Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Mindsets around feedback or advice

3 replies

Squarestones · 07/07/2025 13:53

Interested in perspectives on times when you get unsolicited feedback from people - in work or not.

I'm very very bad at taking any kind of negative or even semi-negative feedback, I perceive it all as criticism even when it's more of a critique. I find criticism in statements or offers of help which are not meant to be negative. I recently read about rejection sensitivity dysphoria and it's me to a tee though am not formally diagnosed with anything.

In a work context I can cope (usually). Mainly I work very hard and get very anxious in the process to make sure any feedback I get is positive. In my closest relationships we either have understandings, explicit or otherwise, about productive and counterproductive ways to approach these kind of conversations, or I know that they love me so I can eventually rationalise feelings of rejection if we have a tough conversation.

This weekend I led a part of a service at our church due to leadership changes meaning different people getting involved. I've never done that role in that context, though am used to public speaking and doing other things at church. It was a big service, with lots of guests there for baptisms. Should emphasise I know that leading in a service is not about the person but the spiritual side and that's what I had tried to focus on leading up to it.

After the service I was speaking to two women I know in the congregation, I think one was in a bad mood due to something else, and she chipped in suddenly with "you need to slow down next time, I saw people who didn't understand what you were saying"

I do tend to speak fast when nervous, so I acknowledged that and said I'd try and slow down next time, for sure. I always really try to be slow when reading stuff, but this was sort of ad lib and I can speed up with that.

She said "I just think people like to have feedback" to which I smiled and nodded but inwardly thought "really? some people might but not everyone and really isn't this more about you asserting some kind of power or judgement?"

Later in the day my DH said he thought I wasn't speaking especially fast, but even if I was, is the right time to mention it straight afterwards?

It was a minor discussion, but had definitely triggered my fear of criticism and rejection, and various other issues around being expected to volunteer for lots of stuff at church. It also made me think - are there people who actually enjoy giving other people random feedback, who think it's a kindness to offer it? Does it cross their mind that it might be damaging to just drop something in like that, putting someone on the spot, rather than putting it in a more suitable context?

And on the other hand if you're someone who would have just accepted that and moved on, how does that work in your mind? I want to be in that place!

OP posts:
SailingWonder · 07/07/2025 23:19

She thinks people like to have feedback? I bet if you’d given her feedback on how you didn’t appreciate her comment, you’d have found out exactly how much she likes receiving feedback herself!

ByLimeAnt · 07/07/2025 23:30

This is a really interesting post OP.

I was very lucky. When I was 30 I started a job in a specific profession (which I had qualified for five years previously).

However, the context was very different so we were essentially trained from ground zero. My God, the training was brutal. Constant feedback, and i do mean constant. Exams, role play, vivas.

IF you passed you were very heavily audited. The audit never actually stopped, but was less frequent unless you screwed up and then it would likely be 100% again.

And I'm so grateful for that experience. I am now absolutely bomb proof with negative feedback and actually prefer it as I think it steers my practice more. I solicit it a lot!!

NOTE: During this time I went through a lot of tissues and rang my mum a lot.

OP, a tool I love is a 360 degree review. Would that be a possibility for you, even informally?

Squarestones · 08/07/2025 17:35

Thanks both, I feel like your comments illustrate exactly what I was thinking, that people have such different attitudes to feedback!
@SailingWonder I agree she might not have welcomed my honest thoughts on her comments, I'm so cautious about feedback when ever I give it because I assume that people might find it uncomfortable.
@ByLimeAnt that sounds both tough and useful, as you say! I can just about manage feedback at work because i can rationalise it (mostly/with time) and remove it from my sense of worth. In one particular area of my work I was used to having seniors review work and I still have my work checked by peers so I'm better in that area at seeing it all as a way to improve rather than a form of rejection.
What I find hardest is feedback in this kind of semi-personal or informal context, where I take it very personally and either react with anger or by feeling worthless.
I've never had 360 feedback, my company is too small for it really, but i think I'd find it interesting. Maybe leaning into feedback is how to improve my reaction to it, getting used to it in the way I'm used to it for one specific part of my work

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread