Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

How medical advice differs in other countries. (Lighthearted but perplexing)

381 replies

KnopkaPixie · 23/12/2024 13:16

The other day I was behind a woman in the queue at a pharmacy here in France. She had oral thrush. The pharmacist took quite a while talking to her about her treatment and the various medications she'd been given by the doctor then went into the general advice section of the lecture. The most important thing was not to eat, "Trop salé." (Too salty.)

I thought, "Pardon?" Surely it's the other way around, nothing too sugary and yeasty? It bothered me so I googled and sure enough at least in the English results - sugary and yeasty were to be avoided.

This happens all the time. I've heard an awful lot of strange medical advice in France over the years and the folk remedies of my Russian ex boyfriend for various illnesses were quite bizarre too. Putting your head over the boiling potato water to cure a cold because the vitamin c evaporated into the steam was a good one.

Have you ever been given strange medical advice abroad?

This thread is kind of inspired by the post about the Germans opening their windows all the time for "Luften"

On the other hand, if you're not a Brit, what are our bizarre medical beliefs/practices?

OP posts:
KnopkaPixie · 23/12/2024 17:18

Not foreign advice but I was told by Tawny Owl at Brownies not to sit with my back to the radiator in the church hall because it would cause untold harm. My back would be warmer than my front causing an inbalance in the system and possible instantaneous human combustion. (Or something.)

OP posts:
LochKatrine · 23/12/2024 17:18

When I was in East Germany I had a bad cold and lost my voice. My host made a concoction of sugar and raw onions...it worked! I've used it since.

LochKatrine · 23/12/2024 17:18

KnopkaPixie · 23/12/2024 17:18

Not foreign advice but I was told by Tawny Owl at Brownies not to sit with my back to the radiator in the church hall because it would cause untold harm. My back would be warmer than my front causing an inbalance in the system and possible instantaneous human combustion. (Or something.)

Perhaps your humours would become unbalanced!

Flicitytricity · 23/12/2024 17:21

Ohnonotmeagain · 23/12/2024 15:34

Evidence based medicine. It’s not hard to understand.

deaths from overdose dramatically dropped when the pack size restrictions were brought in. It’s well studied and the data is freely available. It also saves the nhs ££££££ in intensive care beds treating post overdose liver failure.

yes you can go round multiple pharmacies, but you need to be pretty intent on you plan to kill yourself and obtain enough to do it. That is relatively rare.

That's actually heartening to read, thank you.
I must admit to being quite sneery about the restrictions, so great to hear its had an effect!

LoyalCrab · 23/12/2024 17:22

Or running it under the cold tap! 🤣

KnopkaPixie · 23/12/2024 17:23

LochKatrine · 23/12/2024 17:18

Perhaps your humours would become unbalanced!

That radiator was the only thing keeping me going in that freezing cold hall. I think she suspected me of not being a team player in the coconut ice making ritual, er activity.

OP posts:
FuckItItsFine · 23/12/2024 17:23

LochKatrine · 23/12/2024 17:18

When I was in East Germany I had a bad cold and lost my voice. My host made a concoction of sugar and raw onions...it worked! I've used it since.

My mum (Scottish not German) swears by this!

LochKatrine · 23/12/2024 17:25

FuckItItsFine · 23/12/2024 17:23

My mum (Scottish not German) swears by this!

That's interesting! I'd never come across it before.

LochKatrine · 23/12/2024 17:26

KnopkaPixie · 23/12/2024 17:23

That radiator was the only thing keeping me going in that freezing cold hall. I think she suspected me of not being a team player in the coconut ice making ritual, er activity.

Ahhh, that sounds like the real reason!

Flicitytricity · 23/12/2024 17:26

I was prescribed Guiness by my surgeon when I was dreadfully constipated after surgery.
Took a good few pints, and I was very 'happy' when it took effect.
This was UK, not sure how widely prescribed Guiness is🤣

Fizbosshoes · 23/12/2024 17:30

BeyondMyWits · 23/12/2024 16:49

Ex mid-day supervisor here... NEVER underestimate the power of a wet paper towel. 😄

When DD was a toddler she walked straight into a table in John Lewis and whacked her head really hard, but didnt cry. The staff straight away called a first aider who came running in with a bag but all he used on her head was a wet paper towel and the swelling went down, after about 10 min. I was quite astonished by the power of the humble paper towel !!

A few years later DS banged his head (he was 20 months) and got a huge lump like an egg. He screamed the place down , I tried to put a wet flannel or kitchen roll and he was literally fighting me off, and wasn't having any of it. Although by the next day the lump had subsided somewhat.

KnopkaPixie · 23/12/2024 17:31

Flicitytricity · 23/12/2024 17:26

I was prescribed Guiness by my surgeon when I was dreadfully constipated after surgery.
Took a good few pints, and I was very 'happy' when it took effect.
This was UK, not sure how widely prescribed Guiness is🤣

A common remedy for horses with colic used to be Guinness. It would stop the eyes rolling around in the head whilst you walked the poor animal up and down the yard, (Eyes in the horse, I mean) and then shortly afterwards you would be rewarded with a steaming pile of grassy plop.

You could always have a nip yourself.

