family, and I don't call him her 'Uncle', she doesn't know him - I don't want her around someone who thinks it's appropriate to treat people how he does (he has, on a few occasions, not controlled his temper with her around, swearing, slamming doors, threatening and verbal abuse etc).

AIBU to stay away from this event, even though my parents will be annoyed with me for not playing happy families?

OP posts:
porcamiseria · 26/08/2011 15:22

I have this type of shit with my parents about events and stuff, YANBU, dont go

eaglewings · 26/08/2011 15:23

You have thought about it seriously!

If you are not going to have a continued relationship with his baby there is no point in going......then there are all the other reasons, such as his behaviour .......

SouthernFriedTofu · 26/08/2011 15:27

I can't think of any reason for you to go! People will notice is not a valid reason either if your parents use it again. People are not stupid. People will know your brother is a wanker even if they don't know the extent of it. And if someoen does say something good, let your parents or brother explain why you didn't come.

ScaryFairy28 · 26/08/2011 15:30

I had a similar relationship with my sister. I chose to cut her out my life a few years ago, I say don't go and get him out your life.

BurningBridges · 26/08/2011 17:32

I'm going to say don't go as well, in a sort of similar situation, we get cards addressed to our DDs from "Auntie and Uncle" so and so although they have seen them once in their lives - its so they can say they tried to be nice "after all, we sent cards every Christmas and birthday" .... you're in a slightly better position as it looks like your brother doesn't want to know you either, I say bonus all round. Don't go, don't give it another thought.

diddl · 26/08/2011 17:40

"my parents told me I was going the other day, haven't heard from brother"

Only just seen this.

You´re an adult-you don´t have to do what your parents say.

Do wouldn´t have to go even if you had been invited.

diddl · 26/08/2011 17:40

Do???=you.

sausagesandmarmelade · 26/08/2011 18:13

One key decision I made in adult life was that I really didn't have to do anything that I didn't want to do....or be in a situation that made me feel uncomfortable or upset me.

You are not being unreasonable at all. You've made a very grown up decision....which you can stick to.

Hopefully....his behaviour will change in the future and you may be able to have an amicable relationship further down the line. But for now, it really is completely your call!

ShoutyHamster · 26/08/2011 18:19

This is about your parents then, really.

Time to really make things clear to them, I think. Maybe in a letter if it's easier.

Make it clear once and for all that you have made your decision, and it's not come from you, it's come from your brother's behaviour over the years. It's not in your power to change the person he is. Because of that, you have made a decision and it's not something you are going to revisit. You do not want contact with him. You do not consider him family.

Having your DD has made this MORE certain, not less.

Here is where you hit them with it in a way that they cannot misread or mistake - you have NO INTENTION of saddling your daughter with a violent, bullying, aggressive 'uncle'. He is NOT IN HER LIFE AND THAT'S THE WAY IT IS STAYING.

The point of the letter is to ask them, from now on, to respect that decision, adult to adult.

So far, requests have not got through. They are not only failing to respect your decision, they are actually BELITTLING the upset your brother has caused over the years by brushing off your decision. That is hurtful and will, if they keep at it, eventually drive a wedge between you and them, too.

As will constant attempts to get you to change your thinking on this.

They either start respecting you, or they start to alienate you and YOUR family.

Their choice, and they need to make it now. You aren't asking them to take sides. But you ARE asking them to respect your right to live your life as you choose, just as they seem to 'respect' your brother's right to - presumably - continue to be the person he is.

CheshireDing · 26/08/2011 19:06

OP you have not been invited so as far as I would be concerned from that point you would not be going.

Just because you are related to someone anyway if they are of no advantage to your life because they are horrid etc than don't waste your time (similar to what an early poster said).

Your Parents are being silly and need to understand.

I did not invite my Brother to my wedding, nor do I see him because he is horrid, nasty, a lazy git etc etc. Eventually the rest of the family are coming round to not seeing him either but that's their problem if they want to waste their time with him I think.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page