Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emotional cruelty from my 4yrs old son....

40 replies

StayHappyMum · 09/08/2011 21:57

My 4 yrs son has just told me that he doesn't like me reading bedtime stories to him and only want his daddy to read stories. I work term time and have been enjoying the summer holidays with him. The days are busy but fun. Today has been a good day - diving, swimming and an arty afternoon, but he was tired and went to bed a little later than usual. We are currently a host family for foreign language students and currently have 2 Chinese girls staying with us. In the chaos of sorting dinner for them, husband returning from work to leave again for an evening meeting and tidying the dishes etc, bedtime got hectic and I was also pretty tired by then. Usually bedtime is a long established routine of two stories and then a cuddle by which time my son has usually fallen asleep, only tonight he started crying that he wanted Daddy to read the story. I was perhaps too quick to respond that Daddy was out as so his only second choice was me so tough - only he then said very clearly that he "only sometimes" likes me to read stories with him and "always" wants Daddy and that he didn't want a cuddle either. I was very taken aback by this and amazed at how much that stung (and is still stinging) so much so that I searched Google for advice and found you.... I'm aware at how petty this sounds but it was very out of character and when he had fallen asleep, which he did very quickly, I stood by his bedroom door for ages just looking at him and feeling a failure. There are times that I'm sure I raise my voice at him too much but I have the awful feeling that my inadequate parenting chickens are already coming home to roost.... I'm hoping (please) that I'll get lots of replies teling me that this is normal boundary-pushing behaviour and he is looking for a reaction and I should stay calm and rational and ignore it but if I'm heading for a fall, any advice would be very gratefully received.... this is my first posting on anything like mumsnet... thank you!

OP posts:
rhetorician · 09/08/2011 22:25

StayHappy ah, you can't do irony in AIBU and expect to get away unscathed. He's normal. And you're doing fine.

squeakytoy · 09/08/2011 22:27

Perfectly normal behaviour Grin

starsandstripes · 09/08/2011 22:29

DS does this all the time sometimes it's mummies team and other times Daddy rules.
We've just turned it into a game now. So I don't take it to heart at all! He has a younger brother so when DS1 is on Daddies team ds2 is on mine and visa versa.

His dad often does the story reading but if he's not home them i'll do it and sometimes he'll ask for Daddy then but i'm just firm and say it's me or no story.

He's with me most of the time so I appreciate he really enjoys story time with Daddy. Plus by bedtime 8pm I just want to choose the quickest books to read and get downstairs to watch Eastenders have some quiet time where as DP will read slower and more books Grin.

We also sometimes get 'I don't love mummy', or 'I don't love daddy', and even I just love mummy but it's mostly I love mummy, daddy. and ds2

Ds is nearly 4.

Beamur · 09/08/2011 22:31

Hope you're feeling a bit cheered up now!
My poor DP has had this from our DD ever since she could speak, at bedtime she is totally Mummys girl and used to take the book out of his hand, give it to me and literally show him the door and ask him to leave. She is a bit more equable with her love now but still wants me to be the one who tucks her in, although she does love a story with Daddy first now.

stillfrazzled · 09/08/2011 22:31

DS1 told me he didn't like me and didn't want to talk to me at 6pm. I'd just advised him that the ladybird in our living room needed to go outside or it would die.

At 6.10pm, right after I'd pressed 'play' for The Gruffalo, he told me he loved me.

AFAIK, what he actually says mirrors how he feels then and there. It does sting a bit sometimes, but he's a creature of the moment and pretty typical for his age, I think.

FreudianSlipper · 09/08/2011 22:34

ds was deep in thought the other day and said to me mummy i love you, aww i said thank you i love you too, he replied i love daddy best Shock

he is 3.10. tomorrow he will love me best (i live in hope)

its not deliberate just at times he wants his daddy more other times it will be mummy he loves you both

worraliberty · 09/08/2011 22:35

It's totally normal and could be something as simple as Daddy reading with more/different expression...or it could simply be 'their special time'

Chances are if his Dad tried to do arty stuff with him, he'd prefer you to do it instead.

lovecat · 09/08/2011 22:39

DD (6) quite cheerfully tells me that 'when' DH and I split up, she's going to go and live with DH and I'll 'be lonely'... if I took it seriously, I'd be wibbling in a corner...

I think she's pushing for a reaction, which of course I don't give her. Just tell her I'll always love her anywhere, which winds her up no end...:o

Welcome to MN :)

lovecat · 09/08/2011 22:39

anywhere? anyway

stillfrazzled · 09/08/2011 22:41

Oh, and often when we come back from a visit to my parents, DS1 informs me that he wants to live with Nana and Grandad. Nowt to do with the spoiling he gets there, of course. Huh.

pictish · 09/08/2011 22:43

It's a back handed compliment - he is so confident of your love for him that he feels quite at liberty to dismiss you. It's normal, and at that age they have scant concept of your emotional wellbeing, which is as it should be.

Man up mama - he doesn't hate you. You're both just fed up and tired.

HerBeX · 09/08/2011 22:43

LOL FreudianSlipper have you heard that episode of Clare in the Community where she tries to elicit the declaration that her son loves Mummy more than Daddy?

I thought of that when I read your post... Grin

HerdOfTinyElephants · 09/08/2011 22:47

Four year olds do not do tact. Even now, at six, the best my DS sometimes manages is "I know that I shouldn't say [insert upsetting thing here], Mummy, because it wouldn't be nice, so I won't" Hmm. Which obviously makes me feel a whole lot better.

blackeyedsusan · 09/08/2011 22:49

normal behaviour. my four year old packed a bag so she could go and live at granny's... and then sat waiting to be taken there. she says I am not her friend any more and she has told me that she doesn't love me (usually when I have told her off) but it is me she shouts for in the middle of the night!

if four year olds want a particular thing they hate anything else that is offered. they are very black and white.

wompoopigeon · 09/08/2011 22:55

You need to carefully translate this. If it were an adult, you would be right to hear and understand it as "I don't want you to cuddle me."

But your DS is not an adult. He is not abusing you. He is speaking four year old-ese. You can translate it as "I am tired and annoyed about these visitors in the house and I want to be in control of something and I want to test whether mummy loves me. And I come out with things which I am feeling."

You can safely stop beating yourself up now. Just try to remember he is not an adult and you need to translate everything he says.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread