Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know how to handle this situation with my (ex)driving instructor?

26 replies

arses · 16/08/2010 20:13

Yes, I am too old to be learning to drive (mid-30's) and it should never have come to this, but having had my first-born earlier in the year I decided that the time had come to put away childish things which (for me) at the time included a bus pass that was key to a public transport commute to work hat took 50 minutes longer than a car ride would have done.

So, I engaged the services of a driving instructor. At the time that I started lessons with her, I didn't know her other than as a driving instructor although in the weeks after I started we began to come across eachother in the community quite a bit as she has a baby a few months older than mine. Within the space of a few months, we seemed to be showing up at all the same events (e.g. baby groups, Baby massage - don't shoot me!)and we became quite friendly.

This led to quite a lot of nattering in the car. A lot about her MIL, in fact. An awful lot. To the extent that I had to say to her - several times - that when we were doing x, I needed her to be quiet (which, to be fair, when prompted she mostly did). I still had to remind her the week before my driving test as we would be practising manoeuvres while she was mid-rant.

I didn't mind. I suppose part of it was the bored-lonely-housewife type of thing, it was my time out of the house and I probably didn't deal very effectively with the fact that I was paying £40 a pop for 2 hour lessons in which we might only do 3 manoeuvres with all the talking. I told myself that because we were friendly, I felt more confident in the car than I had when I'd tried to learn before and she, in turn, told me it was better not to become too focused on what you were doing as when I was driving in real life I'd have my baby in the car and besides, everyone else that she taught had passed first time despite the talking and the examiner might talk to me on the test etc etc etc.

However, all good things come to an end and
I took the test two weeks ago after 70 hours of driving lessons (I had booked her for lots of lessons in the run up to the test). I failed with 16 faults and 3 serious.

Now, the thing is, I'm not blaming her for failing. Lots of people fail the driving test and I know that I failed because I made a silly error on a manoeuvre that I usually did well but I am annoyed at how she's been with me about it after the test. She had a go at me about her pass rate even though we were nearly late for the test as she decided in the lesson before that she had to wash her car and I was really rattled; after the test, she was really negative about the faults I made saying that it was typical of me to be 'so unfocused' etc... and a little voice in my head is saying: "but I paid you a bloody fortune and yes, I should have worked harder but so should you!"

I decided we needed a break from eachother so I have since had some lessons with someone else in a very covert way (feel like I've been having an affair tbh!).

I've been amazed since I have had these lessons. He has pointed out to me that some of what she was teaching me was just WRONG e.g. she told me you didn't have to put your handbrake on when waiting at a junction as it was bad for fuel efficiency and my new instructor says I got faults for this.. it's been clear to me after a few hours in the car with him that basically I've been throwing money away by having lessons with her as my driving has improved beyond measure in a few short hours of proper lessons with no chit chat.

My new instructor is just so positive and I am making progress every lesson - and he is charging exactly the same as she charged me which she told me was a reduced rate as we 'were friends'! All along, she has been quite negative about my driving and my learning style but to be honest I lapped it up because I was just so desperate to drive that I would have walked over hot coals if she told me to.

Anyway, we're part of a group that meet every Tuesday and Thursday and to be honest, they're the backbone of my week on mat leave re: meeting up with adults in the day. How am I supposed to tell her that I have a new instructor and not sour things with her/with the group?

I'm a bit Hmm that she let me take all those lessons and blamed all my faults on me now that I can see I'm not as slow a learner as she was making out, but I guess I can let that go.. just feel a bit ill at ease with the whole situation and not sure where to go from here.

AIBU to feel this way?

OP posts:
poshsinglemum · 16/08/2010 20:17

I am in a very similar situation to you. I dumped my old driving instructor and have hired someone new. Some of them are negative as they want you to spend as much money as possible on lessons imo.

Tootlesmummy · 16/08/2010 20:18

No, and I'd be bloody pissed off to have spent that money and then failed. As you say it sounds like what she was telling you was wrong and I don't care what she says when you're learning you need quiet to be able to concentrate on what you're doing.

I would just say if it comes up in conversation that you're having lessons with someone else who isn't you're friend as they can give you a hard time that she won't and that you think this style will help you to learn.

Do you still want to be her friend anyway?

Mowgli1970 · 16/08/2010 20:20

Yanbu, you were paying her to teach you, not use you as a sounding board. If it comes up in conversation, I'd say "I hope you're not offended and don't take it personally, but I'm so comfortable with you as a friend (Hmm) that I thought it best to go with another instructor in case it interfered with our friendship!" She probably will see through it, but by the sounds of it, she's no loss!

bobbuild · 16/08/2010 20:22

Wow, how bloody annoying! I'd be really pissed off.
Do you need to tell her that you have a new instructor? Just avoid the topic or , if she asks, say you'd rather not talk about it and change the subject. Be a bit frosty perhaps. You have NO reason to feel embarressed about getting as new instructor; SHE should be the one embarressed for ripping you off and being a crap instructor. Be a bit off with her and refuse to discuss driving. Then one day when she sees you stepping out of a car just say "Yes I passed my test" but offer n o more information. It's none of her business! Though I'd be bloody tempted to complain to whatever body it is that regulates driving instructors, or whatever company it is she works for. Though I can see how you might not want to do this if you still see her every week at the baby group.

arses · 16/08/2010 20:23

That's the thing tootlesmummy, I'm finding it hard to actually admit to myself that she was taking the proverbial with me because I thought we were becoming quite close and we seemed to enjoy eachother's company.. but though I try to spin it that she wasn't, that little voice says: 'but every chat you had, you paid for and she didn't'.

