Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"If you were really fit you wouldn't have asthma"

64 replies

giraffesCantChaChaCha · 26/08/2011 06:56

AIBU to think this isn't true? I do think exercise helps - if you are fitter then lungs better so can deal with it easier. But surely if that was a miracle cure it would be "prescribed"? After all it must be cheaper than drugs/hosp admissions/home nebs.

OP posts:
Whatmeworry · 26/08/2011 09:55

Sorry meant to add without using drugs to manage it.

OpinionatedMum · 26/08/2011 10:01

Oh FGS, I wish people would educate themselves before making judgments about other peoples illnesses.

Please google Asthma, print it off, then roll it up and shove it up his ignorant arsehole.

My DD has well controlled asthma and goes to football club after school and dance classes every weekend. If she didn't take her medication she would not be able to. Try dancing when you can't breathe.

eaglewings · 26/08/2011 10:08

Demand your money back and suggest he educates himself before making claims that he can help certain illness. Was ME something he can cure by any chance?

Debs75 · 26/08/2011 10:16

sportstars with asthma

not all people with asthma have exercise induced asthma. i have attacks afre exposure to certain dogs, perfumes, smoke and dust.
People see asthmatics as the little fat kid wheezing in pe but thst is not every asthmatic.
Asthma does not stop you getting truly fit but it can make it harder

SardineQueen · 26/08/2011 10:18

DB has asthma and he is super-fit.

I am not fit and I do not have asthma.

Tell your personal trainer this evidence and that therefore in your opinion exercise causes asthma.

He is a berk.

pamplemousserose · 26/08/2011 10:21

Why have I got to stick my biscuit down my segment? I agree with you rip your throat out

Thistledew · 26/08/2011 10:24

giraffes - sorry, I didn't note your name when I first posted. I hope that you have not had any trips to hospital recently.

If I were you I would think twice about training with someone who is so ignorant about asthma. Of course your trainer's job is to push you as hard as you can go, and to go that little bit further than you think you can, but that has to be done ultra carefully with someone who has asthma. It is horrible to train with someone who does not understand asthma. I joined a group once with a particularly tough instructor. Despite me telling him that I would push myself as hard as I knew I could, but sometimes I just had to drop out and catch my breath, he kept shouting at me to push harder, and not to stop. It did kind of shock him when I followed his instructions onetime, and my lungs closed up so much that with the exertion of coughing I threw up everywhere! Grin Blush.

If you wheeze when you exercise, does the wheeze abate when you rest, or do you continue to wheeze? If you are not confident that it will abate within the time it takes you to return to normal breathing rate, then you will have to be very careful indeed.

Do focus carefully on your breathing whatever exercise you are doing, and try to keep it as slow and regular as possible. Make sure that every breath comes deep from the bottom of your diaphragm. I find that if I am getting wheezy, it really is not possible to breath slowly, as you just need too much force to get the air in and out of your lungs. My method for working around this, and I stress it is something that I have worked out for myself and is not medical advice, is to focus on filling and emptying my lungs as much as I can. If I can't do it slowly, then I do it quickly, but make sure that I pause and hold my breath for a second or two at the end of every inhalation. This stops my breathing getting out of control and stops me hyperventilating, which is when I really get into trouble.

If anyone reading is medically trained, and would like to tell me that this is wrong and there is a better way, I really am all ears!

SardineQueen · 26/08/2011 10:28

I agree with you too pamplemousse piss in your ear

hellhasnofury · 26/08/2011 10:33

Your personal trainer is a twat.

My Dd has asthma but she also competes in swimming and triathlon. She can beat several of her non-asthmatic rivals into a cocked hat. She holds County records for several swimming events. I'd go as far as to say that if she wasn't as fit as she is her astma would be even more severe than it is.

pamplemousserose · 26/08/2011 10:38

Wtf? It was only a biscuit and I am asthmatic, so I no way believe what the OP's personal trainer does. You are just using any excuse to be abusive. Back at you sardinequeen.

sparks · 26/08/2011 10:39

YANBU it's obviously not true. He doesn't know anything about asthma. I would find another trainer if I were you.

sparks · 26/08/2011 10:41

Here is a nice article about elite athletes with asthma.

SardineQueen · 26/08/2011 10:43

pamplemousse i was a joking, because I don't understand why she gave you a biscuit either

Marrow · 26/08/2011 10:51

Sebastian Coe and Bradley Wiggins have asthma too.

HellonHeels · 26/08/2011 10:58

Personally I would rethink having him as a trainer.

Partly because he seems ill informed and therefore not really a suitable person to help you meet your fitness and training goals and partly because you said "I felt a bit Blush when he said that like it was my fault."

I wouldn't want to train with someone who I felt uncomfortable with - why pay good money just to end up feeling bad about yourself?

LaWeasel · 26/08/2011 10:59

He is being very daft.

I only have one trigger for my asthma, unfortunately it's dust which means any sports/exercise in big echoey sports halls and gyms is my kind of hell. Haven't yet found an outdoor exercise as an adult which suits me so fitness is suffering a bit, but I'll get their eventually I'm sure.

ripstheirthroatoutliveupstairs · 26/08/2011 11:03

I was rude to Pamplemousse because she was being dismissive of the OP. Clearly doesn't know her history.

pamplemousserose · 26/08/2011 11:17

But its aibu. Biscuits are allowed. I can't be expected to know every posters' history. I dont have a spreadsheet. As an asthmatic, op posting this pissed me off.

NettoSuperstar · 26/08/2011 11:47

He's a chump.

GalaxyWeaver · 26/08/2011 11:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Pan · 26/08/2011 12:00

rips - you shouldn't have been rude to pamplemousserose. As you say she didn't know of the OP's history. So it was a chance for you to help and educate. Instead you behaved very badly. Go to your room.

pamplemousserose - you're right of course. Biscuits are allowed in AIBU but that doesn't mean you must use one as a first response when you see something you don't like. Now. here is your very own spreadsheet. Later, go and find rips and share the joys of spreadsheets together.

GalaxyWeaver · 26/08/2011 12:00

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

thekidsmom · 26/08/2011 12:05

Wow, makes me angry. But you've all covered that well enough up thread!

Just shows you need naff all medical or physiological qualifications to be a personal trainer. Personally I wouldnt waste my money on someone who obviously has no clue about how the human body works...

SardineQueen · 26/08/2011 12:33

Oh lawks I got confused about who had said what to who.

The OPs personal trainer is an arse and anyone who agrees with him gets a Biscuit IMO.

SardineQueen · 26/08/2011 12:34

If it were me I think I'd look for someone who understood any conditions I had as well. If he doesn't understand asthma then he's not the best person to be training someone with asthma. Especially if he thinks it's their own fault Confused

Swipe left for the next trending thread