Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What would you do if the only houses you can afford are in "bad" areas? Buy or wait?

55 replies

Lostfirsttimebuyer · 17/02/2025 14:15

I am 30 and have started househunting around Leeds for my first home.

My issue is that I recently moved to Leeds for my dream job and I have realised over the last few months of househunting that the only houses within my £240k budget are all in “rough” areas, that I keep being warned off living in. I had hoped that people were being overdramatic, but I have visited these areas on house viewings and haven’t felt like I would feel safe as a woman living alone.

My background:

  • Buying on my own. I earn 50k. Single. No kids.
  • My budget is approx £240k (I have £25k for a deposit, an extra £10k for solicitors & moving expenses and a £215k mortgage in principle).

My non-negotiables:

  • I cannot drive for medical reasons, so need to live in a place within train/walk/bus of Leeds city centre.
  • I don’t want to buy a flat (I have concerns about leasehold properties with their unregulated potential for service charges to soar and the difficulty of reselling leaseholds - I would not be happy to be a landlord if the flat was unable to sell, so don’t want to risk getting into that position)
  • I don’t want to move outside of Yorkshire or change my job because I moved to Yorkshire specifically for this dream job - I have spent my entire career working my way up to get this job!

What would you do if you were me?
A. Buy a house in a bad area and grit my teeth through feeling unsafe for 5 years until I build up enough equity to buy in a nicer area (or meet a partner I suppose).

B. Keep renting and wait a few years to have a slightly bigger budget.
However, I am not convinced that my salary or savings will increase in line with house prices. There is potential for a promotion from £50k now to £65k in 3 years time and then potential for a further promotion 3 years after that. I could also probably save an extra £30k over the next 3 years. So that means I’d potentially be able to borrow £60k more due to that increase in salary, and have extra £30k on my deposit- so my budget would maybe stretch to £330k in 3 years time. But £330k is the price of the houses in not-rough areas at the moment! In 3 years time, those houses will have risen in price won’t they and I will still be priced out of them, and in the same situation but 3 years later, won’t I?

C. Wait to find a partner who will buy with me?
Seems a bit Disney princess to pin my living situation on waiting for a partner to come along, but yet sometimes I think if I just had a partner right now, we could have a £500k budget and not have to worry about all of this. But of course I have no real control in when a partner may come along and that could take years.

D. Continue to attempt to try and find a house in an area that isn’t rough, that perhaps is cheaper due to a long commute to Leeds?
It would need to still be commutable by train though as I cannot drive for medical reasons, and so I am really struggling to find anywhere and I am not sure if this is a dead end.
(If you’re from around West Yorkshire, ideas of places? Harehills, Seacroft, Beeston, Holbeck, Chapeltown are all places I haven't felt safe in and have been warned off. I’ve looked at houses in Headingley, Hyde Park Meanwood, but have heard so many stories of burglaries - I think I might have felt safe as a student in a house of 5, but don’t feel safe as a woman living alone. I have heard people say Garsforth and Woodlesford as places that are cheaper than Leeds itself, commutable by train and nice, but I am struggling to find more than 1 house in my budget there.)

E. Something I haven’t thought of?

OP posts:
newrubylane · 17/02/2025 17:36

It does depend on how long you're willing to commute, but there are definitely options. I used to commute by public transport from a nice part of Wakefield not on a trainline - five minute walk to a bus stop, ten minutes on the bus to the train station, then fifteen minutes on the train and you're in central Leeds. I had a fifteen minute walk at the other end all in all it used to take me about an hour. I didn't find it particularly difficult, I've had longer commutes since.

SoapySponge · 17/02/2025 18:43

When we first got married in South London, there were areas so rough and downmarket we refused even to look at them. They were:
Herne Hill
East Dulwich
Wandsworth/Clapham borders
Brixton.

Buy in a rough area. If those places can get gentrified, anywhere can.

PaintDecisions · 17/02/2025 18:51

Crossgates is OK

I found this property on the Rightmove Android app and wanted you to see it: www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/87055809

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Meadowfinch · 17/02/2025 18:52

I bought a scruffy house in a less desirable area, redecorated throughout, sorted the garden, and moved after three years.

The increase in value allowed me to move to a better area. It took most of my weekends but it was the quickest and least financially risky way to build the extra equity.

There is always the chance that the area will improve while you are there, and you choose to stay.

KaitlynFairchild · 17/02/2025 19:01

Can definitely recommend Horsforth - unless things have changed a lot recently, it's very quiet, safe, and as long as you like reading, being on the end of the bus route is fine - you'll always get a seat.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page