Good advice re: what to say. I think I was just being an idiot, assuming she was being above board with me when I was probably a nice little earner for her who was willing to work around her availability etc (she's not officially gone back after mat leave yet).

OP posts:
KickButtowski · 16/08/2010 20:23

Assuming you still want to be friends with her, I suggest that you tell her openly that you have started to have lessons with someone else. Give as the reason that you feel such good friends with her that you feel it was distracting you from concentrating ie put all the blame on you.

If you can be so magnanamous as to not say anything about the fact that she has ripped you off and let you down then this is probably the best way not to sour things.

elliemental · 16/08/2010 20:24

god how awkward! But you have learned an important lessons about boundaries...
Best of luck with the driving, do as tooltes and mowgli say and keep her a s a 'friend' but pay a professional to teach you to drive.

scurryfunge · 16/08/2010 20:25

I think you will have to accept that she is not very good at her job. If you want to keep the friendship then I would ignore all references to driving and not let it come between you.

Tootlesmummy · 16/08/2010 20:36

I'd suggest go along the lines as I originally and others have suggested re not interfering with your friendship. I'd also be a bit more likely to keep my distance as there is an element of being hacked off that she took your money and used it as her counselling time!

SugarMousePink · 16/08/2010 21:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SugarMousePink · 16/08/2010 21:36

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

macdoodle · 16/08/2010 21:46

YABU!!
And FFS why are you beating round the bush, she took advantage of you, she is not your friend nor a very good driving instructor.
I would either ignore her, or say that you arent very impressed with her professionalism and have gone elsewhere, no great loss either way!

(Just to clarify, you spent 70hrs @ £20/hr = £1400 Shock!!!)

macdoodle · 16/08/2010 21:46

oh bum I meant YANBU, definitely NOT!!

Spacehopper5 · 16/08/2010 21:52

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

arses · 16/08/2010 21:53

Yes, 1400 I do not have. Literally living on peanuts for it.

Thanks for all your responses, I was wondering if I was being too harsh!

OP posts:
wannabesybil · 16/08/2010 21:54

My Great Aunt passed her driving test at 57 and only stopped driving in her 80s (thank goodness! She was a bat out of hell!)

Good luck with the lessons, I am sure you will do fine.

tokyonambu · 16/08/2010 22:19

"she told me you didn't have to put your handbrake on when waiting at a junction as it was bad for fuel efficiency"

What? What? Didn't anything in your head say "how does that work again?" If the car's stationary, how can the handbrake affect the fuel consumption?

arses · 16/08/2010 22:30

tokyonambu, not at all! Never.. Blush Just thought it was one less thing I had to do.

OP posts:
Myleetlepony · 16/08/2010 22:38

Well, your new instructor is talking a lot of bollocks. Putting the handbrake on (after you've come to a halt from the foot brake) will not save you any fuel. If you are on the level, you can either put the handbrake on, or keep your foot on the foot brake, it makes no difference as far as fuel economy goes.
However, if you are on a slight slope, and need to hold the car with the clutch, you will wear your clutch, burn it and reduce it's lifespan.
This is from a mechanic.

Myleetlepony · 16/08/2010 22:44

I meant to say "putting the handbrake on or not" - I wish we had an edit function for a few minutes. Hmm

Mowiol · 16/08/2010 22:46

Tell her you can't afford any more lessons as you had a budget for it which is now all used up and your
husband/mother/sister/brother/ is teaching you. Then when you pass (and rub her nose in it) she will think an amateur was a better teacher than her.

elphiethropp · 16/08/2010 22:48

The new instructor didn;t say it would or wouldn't save fuel from what I've read, just that she would get a fault on a driving test for doing it.

Myleetlepony · 16/08/2010 23:03

You are absolutely right. I am too tired and must stop posting and go to bed. Grin

textpest · 16/08/2010 23:04

You don't get a fault for not using your handbreak at a junction - it is up to the driver which break they use. I never use it and never got faulted for that (took me three times to pass so got faults for lots of other things)

Sounds like you are better off going with what Mowiol says - get to keep your group and keep the peace

Keep going with the driving - I had millions of lessons but it was worth it in the end

tokyonambu · 16/08/2010 23:13

"However, if you are on a slight slope, and need to hold the car with the clutch, you will wear your clutch"

and fail your driving test, and bloody right too. You'll also have fun and games if and when you drive an automatic.