Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A bit harsh?

39 replies

silverbullet · 26/02/2011 21:38

Basicly my DB spilit with his dp a few months ago. They have two dc's together (both under 3), Db has the dc's every other day, he works but will have them before and after work.
He always did a lot of the chilcare things when he wasnt at work i.e getting up with the dc's even when he had to get up for work, take over childcare as soon as he got in from work. They didnt have their own place and lived with exp's family due to money issues.
They spilt because db cheated, exp still wants him back tho.
I was friends with his ex when i was younger but sort of out grew her, thought she could be very rude, self centered and judgemental (a view held by our imediate family, neither parents or step parents ever liked her although were never rude etc)
So anyway db's ex has not broke away from our family yet, for example using our extended family to babysit, wanting to talk to family members a lot, ringing db for things that does not involve the dc's, she does have her own family btw, i dont get why she doesnt ask them.
Db does a lot concerning the children, has them loads, pays for them and tbh its not very amicable between them atm because of arguements about anything really.
So aibu to think that exp should be breaking away from our family?

OP posts:
PrincessScrumpy · 26/02/2011 22:44

I think it's fab that she still sees you as her family (whether you like her or not). I know a friend of mine split from her dh and was really upset that she'd lost the friendship she had with his mum.6 years on they bumped into each other and both admitted they missed each other (no kids involved to link them) and now meet up as friends even thought my friend and her ex are now both married to different people.

nenevomito · 26/02/2011 23:40

YABU

Your brother cheated on his partner that he has two children with and you think she's being unreasonable for not breaking away from your family. Sheesh, your family sound lovely. I bet you're all justifying what he did by blaming it on her as well.

If she kept away and didn't involve you with the children she'd be in the wrong as well wouldn't she.

I'm not generally harsh on AIBU but I'd be ashamed of myself if I'd written your OP as you come across as pretty unpleasant.

JoBettany · 26/02/2011 23:51

If the split is quite recent then no doubt she will be in a bit of shock. You mentioned that she didn't want the split and she may feel that keeping your family involved may keep her involved with your DB. In other words, she simply hasn't come to terms with her new 'situation'.

I think you should try to be patient with her and encourage her to remain part of your family. After all it was your brother who cheated.

Things could get 'messy' and it would be horrible if all contact stopped.

pastapestoforgotherpassword · 27/02/2011 00:49

What a horrible op! Yabvvvu keep your nose out of it you nasty piece of work! Your DB cheated on her fgs cut her some fucking slack (am so annoyed by your post its unreal)

BitOfFun · 27/02/2011 00:54

The thing is, it's just more mature and nicer all round if you can all stay friendly and civil.

I regularly get invited to social stuff my DP's ex's family. Because we are grown adults.

Maelstrom · 27/02/2011 00:58

"db's ex has not broke away from our family yet,"

Why should she? she has a child that is part of that family too. Or what? are you expecting her to disappear from the map because they are no longer together?

YABU (and very provincial as well)

helenthemadex · 27/02/2011 00:59

with that sort of attitude Im sure she will realise soon enough that she really should move on, hope for your familys sake you still get to see the children they are your family after all

maybe its that fact that she is actually being so pleasant and keeping you all involved that makes you uncomfortable after all it really does show just how unpleasant your brother is and you dont sound that nice the way you would like her to keep away from you

pinkstarlight · 27/02/2011 01:54

i dont see your problem your family could always say no,have you ever thought maybe shes trying to be a good mum and trying hard to keep a relationship going for her childrens sake with exstended family members.

sunnydelight · 27/02/2011 03:50

YABU. Maybe she will "break away" soon, leave your cheating brother to stew and his bitchy sister to moan and none of you will have contact with your brother's kids again. I guess that will make you happy.

beijingaling · 27/02/2011 05:09

YABU (but you've realized that I think).

My DHs family are still very involved with his ex's life. They babysit, help out if she has a problem around the house, go over for meals, travel together etc. I can't say I loved it in the beginning but I think it's fantastic that the family is still together even though the parents are not. How much worse would it be if you were posting "my DB's ex won't let my parents see her DC's"

agnethafaltskog · 27/02/2011 07:38

Your brother sounds like a real shit, cheating on the mother of his very young children, yet you try to paint him in a good light and her in a bad light.

iscream · 27/02/2011 08:42

Yabvu.

differentnameforthis · 27/02/2011 21:44

She has had your brother's children, no? So therefore they are part of your family.

If your family don't want to help her, they are able to say no. But she has been let down by your brother, and it would be harsh of your family (her children's uncles/aunts/grandparents etc) to start shutting them off.

solooovely · 27/02/2011 22:09

I think it's nice that she is staying close to your family. theya re all still related after all and always will be seeing as there are children involved.

It seems a bit mean wanting her to just go away.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread