Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is sis being unreasonable?

32 replies

twinklingfairy · 21/07/2010 00:34

Sis has made me feel awful again.

I asked her and fiance to babysit 3 nights this year. Sent them an email months in advance, cos he complained last year that I had given no notice on the one occasion I asked. So thought I had better give more notice this time.
Putting all three dates in one email (one in May, June and July) he said, 'huh, asking a bit much isn't she?'
sis talked him down and made him realise he was being a tw@t.
First time, we had to go out after 9, cos it was friday and she would not give up her scouts for no man, even with months of notice. Second time, she forgot and said that 'she knew nothing about it' So I felt awful, like I had dropped it on them and he would gurn again.
This time I reminded her a week ago, but she didn't respond, so I text again last night and she said 'yes. you have mentioned it a few times' then 'Yes. we remember and will be there.'
Now I feel I am badgering her.

God I hate asking her to do anything like this for me. I feel so indebted to her, and him (she cannot possibly be without him for a night, no he her)
Not to mention that she wanted me for a day, to watch her have her hair and makeup done. DH had to work. So they said 'can one of your friends not take them?'
No!
Told him if she wanted me, HE could surely have them. He made such a fuss. Said he would have them, but at my house, but he had to be out by 1. She would not be finished til at least 3. 'Could one of my friends not come collect them' cos he would not drive them anywhere, or walk them to my friends.

In the end I had to ask my friend to take them for the day. It was just too much hassle and upset.

Am I being unreasonable in thinking that they both make me feel so awkward about asking for help. To the point I don't want to.
And yet, she will say 'I never see the kids' 'We will help you out anytime we can'

What and then make it as difficult for me as they can so that I feel awful in putting them both out?? And do not want to go ut anymore.
Then they will say, your marriage is struggling cos you don't go out as a couple often enough (ok, they said that last year, when we were floundering).

OP posts:
GetOrfMoiLand · 21/07/2010 14:04

You want you sis to babysit and plan her life in advance to do so.

However she asks you to spend one day with her and you state 'I could easily do without a day in siss company'.

What a lovely attitude you have

porcamiseria · 21/07/2010 14:14

dont ask her to babysit anymore, find someone else!

twinklingfairy · 21/07/2010 14:42

yeah, that sentence does sound harsh, but honestly she is very draining and demanding.
DH had to work that day and I was made to feel like my children were unwanted baggage that were simply a hinderance to my sisters plan for what she wanted me to do that day.
It felt as if I were being asked to just get rid
This was after she had to collect her dress, about a 2hr trip. I said I would go with her, did not like to think she would do it alone, but that I would have to bring the children. She said, 'I would rather go alone then.' I can understand this. DS is a wee terror But when it came to this day of pampering and they were quick to assume I could just offload them onto a friend?

Can anyone see where I am coming from?

OP posts:
twinklingfairy · 21/07/2010 14:52

What is unreasonable about asking her fiance to look after the children so that I can spend the day with her?
I have 2 children, she does not want to see them at these occasions, who would at a makeup trial, but there is no getting around the fact that I have them and would assume that her fiance would be able to help in order that I can go with sis to her trail?
In the end he did not help and I did ask a friend and I did go with her for the day.

what is me me me me about that?
It is the children and the dismissing of them that I am upset about!

I don't like being away from them. Don't especially want to go out 1 night a month, but DH had a work thing, a wedding dance and so do I.

3 nights in 3 months it may be, but sis knows that that is the end of it and certainly not the norm. I am not going out just to the local pub. We have been given invitations to other do's but I turned them down so that I wasn't taking the mickey out of sis.
That is unfair

OP posts:
MrsC2010 · 21/07/2010 15:51

It appears some of us disagree, which would answer your question I think?

worldgonemad72 · 21/07/2010 19:04

Both my sisters are like this, my dd is now 9, they always say i'll look after her/have her stay over. In all the 9 years neither one has actually looked after her, ive asked a couple of times esp when i was single and both always made excuses. YANBU she offered you gave her plenty of notice, if she didn't want to why bother to offer in the 1st place.

traceybath · 21/07/2010 19:10

Agree with GOML.

If her fiance doesn't have children I can quite understand him not wanting to look after yours alone especially if your DS is a 'terror'.

And you know I have 3 dc's but wouldn't take them on a long journey to collect dress/go to hairdressers etc - wouldn't be fun for anyone.

If I were you I'd find a babysitter and just let your sister spend time with your dc's when you're around.

How old are they by the way?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread