Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to talk about The Straw Man Fallacy

52 replies

colditz · 13/11/2010 12:09

Example.
Y "I want everyone to stop buying kittens, and buy puppies instead"

X "I happen to believe that kittens are much nicer than puppies, and I choose to support kittens"

Y "Oh, I suppose you like seeing puppies suffering then? You're one of those people who burns puppies alive and then eats them in a stew, aren't you? You disgust me. You're a disgusting human being. People who are cruel to puppies are often cruel to children - I'm glad I'm not your child."

What Y has done there is set up a Straw Man. Y has decided, in his/her own head, what sort of person X is, and has commented upon this effigy of X, instead of what X has actually said.

I'm seeing a lot of this going on in AIBU and it's lazy debate.

OP posts:
sethstarkaddersmum · 14/11/2010 08:58

OMG, Desiderata, I haven't seen you for ages!

colditz · 14/11/2010 19:32

PMSL at SM

"I don't like it when people use hyperbole to make their point"

SM "That's because you're telling us how to dispute and ocmpose an argument. You got your arse kicked and now you're crying straw man"

Guffaw. Anyone else seeing the irony here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page