Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Feeding horses, specifically other people's

45 replies

TheTecknician · 10/10/2025 11:31

First of all, I know this activity is frowned upon and can unfortunately be harmful or even fatal to horses and ponies. It's not something I do but I confess to not fully understanding the harm that can be caused. I know grass clippings are bad news but what about 'traditional' horsey treats like sugar lumps, Polos, apples, pears, carrots and so on. In what way are these not good?

Thankyou.

OP posts:
Uuiyo · 10/10/2025 12:49

Don’t feed any animal that isn’t yours, even “traditional” things unless you have permission, they can be on special diets, they can not do well with certain foods, it can be too much sugar etc.

DiscoBob · 10/10/2025 12:49

Of course feeding sweets and sugar lumps is bad for any animal? You mustn't need an explanation as to why.

Would you feed a dog haribo or a cat tic tacs? Assuming they'd eat them, you just wouldn't even try surely? Because common sense.

Animals eat natural things or food specifically designed for their species.

WibbleyPie · 10/10/2025 12:52

People are cross because they've had vets bills, dead horses or hours/days/weeks watching an animal suffer and usually because people won't listen, or assume the horse owner is being precious, are rich and above themselves and so want to show them by feeding the horse anyway, with absolutely no knowledge about a horse's biology or digestive system, just that the horse likes an apple, or a polo or a sugar lump and the person likes the feeling of giving it to them, so it must be all good.
I caught someone trying to feed my horse a pineapple once, and got told to fuck off because I'm a posh cunt when I asked them not to. I've also had people trying to sit their kids on my elderly, retired horse who was patient and kind, but having someone sat on him was uncomfortable and hurt, even a small child, confirmed by vet diagnosis and x-rays, he was living out his days in as much luxury as I could provide him, just being a horse, but someone with no knowledge or permission did that to him, having scaled 2 fences laden with private property signs, and then told me how awful I am for advocating for him by telling them to stop, not to mention the threats of burning the farm down. Would you not be angry and frustrated at that happening repeatedly?

If you're truly interested then think about the areas wild horses still inhabit, I'm not being sarcastic here, but are there any polo or sugar lump trees in the wilds of America where herds of wild Mustangs live?

It's a harsh environment, as is just about anywhere a horse has developed and thrived, Shetland ponies or Welsh Mountain ponies, Dartmoor, Exmoor, for example - sparse land that requires hours of roaming to provide the same level of sugar in a day that a packet of polos or a bag of apples contain, and there's competition for high value sugar laden foods like apples or anything like that that grows naturally, for a start there's 30-40 horses in one herd eating it, rather than 5 or 6 in a field, there's other animals competing for it and it's only available for a short amount of time, so in order to get enough to see them through winter to spring when there's more food, they will eat whatever they can get hold of - because it's rare, they'll still do that when presented with a high value food source, even though they (should) be getting everything they need from the person looking after them, because that's how they've evolved and survived.

Horses getting too much sugar is the other side to the coin of not getting enough, both are bad and lead to problems for the horse, and it's a delicate balance.

And that's just the nutritional side of things, horses have digestive systems that have evolved to eat small amounts almost constantly, large amounts or bulky food causes problems because it messes with that, they can choke and horses can't be sick in the same way other mammals can to rid themselves of excess food, or something that they can't digest or is making them ill, so it clogs the gut up or is absorbed where is goes on to cause more problems.

Then there's the behaviour it causes as they compete for a food source because their evolution tells them they need it.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

CharlieKirkRIP · 10/10/2025 12:55

Blahdiblahblahr · 10/10/2025 12:28

Wow someone got out of the wrong side of bed this morning!

She just asked a simple question.

Many people born and raised in cities don’t know what you might consider basic things about animals because we don’t come in contact with them.

Ignorance is no excuse.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-derbyshire-11964087.amp

https://www.horseandhound.co.uk/news/devastation-much-loved-pony-dies-after-public-feeding-882819

https://www.itv.com/news/central/2021-02-19/lady-issues-warning-as-pet-horse-dies-from-eating-mince-pies-and-sausage-rolls?fbclid=IwZnRzaANV0rBleHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHr35UrJl4bpaSjcHXbGZ7N983GJpzgFC2Tox87TDWi416e3DvXeQJrg57bql_aem_ucRArE_1XrGLUgKgJpp-pA

https://www.wiltsglosstandard.co.uk/news/19148958.pony-dies-being-fed-kitchen-scraps-stranger-field/

https://www.itv.com/news/wales/2023-11-27/rare-horse-and-unborn-foal-killed-by-kindness-of-ignorant-stranger

https://www.horseandhound.co.uk/news/ive-lost-my-sunshine-owner-of-pony-killed-by-public-feeding-speaks-out-on-the-lasting-impact-739934

It’s not just horses that these ignoramuses are feeding, where I live a reindeer was also killed by stupid people a few years ago

https://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/reindeer-belonging-christmas-tree-farm-19185400.amp

Devastation as much-loved pony dies after public feeding

The owner of a Shetland who died after he was fed chestnuts by a member of the public said he was loved by all those who knew him – and should have had many happy years ahead. Zoe Mullins’ nine-year-old Reggie died in his owners’ arms at the end of las...

https://www.horseandhound.co.uk/news/devastation-much-loved-pony-dies-after-public-feeding-882819

NoctuaAthene · 10/10/2025 13:16

I honestly believe some people do genuinely think the countryside has been put there as some kind of amusement park for them and their children. I don't think the idea of ownership and leaving things that aren't yours alone even enters some of their heads. Right after people have crossed the footpath with the horses in it I mentioned earlier, they come out into a farmyard belonging to the owner of the fields/livery yard, where there's lots of farm machinery parked, including a couple of big tractors, a baler, thresher and so on - obviously this is highly exciting to little kids particularly the tractors and so, so many people proceed to let their kids climb all over the machinery, lift their kids up into the cab to 'drive' the tractor, take pictures etc. Literally no thought that (a) farm machinery isn't a toy and might be dangerous (b) it belongs to the farmer, just because it's adjacent to a public right of way doesn't make it a free playground. I get it, obviously a tractor is an inanimate object so 'they're not doing any harm' but that's not the point, it's not yours! Leave it alone! Even if it's a one in a thousand chance that your precious darling kicks and hits a lever they shouldn't or damages something, why should the farmer carry that risk?

I had an interesting insight when I was chatting to my very townie BIL about this, and he sighed and said 'look I get what you mean but if you say no to a toddler they'll tantrum and if you can avoid that by letting them have a go and no-one was watching I'd probably let them' and I was all 😯😯 of course you deal with your child's tantrum rather than risk damaging someone else's property! I just don't get why it would be different because it's a farm - if you saw a fire engine or something on a city street surely you wouldn't think your child is entitled or it's a good idea to 'give them a go' - or maybe people really would?

Danioyellow · 10/10/2025 13:39

twistyizzy · 10/10/2025 12:27

Because to me you joking about feeding my horse something which could kill it isn't funny.
It's shits and giggles to you whereas to me it's the very real possibility of losing one of the most precious things in my life plus the cost of multiple Ks of vets bills and countless hours of lost sleep and stress.

Sorry but no one joked about killing your horse anymore than they did about killing mine. You must work so hard to take everything out of context 😂

twistyizzy · 10/10/2025 13:53

Danioyellow · 10/10/2025 13:39

Sorry but no one joked about killing your horse anymore than they did about killing mine. You must work so hard to take everything out of context 😂

You inferred "what's wrong with it" and that it was "woke".
Just don't write facetious things if you don't want them to be misconstrued.

Springersrock · 10/10/2025 14:36

People are cross because they've had vets bills, dead horses or hours/days/weeks watching an animal suffer and usually because people won't listen, or assume the horse owner is being precious, are rich and above themselves and so want to show them by feeding the horse anyway, with absolutely no knowledge about a horse's biology or digestive system, just that the horse likes an apple, or a polo or a sugar lump and the person likes the feeling of giving it to them, so it must be all good.