OP posts:
TheBoots · 23/12/2024 17:33

isthismylifenow · 23/12/2024 13:54

I don't live in the UK but have spent some time there. No matter what is wrong with you, if you visit the dr you will have a virus. No more information than that.

Kid can have chicken pox - Ah yes it's a virus
Flu/upper airway/pnuemonia - Ah a virus

Why not just give a proper diagnosis rather than that general term.

But chicken pox is caused by a virus! What more information do you want? It's the varicella-zoster virus.
Flu is also a virus. As are most upper resp infections and yes, pneumonia. What possible other diagnosis do you want? If you have a bacterial infection do you ask for the species name of the bacterium?

Sunshineandoranges · 23/12/2024 17:34

How do you use teabags ..I am 8n 7k and have never heard of this. Use them dry..soaked in cold water…?..

RafaFan · 23/12/2024 17:35

In Nova Scotia grandmothers advise that if your toddler's got a cold you should rub Vicks into their feet and put socks on them before putting them to bed.

Sunshineandoranges · 23/12/2024 17:35

In uk

BarMonaco · 23/12/2024 17:35

In the UK advice is to only keep rice for 24 hours in the fridge, whereas in some other countries its longer.

Flicitytricity · 23/12/2024 17:36

KnopkaPixie · 23/12/2024 17:31

A common remedy for horses with colic used to be Guinness. It would stop the eyes rolling around in the head whilst you walked the poor animal up and down the yard, (Eyes in the horse, I mean) and then shortly afterwards you would be rewarded with a steaming pile of grassy plop.

You could always have a nip yourself.

Good God, if it works for horses, it must be good stuff!
I bloody hate hate Guiness, but I necked it down on her advice, and God bless her🤣

Abra1t · 23/12/2024 17:37

Squeekey · 23/12/2024 14:48

Maybe not quite so lighthearted as people get very passionate about the subject, but weaning.

The UK recommends 6 months, most of Europe start at 4m. Given that health differences between these countries are pretty small, it seems bonkers how much each group criticise the other.

Want to start at 4m - it's probably what you'd do in France or Spain or Italy, so crack on.
Want to wait until 6m - that's the official advice here, crack on.

(I was a 4m weaner to reduce allergy risks but I think the almost religious fervour about this subject is nuts).

Article in the Times (or possibly the Sunday Times) this weekend on this very subject, saying that allergy specialists believe six months is too late.

I mean, pushing weaning back two months hasn't exactly been a roaring success in reducing allergies and intolerances, has it!

Bodeganights · 23/12/2024 17:38

charlieinthehaystack · 23/12/2024 17:01

for cold sores I get a used cooled of course tea bag and put on the sore area works a treat. I try to do it when i get the first tingle and it works well

Any tea like green or peppermint ? Or your more general Yorkshire, tetley's?

CulturalNomad · 23/12/2024 17:38

flat ginger ale. It used to be a standard post noro thing, plain crisps and a flat fizzy drink

This was my mother's "go to" treatment for everything from nausea to flu to all childhood illnesses😂

If nothing else it helps to get fluids in when plain water is just unappetizing.

WaryCrow · 23/12/2024 17:39

LochKatrine · 23/12/2024 17:18

When I was in East Germany I had a bad cold and lost my voice. My host made a concoction of sugar and raw onions...it worked! I've used it since.

Garlic honey is also a thing, and doesn’t taste as bad as you think. Thyme honey is downright nice.

At this rate I need to change my username to GarlicCuresAll😁

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 23/12/2024 17:40

Re: fizzy drinks and recovery , when I was young everyone had a bottle of Lucozade to ‘ aid recovery’.

Fennel is aniseed related ( both umbellifers); in the Mediterranean countries aniseed based drinks are used to aid digestion as both aperitif (Pernod, Ricard) and after meal digestif ( ouzo, brizard etc) . Even in Marrakech in a highly Islamic phase, raki was permitted. And even recommended.

I think gripe water contains fennel, and also ginger which has a carminative effect ( prescribed for painful menstruation in the Middle Ages, but only for the rich).

KnopkaPixie · 23/12/2024 17:42

Flicitytricity · 23/12/2024 17:36

Good God, if it works for horses, it must be good stuff!
I bloody hate hate Guiness, but I necked it down on her advice, and God bless her🤣

And there was/is a proprietry hoof salve called cornuscresine that really made their hooves grow fast and their manes and tails if they'd rubbed them off.

It would probably work on humans as a hair restorer/nail grower as well but it has the consistency of black tar so not the most aesthethically pleasing look whilst in the process.

OP posts:
nervousnellylikesjaffacakes · 23/12/2024 17:45

LuckyBea · 23/12/2024 13:26

I think it's weird how in the US, pregnant women have so many unnecessary vaginal exams (seems like at every check up in the final months!). These exams serve no good actual purpose.

I've had 2 babies and nobody medical has ever even asked to see my nethers (2 ELCS), apart from to place a urinary catheter each time!

Never mind their inhumane maternity leave policies over there...

This isn’t true. I’ve had two in the US and I’ve only been naked waist down for the 6 week scan when a trans abdominal ultrasound wouldn’t work, and for the pre birth strep test.