Packets of socket covers should make it very clear that they are not a safety product

[duchesse]

My friend told me the other day that if we wanted to be foster parents, we would have to abide by all standard safety rules, including socket covers.

Don't get me wrong, I can totally see the point of stair gates when receiving other people's toddlers into your house- you have no idea what the child's experience of stairs will have been.

But I would be mightily teed off to be obliged to install something in my house that at best does nothing but could at worst create danger.

Manufacturers of these things are less than candid about their dubious benefits, and state institutions (SS, children's centres, etc) seem to be unaware that they are at best unnecessary.

I just think that manufacturers should be obliged to state on the packaging that UK sockets do not need them. AIBU?

RoSPA don't recommend them

We have them all over the house. Assumed you needed them! Why aren't they needed in the UK?

RoSPA discourages the use of decorated covers.

It depends so much on the child too.

Ds1 pretty much avoided sockets and it was never an issue. Ds2 was fascinated no matter how much we tried to keep him away and would happily play with switches and poke stuff into the holes. Got socket covers for that limited time with ds2 as it seemed the lower risk.

At the age of 5 I stuck a wire coat hanger into a socket -not good.

from that RoSPA page (my arrows):

Protective Plastic Covers for 13-amp Socket Outlets

RoSPA recommends that small children are warned to keep away from electrical equipment until they are capable of understanding the risks and are able to use it safely.

-->Modern 13-amp power sockets made to BS 1363:1995 incorporate a shutter mechanism, which prevent inappropriate access to the live connectors. RoSPA therefore does not consider it necessary to recommend the use of socket covers.

How can socket covers create danger?

How do covers create danger?

Mae you would have had to stick 3 coat hangers in the socket - one in each hole- to get a shock.

At least we have boring white ones!

DECORATED

They interfere with the safety already built into the design of our wall sockets, Poogles.

www.fatallyflawed.org.uk/index.html

because the live and neutral cannot open unless the earth pin is fully inserted. It is impossible for a childs fingers to touch anything dangerous unless they have a handy socket cover which can be inserted upside down.................

here - they can undermine an existing safety feature.

I did get a shock but it was the Seventies and it was France so only 2 holes.

This explains it more clearly than I could

Sorry, not sure why the Seventies would be relevant!

Basically they remove the contact covers and expose the live parts of the plug, so if the socket cover is badly designed, it can actually make it easier to poke stuff in there and get electrocuted.

Presumably they stop your toddler shoving something long, pointy and possible metal into a socket and electrocuting themselves?

ROSPA don't say the covers themselves are dangerous, just that they may attract more attention to the sockets. We have them at the insistance of DH but the kids have never really shown in interest in them anyway. We've never had locks on the kitchen cupboards either, even, shock horror, the cleaning cupboard!! Medicines are kept way up high.

It is sort of relevant actually Mae, because modern European sockets have an earth hole as well now. Except they still don't have the same safety mechanism as we do in the UK.

Another person talking sense

UK sockets are designed to be safe and it is very, very difficult for a child to come into contact with any live parts. If you combine them with a modern switch board it is impossible to get a shock even if the child does manage to get through the safety shutter.

No, some of the socket covers DONT prevent something long pointy and metal into a socket - you need to check the position of the prongs compared to the edge of the cover and how flush the cover is.

As I say, we only bothered because ds2 had an unnatural fixation and it seemed the lesser of two evils.

Mae you would have had to stick 3 coat hangers in the socket - one in each hole- to get a shock

Not true actually. you only need to come into contact with the live to get a shock so if the earth pin is inserted or the shutter is damaged then a coat hanger in a socket could easily be lethal. The shutters have only been fitted to sockets for about the last 15 years so if the house is due a rewire then socket covers are a very good idea

A safer option, if you have older sockets, is to replace them with modern sockets.

Ok I'm sold after reading the fatallyflawed website - I'm binning all mine. Read the cover review on the website, it goes through all the different makes of socket covers.