I totally agree. I’ve moved my girls now to a tiny private yard so haven’t had too much of an issue this year, but in the past we’ve had a nightmare with people feeding them, climbing in their fields, even entering the yard and interfering with them in their stables. I’ve had people taking down electric fences, climbing over locked gates, telling me to fuck off when I’ve politely asked them to stop feeding my horses McDonald’s, I’ve caught parents lifting their children onto my horses (one of which is retired due to arthritis) backs to take photos and being called stuck up when I’ve asked people to stop trespassing on private property.

It does make me angry and I just think, they’re not yours, just leave them the fuck alone, but I have found I’ve had more success if I talk directly to the child concerned - “please don’t feed my horse that apple/sausage roll/whatever, unfortunately it may make her sick/give her a tummy ache”.

I mean, it shouldn’t matter why I’ve asked you to pack it in. They’re my horses, if I don’t want you to do whatever thing it is I’ve told you to stop doing, just stop. No arguments, no why, no ifs buts or maybes. They’re not yours, you don’t pay their vet bills or feed bills or livery bills, or insurance premiums, I do and half the time I still get told to fuck off, but I find the kids to be more responsive to a bit of education than the adults.

Spanador · 10/10/2025 15:10

twistyizzy · 10/10/2025 13:53

You inferred "what's wrong with it" and that it was "woke".
Just don't write facetious things if you don't want them to be misconstrued.

Not to defend them but it was a different poster who said that, they were just responding to your reply

NoctuaAthene · 10/10/2025 15:13

Springersrock · 10/10/2025 14:36

People are cross because they've had vets bills, dead horses or hours/days/weeks watching an animal suffer and usually because people won't listen, or assume the horse owner is being precious, are rich and above themselves and so want to show them by feeding the horse anyway, with absolutely no knowledge about a horse's biology or digestive system, just that the horse likes an apple, or a polo or a sugar lump and the person likes the feeling of giving it to them, so it must be all good.

I totally agree. I’ve moved my girls now to a tiny private yard so haven’t had too much of an issue this year, but in the past we’ve had a nightmare with people feeding them, climbing in their fields, even entering the yard and interfering with them in their stables. I’ve had people taking down electric fences, climbing over locked gates, telling me to fuck off when I’ve politely asked them to stop feeding my horses McDonald’s, I’ve caught parents lifting their children onto my horses (one of which is retired due to arthritis) backs to take photos and being called stuck up when I’ve asked people to stop trespassing on private property.

It does make me angry and I just think, they’re not yours, just leave them the fuck alone, but I have found I’ve had more success if I talk directly to the child concerned - “please don’t feed my horse that apple/sausage roll/whatever, unfortunately it may make her sick/give her a tummy ache”.

I mean, it shouldn’t matter why I’ve asked you to pack it in. They’re my horses, if I don’t want you to do whatever thing it is I’ve told you to stop doing, just stop. No arguments, no why, no ifs buts or maybes. They’re not yours, you don’t pay their vet bills or feed bills or livery bills, or insurance premiums, I do and half the time I still get told to fuck off, but I find the kids to be more responsive to a bit of education than the adults.

Agreed. I completely get the anger and panic as a horse owner you feel when we hear these dreadful stories of horses dieing after being fed by members of the public. A horse in your care coming to harm through something like that is just the nightmare scenario. But in my unfortunately extensive experience of getting people to leave my horses alone, getting really angry or talking in very emotive terms isn't particularly helpful. I've tried pretty much everything and the most reliably effective method is a simple, polite but clear request 'Please do not touch or feed the horses', in my experience that stops about 95+% of the bad behaviour, and I've come to the conclusion the remaining people basically just can't be stopped at all whatever you do, shouting angrily about killing the horses doesn't work, big long explanations all about the special needs and diets and life histories of the horses doesn't work, CCTV doesn't work, saying the horses are dangerous doesn't work, saying your child could die doesn't work. Sad fact but that's how it is - if possible you can put physical barriers in place (not possible in some of our fields with public rights of way going through them) or limit the horses you put where or if you can move to a more secluded/private grazing (good luck with that round our way!).

Fiftyandme · 10/10/2025 15:15

You do not know the horse. You do not know its conditions for example allergies.

It’s not your horse.

Do not feed other peoples animals.

Fiftyandme · 10/10/2025 15:16

And if I catch you feeding my horse - you’ll be billed for any resulting vets bills.

The serious cheek of some people.

Needtosoundoffandbreathe · 10/10/2025 15:16

There's this wonderful thing called the internet. Why don't you just Google or even ask AI OP?

Fiftyandme · 10/10/2025 15:18

NoctuaAthene · 10/10/2025 15:13

Agreed. I completely get the anger and panic as a horse owner you feel when we hear these dreadful stories of horses dieing after being fed by members of the public. A horse in your care coming to harm through something like that is just the nightmare scenario. But in my unfortunately extensive experience of getting people to leave my horses alone, getting really angry or talking in very emotive terms isn't particularly helpful. I've tried pretty much everything and the most reliably effective method is a simple, polite but clear request 'Please do not touch or feed the horses', in my experience that stops about 95+% of the bad behaviour, and I've come to the conclusion the remaining people basically just can't be stopped at all whatever you do, shouting angrily about killing the horses doesn't work, big long explanations all about the special needs and diets and life histories of the horses doesn't work, CCTV doesn't work, saying the horses are dangerous doesn't work, saying your child could die doesn't work. Sad fact but that's how it is - if possible you can put physical barriers in place (not possible in some of our fields with public rights of way going through them) or limit the horses you put where or if you can move to a more secluded/private grazing (good luck with that round our way!).

Yup. That’s been my experience. I’ve had people arguing all kinds of shit on menu they know better, or why they should be allowed to feed my horse/ sit their sodding child on my horse.

They'd soon be screaming blue murder if they/their children was hurt by my horse.

You can’t argue with Stupid, unfortunately

Fiftyandme · 10/10/2025 15:20

TheTecknician · 10/10/2025 11:39

This is what I'm asking about. Asking leads to knowledge. Failure to do so leads to ignorance.

There's some cross posters here today!

Cross at your ignorance, yes. No means no, you’re not a 5 year old, you don’t need to know ‘why’

user1471538283 · 10/10/2025 15:37

I know nothing about horses but we've never fed them because I don't know what they should/can eat and horses have got big teeth. We've only ever chatted to them from a distance unless my DS was at the riding school when he was small. Most horses fields around here have a sign to not feed them.

Serencwtch · 10/10/2025 15:41

A horse on a livery yard I was at got kicked when they were fighting to get a treat offered over the fence.
The horses injuries resulted in several thousand pounds worth of vet bills and the horse was eventually put to sleep due to the injuries.

I wouldn't feed my own horses treats over the fence or in the field.

It's basic respect for the animals & basic respect of other people's property.

Danioyellow · 10/10/2025 15:41

twistyizzy · 10/10/2025 13:53

You inferred "what's wrong with it" and that it was "woke".
Just don't write facetious things if you don't want them to be misconstrued.

You’ve got that wrong too. Who are you even talking to at this point as that wasn’t me. Take chill pill 😎

twistyizzy · 10/10/2025 15:43

Danioyellow · 10/10/2025 15:41

You’ve got that wrong too. Who are you even talking to at this point as that wasn’t me. Take chill pill 😎

Apologies bloody quoting function mis-quoted you! It was indeed another poster

Scrope · 10/10/2025 16:52

TheTecknician · 10/10/2025 11:52

Thankyou for the most recent sensible, measured, informative and POLITE replies.

When it would have been perfectly possible to google for similar information, or to search out the several lengthy previous threads there have been on here about feeding other people's horses.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page