Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right I need no nonsense thoughts and advice.

46 replies

shimmerysilverghosty · 25/10/2010 08:37

Will try to keep as short as possible.

Been split with my ex for about a year, he was to put it bluntly, an absolute pig while together. Since he left he has been living in a shared house.

I live in a HA flat, with secure tenancy etc but it is tiny. 2 dc in a two bedroom flat, if we stay here then I will move into the living room with a sofa bed and they will have a room each - have a dd and a ds, one child has SN.

Ex has had a windfall and wants to move out of his shared house either into a flat of his own so he can have dc overnight etc or will pay for me and the dc to move out of our HA flat and he will move back in while we move into a bigger, with a garden private rented house. He says he wants to do this as he does not like the idea of living in a nice flat of his own while we are stuck here. I believe him when he says this, he loves his dc and has always paid child support on the button.

I would like to move but a very worred about moving out of a secure tenancy into private rented, especially in the current climate. We live in a big city and it is not the best, lots of traffic, cramped flat etc, but we do make the best of it, get out a lot and are relatively happy here, we cannot get a move to a bigger place, the wait list is about 8 years. The kids school is ok, not perfect but whose is? Ds is statemented so would be moving with a statement (another worry). I don't have a great support network but a couple of close friends within about half an hours drive. Not really close to my family and of course ex is here and sees and has the dc a fair amount.

My worries is that in the past ex has not been greatly reliable although I would make sure that we move to a place that I can afford alone, he basically would be providing moving costs and whatever deposit we needed. But I have lived in private rented before and it wasn't always a great experience. I would be moving somewhere out of the city as it is far too expensive to live in private rented here. So everything familiar would change.

So what do you think? If you were in this position would you go or hang onto your secure tenancy for dear life? I feel I am being very rushed too as his tenancy has come to an end at his current place so he wants to move asap, we would basically be moving in the next couple of weeks, worrry about this being disruptive for ds although he is on a reduced time table at school as it is, due to SN. I am also really worried that by moving out I am condeming me and dc to a life time of moving to and from rented places etc, while ex sits pretty in the secure tenancy HA flat as I don't think I would ever get him out again once he was back in. It was hard enough to make him leave when the marriage broke down.

Tell me what to dooooooooo please! Not really but any thoughts and advice, this is a huge decision and I need to get it right for sake of dc.

OP posts:
onceamai · 25/10/2010 10:18

Yes. Good luck.

EricNorthmansMistress · 25/10/2010 10:48

That's why I suggest you ask for cash upfront and pretend you are considering it.

Firawla · 25/10/2010 11:06

as everyone else has said i would stay, the security is a very good thing to have

shimmerysilverghosty · 25/10/2010 12:04

Well I just told him I was staying here and he told me that I was a selfish bitch putting my own peace of mind before the welfare of my kids. Apparently I am a "fucking dildo, who has no ambition and will rot in this HA flat", he on the other hand is not prepared to accept being such a "limited person" and will find himself a marvellous place to have kids I can go and fuck myself!

So that was nice to hear and now I am crying my eyes out AGAIN over this abusive wanker. He says he will pay for kids rooms to be decorated but nothing else, I can "live in shit for all he cares" if I choose to be such "a stupid, dumb fucker with no ambition".

So there you go.

Btw I am a carer for my ASD ds and don't work so my options are actually pretty few and I suppose I am "stuck" here.

OP posts:
ccpccp · 25/10/2010 13:30

Ha ha - not the reaction of a man who has had generosity turned down, but the reaction of a man whos plan to get his hands on a secured tenancy has failed :)

Well done on keeping the flat OP. You are sorted so long as you can put up with the limited space.

onceamai · 25/10/2010 13:31

Shimmery - he's just horrid. Anyone who can say that cannot be relied upon. He tried to control you and you have stood up to him and stood up for your future and the future of your dc. He has responded like the typical bully he is although I know that doesn't make it better.

It's a sunny day here - please wipe away the tears and go to the park or somewhere nice and cheap for the afternoon and if the budget stretches treat the dcs to pizza and you to some wine later.

