Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in thinking this article is totally crazy?

49 replies

Greythorne · 29/11/2010 13:36

Here's an extract from an article which is published in the PTA magazine which comes from school:

"Should I allow my 10 year old daughter come with me to a scan (I am pregnant with my second child)?

I am pregnant and my oldest daughter is delighted. She would like to come with me when I have my scan. I am hesitating...

ANSWER: You are right to hesitate. And you should refuse to allow her to acompany you. Some parents do agree, and their desire to share this type of life-changing experience is understandable. But they are forgetting that a scan is not place for a child: it is the couple's business. The foetus which is in the mother's stomach [sic] is too intimately related to sex for brothers and sisters to be present at the scan. Even bigger children should not get mixed up in the sexuality of the couple. A little boy will feel that he is his father's equal, especially if he is still in the Oedipal phase. A little girl could feel like she has to take on the maternal role, and could feel responsable for the baby in the future."

I think there are very good reasons NOT to take older kids to a scan (because a scan is first and foremost to bring abnormalities to light, and if that sadly happens, older childen's presence is not desirable) but the reasons outlined here strike me as utterly bonkers.

But I am prepared to be put straight by the MN jury.

FI, we are abroad and the above is a back of the fag packet translation. I live in a country where I feel like I am constantly swimming upstream against mainstream thought because I am forrin. But maybe I read too much into my forrin-ness and all this stuff is completely normal. If so, please do tell me.

OP posts:
Greythorne · 29/11/2010 14:05

winnybella
this article was in the APEL magazine from DD's maternelle.

glad to hear your breastfeeding has been unhindered by comments!

I breastfeed everywhere too, but i have heard some weird choice comments, wwith Freudian overtones. such as, when hearing I am still breastfeeding my DD2 aged 2:

"Ah, je pense qu'elle sera prete a arreter, mais, toi, tu n'es pas encore prete. il faut que tu lance un travail sur toi meme le dessous" Shock

OP posts:
thumbwitch · 29/11/2010 14:06

Nutters. But I immediately thought "probably something to do with Catholicism" (yes, feel free to flame away for me assuming that).
Didn't cross my mind it was to do with Freud!
Still mad as a box of frogs though (bet I'm not allowed to say that either, am I )

Greythorne · 29/11/2010 14:07

la dessous, obviously

OP posts:
classydiva · 29/11/2010 14:08

The answer is nuts and is obviously written by someone wearing a twinset, sitting knitting and pushing on into their 80@s how old fashioned is that!

PrematureEjoculation · 29/11/2010 14:08

sack of badgers.
bag of snakes.
box of frogs.
cheese.

pick-your-own similie.

Ormirian · 29/11/2010 14:10

Oh my lord!

I think they author of that article may have some serious hang-ups Confused

winnybella · 29/11/2010 14:16

Wow. I've got lots of smiles tbh. I'm in Paris-would that make any difference?

But the outdated ideas are still firmly entrenched in society: I've never seen so many kids being spanked/pulled by ear etc as here.

emy72 · 29/11/2010 14:20

It's complete and utter madness!

stickylittlefingers · 29/11/2010 14:22

I was going to say what MadamDeathstare said... You do wonder how they're going to hide all the siblings from each other so they're each safe in the knowledge that their parents only ever had sex that once..Hmm

FreudianFoxSquishedByAPouffe · 29/11/2010 14:22

LOL I do love a bit o' Freud but that's insane.

But I wouldn't take
A child that age to a scan in case of a problem.

lollipopshoes · 29/11/2010 14:23

Bonkers Grin

I wouldn't have an issue with taking dc to a scan - obviously if there were any abnormalities that needed to be talked about they would leave the room but in theory - yup

narkypuffin · 29/11/2010 14:26

AIBU to be a bit pleased that my gcse french still works well enough for me to understand the nasty comment?

SummerRain · 29/11/2010 14:27

mine doesn't Sad

i'm going to have to babelfish it

SummerRain · 29/11/2010 14:30

the ever useful bablefish has come back with this:

'Ah, I think qu' it will be ready has to stop, but, you, you n' do not be yet ready. it is necessary that you launch a work on you same the lower part'

Confused

So i'm still in the dark and a little bit fearful tbh!

PassionKissUnderTheMistletoe · 29/11/2010 14:30

Er - something about still bf-ing when he goes to work??

Translation please!!

hairyfairylights · 29/11/2010 14:33

I think the article's reasons are silly but having been told at a scan that the baby has no heartbeat, then I would never, ever have anyone except my partner there, we were devastated and a small child couldn't deal with those emotions.

show the kid the picture afterwards if all is well.

narkypuffin · 29/11/2010 14:34

I think it's (ish)

I think that she is ready to stop, but you, you're not ready yet. You'll have to start working on yourself (?)

pottonista · 29/11/2010 14:43

Plenty of reasons to not take your children to a scan, but that article is definitely a bit Bear.

TorcherQueenie · 29/11/2010 15:13

Ah, I think it will be ready to stop, but, you, you're not ready yet. you must start work on yourself the following

^ Google translate.

thereistheball · 29/11/2010 15:27

Ha ha, I thought that might be French. I'm here too. I would love to experience this attitude to maternity first-hand but I'll have to get pregnant first.

(Greythorne + Winnybella: fancy joining some other (Paris-based) MNers for lunch on Saturday 11th December? The thread is here)

thefirstMrsDeVere · 29/11/2010 15:27

Do you live on in experimental Amish/Freudian community?

Greythorne · 29/11/2010 23:27

thereistheball
thanks for the invitation. (And you sent me a message, too. Thx!) but I cannot make the 11th. I do want to get in on the meet ups, though, so please keep me in mind. i am in the 92)

OP posts:
winnybella · 29/11/2010 23:40

Thanks, thereisaball- not sure I can make it (DP might be travelling then and I would be looking after DD), but I would also like to meet Parisian MNetters- if anyone fancy a morning in Marche d"Aligre followed by oysters and wine in Baron Rouge/kids' park, do let me know! Am willing to venture out of 12eme as well Grin

GetOrfMoiLand · 29/11/2010 23:44

That is so French in my view.

Where is Bonsoir? She will probably say this normale on all the best arrondissements.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page