Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed with mil wanting ds2 aged 3.3 to have big boy everything

42 replies

Itrymybest · 25/02/2011 21:26

Went round to pil today for tea sil and neice were also coming round. I commented I'd forgotten ds2s booster seat and mil said to ds2 oh you dont want that do you you're a big boy now. Later table was set complete with best china cutlery etc. I said wheres ds2s plates. He has a lovely set that he has always usedwhen visiting pil but mil said no everyone is being treated exactly the same as everybody else he's 3 and a half yrs old he's a big boy now! She repeated this and when I said we dont at home she said well its just aswell he goes to grandmas to be treated like a big boy. He even had normal cutlery. He then struggled with a big spoon that was meant for desert but he used for his dinner. Fil said isnt that a big big for him. Mil said no he's fine and I said yes it is can you get one of his mil told fil no get a tea spoon which he did. Why??

Later ds2 asked for milk. Mil gave it to him in a china cup. Ds2 asked for the bob the buildercup with straw mil said no have that one you're a big boy etc! He refused to drink it.

When we left the table ds2 asked for milk again. Mil said you've not drunk you last milk yet and ds2 asked for bob the builder cup again I could see a tantrum beckoning and I said come on mil he has childrens cups wtih straws at home and with a sigh she finally relented. So aibu to be perplexed and bbemused as why mil wants to treat ds2 as such a "big boy" when he is only 3.3 years old?

OP posts:
Itrymybest · 25/02/2011 22:01

Yes I do know exactly what you mean my ds1 is a september baby and was actually already 5 when he started school last september and I started to move him on with these things even dressing himself wiping him bottom etc etc when he was over 4! Blush Most certainly would not have done that for an august baby!

OP posts:
DorisIsAPinkDragon · 25/02/2011 22:01

I think at 3.3 a booster and childs plate it NOT AT ALL U.

DD2 is 3.6 she has has a junior chair at home she is on the small side but dd1 likes to sit in it aswell given half a chance. She uses smaller cultery as IT IS EASIER for her. DD1 5 also still uses the ikea plates and melamine set for evening meals, I have nice crockery and have no wish to spend more money replacing it! They wouldn't use chine plates at school!! so wtf is she on?

Next time she starts chalenge her directly, ds IS a big boy and is doing things apprpriate FOR HIS AGE!

dexifehatz · 25/02/2011 22:01

Good grief.Any time over 3 yrs is way too old for baby tat.

Beamur · 25/02/2011 22:03

How is giving your child appropriately sized plates and cutlery 'baby tat'?

SeeJaneKick · 25/02/2011 22:04

My DD isn't three yet and se manages with no booster, no special cutlery or plate...she has china and metal like we do.

Maybe MIL thinks you baby him too much. You do sound precious.

Beamur · 25/02/2011 22:05

There are two camps on this issue methinks. Looks like I'm precious too.

Itrymybest · 25/02/2011 22:06

No Beamur he wasnt has never asked for big boy things he loves his sets when ds1 was 4 he started asking for big boy everything but when he was 4 not 3! Found that hard though because I was always accidently giving him too much food which ds1 didnt like tbh. Now he has china childrens set which he loves and a good compromise I think. Dont understand School arguement for plates etc as they are plastic for receptioon children at ds1s school. Also ds2 has never asked for big boy ANYTHING!

OP posts:
SeeJaneKick · 25/02/2011 22:06

Well Beamurthe OP wasn't even satisfied with a teaspoon! And a grown up cup is not tat it s sensible at over three.

As for boosters...well they look fussy and are fussy....let the kid sit down and manage...my child does and as I just said she is not quite three and not advanced.

SeeJaneKick · 25/02/2011 22:08

I also despise the term "Big Boy" He's not big is he? No. He's small....but once yo accept thateven small people should be encouraged to fit into the world at large and they cn still be small it's all a lot easier.

You dont have to rmember booster seats for one!

Itrymybest · 25/02/2011 22:08

and he really struggled with grown up cutlery and made a dreadful mess!

OP posts:
Itrymybest · 25/02/2011 22:09

lol serves her right!

OP posts:
Itrymybest · 25/02/2011 22:11

We use booster seats because he could not reach the table at home otherwise!

OP posts:
SeeJaneKick · 25/02/2011 22:12

Is he smaller than average? I'm not being cheeky or rude...but boh my DDs who are not very tall at all for their ages have had no trouble reaching the table from the age of around 2 and a half.

Beamur · 25/02/2011 22:14

Ok, I'll come off my (slight) huff then. DD has one of those Stokke seats which adjusts to the right height, so not a booster and she does have a china cup (and several plastic ones too..)
Saying all that, DD had a chum round this week which made me think perhaps I have been a bit PFB with her about using the toilet, she still uses a potty if I'm not in the room to put the loo insert in (it doesn't fit well) as I'm a bit concerned about her falling in. But I went in to empty the potty, not realising her friend was still on the loo - and bless her she was sitting on the big toilet with no insert quite happily. I don't think my DD can do that! Or maybe she can, but I haven't let her..

megapixels · 25/02/2011 22:14

Well, we only keep baby things at our house, anywhere else they go they make do with normal stuff. So my DC have never used any kind of special cutlery or booster seats (not even highchairs most of the time) or sippy cups etc. out of the home. Made life very easy for me as I didn't have to carry 20Kg of equipment with me and they learned to use proper stuff very easily.

Maybe your MIL has the same experience and doesn't want to encourage using "baby" stuff. Tbh a 3+ year old shouldn't have to. But I don't think she should have been refusing your son, that just sounds plain mean.

Itrymybest · 25/02/2011 22:15

its a big old fashioned oak table my5 yr old sits on a cushion to sit up to it

OP posts:
Timeforanap · 25/02/2011 22:20

What a shame to deprive your little one of his favourite cup. My DD, aged 9, has a favourite melamine beaker at my parents' house - it is a pretty Cath Kidston one that my mum bought just for her and makes her feel special. Being made to feel special is a good thing in my book.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page