In saying no, you have bought some of your freedom back. You can do so much better than him.

terryble · 25/10/2010 14:40

I have just read through this thread and I am SO thankful you've said no. I also think that he just wants your tenancy for himself. Having security of tenancy is not a minor thing! Especially when you have a statemented child. And promptness with repairs is also worth an awful lot.

MyMamaToldMe · 25/10/2010 14:53

My 1st thought when reading your original post was 'he wants it for himself'. So glad you said no. Please don't change your mind.

frgr · 25/10/2010 15:34

I would not let go of my accommodation if I were you, for all the alarming reasons that people have already suggested. Moving into an unfamiliar area with a much higher risk type of property needs very very careful consideration, pressuring you to move within the next couple of weeks and making a hasty decision would massively affect you if it goes wrong in any way.

Stay put.

frgr · 25/10/2010 15:35

Oh i've just seen there is a page 2, I'm so glad you said No and that his horrible behaviour confirmed the suspicians - he didn't have your own welfare at heart - what a horrible reaction to (a very reasonable) decision on your part.

shimmerysilverghosty · 25/10/2010 15:36

Thanks I know you are right. He has been sending me links to houses all morning on MSN. He says that if he moves into a place on his own here where we live then it will cost him this amount anyway, he would rather spend the money on a nice home for his kids and move into this place. There are no guarantees though, if it doesn't work out where we go, what am I going to do? Come back and say it didn't work out now hop it? He would never go.

OP posts:
FrozenChocolate · 25/10/2010 15:47

That was the right decision. There is so much you can do to maximise space, saving gradually to decorate etc. Being in unsecure accommodation is something you would have had no control over. STAY PUT.

FrozenChocolate · 25/10/2010 15:49

He could rent a cheap two bedroomed place for himself and give you the extra for decoration etc if he really wanted to. He just doesn't want to.

TooImmature2BMum · 25/10/2010 15:56

Definitely the right decision! I don't see why he can't move into a bigger place himself and have the kids over more often. It sounded like a generous offer up front, but his reaction makes it seem much more sinister! Either move himself or else give you the money to put in a savings account for the kids - or put it in a savings account for the kids himself, with the proviso that he does not spend it on crap! Like a trust fund, in the kids' names.

SuePurblybilt · 25/10/2010 18:50

Oh well done, stay strong. What a knob he seems to be. He's just proving why you don't want to be reliant on him really isn't he?

shimmerysilverghosty · 25/10/2010 19:09

Spoke again, now he says he is going to save the money to buy a house in the future, apparently can't even give me any of it to re-decorate as "what is the point when I will be buying you a house in 6 months?" It won't happen, it never does and in mean time our place needs decorating, new carpets and a bed sofa for me Sad. Just have to find a way to do it myself.

Thanks for all your messages, very helpful to read and realise I am doing the right thing.

OP posts:
Hedgeblunder · 25/10/2010 19:28

Shimmery- yup I used to be with a man like this, very charming and then fucking horrible all in a day right? I'm glad you're well rid!
Maybe he could pay for some nice activities for your dc instead like ballet/football/swimming- those can b paid in big chunks so at least you'll both the the kids are benefitting.
I wouldn't trust this man atall and I think your gut reaction is the right one.

Hedgeblunder · 25/10/2010 19:30

And btw- don't let hs comments get to you, you sound like a lovely kind and caring lady. Keep your chin up x

KT1324 · 25/10/2010 19:40

I would Stay put if I was you, are you sure it would be 8 years before they give you something else? I would be on HA back asking for a move. thought they were changing scheme so people could bid on properties?

Lauriefairycake · 25/10/2010 19:43

Stop engaging with him - you have done exactly the right thing - it occurs to me he actually wanted to steal your secured tenancy from you.

Either have the kids share a room or divide the largest between them - cheaply with a curtain if you haven't much money. Or if the living room is large have that as a bedroom - we actually have the smallest room in the house as a tv room.

frgr · 25/10/2010 20:06

Can you imagine what your life would be like if you let him get that control over you, by giving up your secured accommodation and going into private landlord accommodation? I'm so glad that you stuck to your guns on this one Shock

New posts on this thread. Refresh page